US 2.0: Win Hearts, Then Minds

    To achieve social change, it is crucial to consider different perspectives and strategies, even if they may seem contradictory, in order to have a meaningful impact.

    enFebruary 05, 2024

    About this Episode

    There's a saying that's attributed to the Dalai Lama: in the practice of tolerance, one's enemy is the best teacher. It's a nice idea, but in reality, when people don't share our values, it's hard for us to tolerate theirs. This week, we talk with sociologist Robb Willer about the common mistakes we make in trying to persuade others of our point of view — and how we can break out of our echo chambers.

    Did you catch last week's kick-off to our US 2.0 series? You can find it in this podcast feed, and here


    🔑 Key Takeaways

    • Tolerating and understanding our political opponents, rather than resorting to name-calling, can lead to productive conversations and potential change.
    • Seeing conflicts from others' perspective helps build understanding and find peaceful resolutions.
    • Understanding that everyone has their own subjective view can lead to more empathy and open-mindedness, enabling us to gain a deeper understanding of others and foster productive conversations.
    • Engaging in empathetic conversations and respecting different perspectives is crucial for building bridges and creating meaningful change.
    • Understanding others' viewpoints and finding common ground through respectful dialogue is essential for productive and meaningful conversations.
    • Effective persuasion involves understanding others' perspectives, finding common ground, and engaging in dialogue to respectfully consider their viewpoints.
    • To persuade others, show respect, find common ground, and construct arguments that align with their values, while keeping emotions in check and understanding their perspective.
    • By understanding and empathizing with others' moral values and emotions, we can effectively communicate our message and potentially change perspectives, leading to constructive resolutions.
    • Peaceful and nonviolent resistance is more effective in garnering support for a cause, as extreme activist tactics can lead to negative reactions and disidentification from the activists.
    • By aligning arguments with the moral values of the audience, we can create more persuasive and effective discussions, bridging divides and fostering productive conversations.
    • To achieve social change, it is crucial to consider different perspectives and strategies, even if they may seem contradictory, in order to have a meaningful impact.
    • Choosing empathy and civility in frustrating situations can lead to positive outcomes and reciprocity, avoiding unnecessary conflict and fostering kindness.

    📝 Podcast Summary

    Effective Communication: Moving Beyond Shouting Matches on Social Media

    Engaging in shouting matches on social media platforms like Twitter is not an effective way to communicate and persuade others with different viewpoints. Instead of having meaningful conversations and finding common ground, people often resort to name-calling and yelling at each other from their own echo chambers. The key to bridging these divides lies in tolerating and understanding our political opponents, even if we don't agree with them. We need to recognize that they may have different values and perspectives, rather than labeling them as close-minded or immoral. By practicing tolerance and open-mindedness, we can foster productive conversations and potentially change hearts and minds.

    The power of empathy in resolving conflicts

    Stepping into someone else's shoes and seeing a conflict from their perspective can be a revelatory experience. Robb Willer's assignment to write about a conflict from his roommate's perspective allowed him to realize how differently the same situation could be interpreted. This exercise enabled Robb to empathize with his roommate and understand that his own actions might have been provocative. It's easy to get caught up in our own emotions and righteousness during conflicts, but taking the time to authentically consider the other person's viewpoint can lead to a deeper understanding and resolution. By embracing the other person's perspective, we can break the cycle of self-defeating behavior and work towards a more peaceful resolution.

    The Importance of Recognizing Subjective Views

    Our subjective view of the world is natural and deeply ingrained in us. When we engage in disagreements or arguments, we often believe that the other person has it completely wrong. This is because our perspective feels real and valid to us. However, it's important to recognize that everyone holds their own subjective view as well. Understanding this can help us approach disagreements with more empathy and open-mindedness. By stepping out of our own perspective and trying to see things from someone else's point of view, we can access different information and gain a deeper understanding of their experiences and beliefs. This is the first step to changing someone else's mind and fostering productive conversations.

    The limitations of using logic and facts in persuasive debate and the value of understanding diverse viewpoints.

    Engaging in passionate debate and arguing based on logic and facts may not always be effective in convincing others of your perspective. While this approach may have been rewarded in high school debate and may demonstrate passion and dedication to a neutral judge, it often falls flat when trying to persuade opponents. Additionally, focusing solely on strengthening your own argument without understanding others' perspectives can limit your ability to empathize and find common ground. This realization occurred to Robb Willer when he was a union organizer, where he had to engage in conversations with people from diverse backgrounds and ideologies. It taught him the importance of understanding and respecting different viewpoints in order to build bridges and create meaningful change.

    Navigating diverse perspectives for meaningful conversations.

    Having productive conversations and achieving understanding often requires entering different headspaces and considering different perspectives. In the first scenario, Robb had to adapt his approach and engage in a conversation from a Marxist perspective to connect with the young woman and ultimately win her support for the union. This experience highlighted the importance of understanding others' viewpoints and finding common ground. Similarly, in the second scenario, Robb encountered a math graduate student who held a conservative stance due to uncertainty about the outcomes of unionization. Rather than arguing, Robb carefully discussed the reasons for and against unionization, showing the significance of respectful dialogue and addressing individual concerns. These experiences demonstrate that meaningful conversations involve navigating diverse perspectives to find shared understanding.

    The Power of Inclusive Persuasion

    Effective persuasion involves not just winning a debate, but actually changing someone's behavior. Robb Willer, a union organizer, learned that the key to persuasion is being inclusive and understanding of others' perspectives. He realized that his goal was not to convince people to join the union for his reasons, but rather to meet them where they were and find common ground. By building a bridge of empathy and understanding, Robb was able to have productive conversations and make connections with others. He discovered that it was important to listen and engage in dialogue, rather than simply talking at people. Ultimately, the takeaway is that successful persuasion involves finding ways to connect with others and respectfully consider their perspectives.

    Building connections and open-mindedness for effective conversations.

    Establishing basic respect and emotional connection is crucial for productive conversations. It is important to show intellectual humility and be open to persuasion instead of shutting down opposing views. When we care passionately about something, it becomes difficult to see the perspective of others. We tend to assume that everyone has access to the same information as us, forgetting that different experiences shape their views. Moreover, our opponents' beliefs are influenced by unconscious drives and motivations. If we want to persuade someone, we should avoid making arguments that challenge their deeply held moral values. Instead, finding common ground and constructing arguments that align with their values can be more effective. Additionally, when we feel passionately about something, it is essential to downregulate emotional reactions and try to understand the other person's perspective for successful persuasion.

    The Power of Moral Humility and Empathy in Persuasion

    When trying to persuade others, it is crucial to understand and empathize with their moral values and emotions. Simply trying to force our own opinions onto others is ineffective and can even create animosity. Moral humility and empathy are key factors in successful persuasion. We must recognize that people who think differently from us have legitimate feelings and perspectives, even if we don't agree with them. By connecting with others on a deeper level and understanding their concerns and values, we can more effectively communicate our own message and potentially change hearts and minds. It is important to bypass our own biases and focus on truly understanding and connecting with others for constructive resolutions.

    The Impact of Activist Tactics on Public Perception

    Extreme activist tactics, such as violence or derogatory language, often lead to negative reactions from observers. These tactics can make people view the activists as less moral and disidentify with them. As a result, observers are not influenced by the activists and may even turn away from the cause they support. On the other hand, when activists engage in peaceful and nonviolent resistance, the reaction is much more positive. People are more likely to listen to their message and be open to their cause. This research suggests that it's not necessarily the cause itself that people reject, but the methods used by the activists. This creates a dilemma for activists who may believe that extreme tactics are more persuasive, but in reality, they can be counterproductive.

    Persuading through moral reframing.

    When trying to persuade others, it is important to reframe arguments in terms of the moral values of the people you are speaking with. This strategy, known as moral reframing, involves transcending your own perspective and considering the values of the recipient. By doing so, you can create more persuasive arguments that resonate with individuals from different political or ideological backgrounds. For example, when advocating for same-sex marriage to conservatives, presenting arguments rooted in patriotism and loyalty was found to be more effective in reducing polarization and increasing support. Similarly, when discussing increased military spending with liberals, focusing on themes of equality and social justice helped to make the argument more compelling. By understanding and tapping into the moral values of others, we can bridge divides and foster more productive conversations.

    Understanding Persuasion and Social Change for Effective Tactics

    Robb Willer's research on persuasion and social change can generate pushback from those who feel passionately about their own beliefs and causes. However, Willer's motivation is not to criticize or police activists, but rather to understand the most effective tactics for achieving social change. This motivation led him to conduct studies on argument strategies that could persuade liberals to support high levels of military spending. Additionally, Willer's personal experience of misplacing his car and finding it in a rundown impound lot highlights the unpredictability and complexity of real-life situations. Overall, this takeaway emphasizes the importance of considering different perspectives, tactics, and strategies in our efforts to effect positive social change.

    The Power of Maintaining Composure and Treating Others with Decency

    Maintaining composure and treating others with decency can lead to positive outcomes even in frustrating situations. When faced with a hefty fee for his impounded car, Robb could have easily lashed out in anger, but he decided to hold back and consider the perspective of the person behind the bulletproof glass. This restraint allowed him to connect with the person on the other side who then helped him find a solution to his dilemma. By resisting the temptation to join the majority who react negatively in such situations, Robb not only avoided unnecessary conflict but also experienced reciprocity and kindness in return. This anecdote highlights the power of choosing empathy and civility even when faced with adversity.

    Recent Episodes from Hidden Brain

    The Curious Science of Cravings

    The Curious Science of Cravings

    We've all had those days when all we want is a little treat. Maybe it's a bag of chips, an ice cream sundae or a glass of wine. But sometimes, these desires become all-consuming. This week on the show, psychiatrist Judson Brewer helps us understand the science of cravings, and how we should respond to them. 

    If you liked today's conversation, be sure to check out other Hidden Brain episodes about ways to regain a feeling of control over your life: Creatures of Habit and Taking Control of Your Time.

    Hidden Brain
    enApril 15, 2024

    What Is Normal?

    What Is Normal?

    Anthropologist Tom Pearson was devastated after his daughter Michaela was diagnosed with Down syndrome. When he began to examine that emotional response, he found himself wrestling with questions that have roiled his field for decades. Early anthropologists would often compare people of different backgrounds and abilities, asking questions like: How is one group different from another? Which one is stronger or smarter? And how do we understand people who don’t fit our expectations? This week, we talk with Pearson about his family’s story, and the evolution of our thinking on disability and difference.

    If you liked today's show, be sure to check out these classic Hidden Brain episodes:

    "Emma, Carrie, Vivian"

    "Why You're Smarter than You Think"


    Hidden Brain
    enApril 08, 2024

    The Transformative Ideas of Daniel Kahneman

    The Transformative Ideas of Daniel Kahneman

    If you've ever taken an economics class, you were probably taught that people are rational. But about 50 years ago, the psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky began to chip away at this basic assumption. In doing so, they transformed our understanding of human behavior. This week, we remember Kahneman, who recently died at the age of 90, by revisiting our 2018 and 2021 conversations with him. 

    If you enjoyed this look at the work of Daniel Kahneman, you might also enjoy our conversations about behavioral economics with Kahneman's friend and collaborator Richard Thaler: 

    Misbehaving with Richard Thaler 

    Follow the Anomalies 

    Hidden Brain
    enApril 01, 2024

    Are You Listening?

    Are You Listening?

    Have you ever sat across from your spouse, colleague or friend and realized that while they may be hearing what you're saying, they aren't actually listening? Poor listening can lead to arguments, hurt feelings, and fractured relationships. But the good news is that active, thoughtful listening can profoundly benefit both people in the conversation. This week on the show, psychologist Guy Itzchakov helps us understand where interactions go awry, and how to become a more attentive listener. 

    For more of our work on how to better connect with the people in your life, check out these episodes:

     Why Conversations Go Wrong with Deborah Tannen

    A Secret Source of Connection with Amit Kumar

    Relationships 2.0: What Makes Relationships Thrive with Harry Reis

    Relationships 2.0: How to Keep Conflict from Spiraling with Julia Minson 


    Hidden Brain
    enMarch 25, 2024

    The Ventilator

    The Ventilator

    Many of us believe we know how we’d choose to die. We have a sense of how we’d respond to a diagnosis of an incurable illness. This week, we revisit a 2019 episode featuring one family’s decades-long conversation about dying. What they found is that the people we are when death is far in the distance may not be the people we become when death is near.

    If you enjoyed today's episode, here are some more classic Hidden Brain episodes you might like:

    The Cowboy Philosopher

    When You Need It To Be True 

    Me, Myself, and Ikea 

    Thanks for listening! 

    Hidden Brain
    enMarch 18, 2024

    Escaping the Matrix

    Escaping the Matrix

    A little more than a decade ago, researchers began tracking an alarming trend: a dramatic uptick in anxiety and depression among young Americans. Psychologist Jonathan Haidt, like many other researchers, says the increase is related to our use of social media and devices. But he believes it’s also deeper than that — connected to our deepest moral beliefs and how they shape the way we view the world. He says there are simple steps we can take to improve the mental health of kids growing up in the smartphone era.

    For more of our work on how technology is shaping our lives, check out our two-part series "The Paradox of Pleasure" and "The Path to Enough."  And don't miss our classic episode on social media, "Screaming into the Void."

    Hidden Brain
    enMarch 11, 2024

    Fear Less

    Fear Less

    Fear is a normal and healthy response to things that may harm us. But fear can also hold us back from doing the things we want to do. This week, we talk to psychiatrist and neuroscientist Arash Javanbakht about the psychology of fear — how it helps us, how it hurts us, and what we can do to harness it.

    For more on the science of fear and anxiety, including how you can overcome it, check out our episode A Better Way to Worry.


    Hidden Brain
    enMarch 04, 2024

    US 2.0: Lincoln's Dilemma

    US 2.0: Lincoln's Dilemma

    Over the past few weeks, we've been exploring the psychology of partisanship, and how to effectively handle disagreements with those around us. This week, we conclude our US 2.0 series by turning to the past. We talk with journalist Steve Inskeep about how one of the most important leaders in American history — Abraham Lincoln — grappled with the pressing moral question of his time. When, if ever, is it worth compromising your own principles for the sake of greater progress?

    If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to check out our 2018 conversation about Thomas Jefferson with historian Annette Gordon-Reed. It's the episode called "A Founding Contradiction" in this podcast feed, or you can listen on our website.  

    Hidden Brain
    enFebruary 26, 2024

    US 2.0: Not at the Dinner Table

    US 2.0: Not at the Dinner Table

    We typically divide the country into two distinct groups: Democrats and Republicans. But what if the real political divide in our country isn’t between “left” and “right”? What if it’s between those who care intensely about politics, and those who don’t? This week, we bring you a favorite 2020 conversation with political scientist Yanna Krupnikov, who offers an alternative way to understand Americans’ political views.

    For more of our reporting on the intersection between politics and psychology, check out our episode about political hobbyism. You might also like this classic episode about how we come to our political values and beliefs. Thanks for listening! 

    Hidden Brain
    enFebruary 19, 2024

    US 2.0: Living With Our Differences

    US 2.0: Living With Our Differences

    Conflicts are inevitable — both at a global scale and in our personal lives. This week, in the latest in our US 2.0 series, psychologist Peter Coleman explains how minor disagreements turn into major rifts, and how we can defuse even the most salient of disputes in our lives.

    Interested in learning more?

    For additional ideas about how to keep conflict from spiraling, check out our conversation with researcher Julia Minson. And for a look at how violence shapes political outcomes on a global scale, be sure to listen to our interview with political scientist Erica Chenoweth.