How Your Expectations Can Change Your Life

    Changing our mindset on stress and aging can lead to improved well-being, reduced long-term effects of anxiety, increased lifespan, and enhanced performance and personal growth.

    enMay 18, 2022

    About this Episode

    During World War II, Henry Beecher, an anesthesiologist serving in the U.S. Army, noticed that 32% of the soldiers he treated for horrific battle wounds felt no pain. A further 44% experienced only slight or mild discomfort, despite the fact they had shrapnel embedded in their bodies. Beecher hypothesized that the euphoria of surviving battle resulted in the release of a natural painkiller. When morphine was running low in Europe, Beecher thought he could harness the mind’s seeming ability to produce natural painkillers in a different way by injecting soldiers who were about to undergo surgery with a simple saline solution, while telling the soldiers they were receiving morphine. About 90% of these patients underwent the surgery with little or no pain.

    Beecher’s field-expedient placebo treatments would go on to open up decades of research into the power of our expectations. On today’s show, my guest will walk us through that fascinating research, and how the connection between the body and the mind is a lot stronger and wilder than we know.

    His name is David Robson and he’s an award-winning science writer and the author of The Expectation Effect: How Your Mindset Can Change Your World. David and I begin our conversation with how and why the brain operates as a prediction machine, and how the expectations it generates can shape the reality we experience. We then discuss how even when someone’s pain or condition is very real, the placebo effect can have an equally real effect on their physiology — even when people know they’re taking a placebo. We also get into the “nocebo effect,” where your expectation that a drug will have negative side effects, in fact produces those side effects. From there we turn to how the expectation effect has powerful results beyond the medical world, and shows up in the areas of sleep, diet, and fitness, including how thinking of doing chores as exercise actually increases the health benefits of that activity, how reframing your anxiety can turn it into a performance-enhancing boost, and how your perception of getting older hugely affects how you will actually physically and mentally age.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With David Robson

    🔑 Key Takeaways

    • Our expectations have a profound influence on our experiences and physiology, including the ability to reduce pain, improve health, enhance performance, and influence aging.
    • Our brain uses predictions to process the world and prioritize important information, shaping our perception of reality based on context and previous experiences.
    • Our brains are prediction machines that help us navigate the world and our beliefs and expectations can have a tangible impact on our bodies, influencing our overall well-being.
    • The placebo effect can provide significant benefits in various medical conditions, showcasing the mind's influence on our well-being.
    • The placebo effect is becoming more potent, posing challenges for drug approval. Open-label placebos, despite being known as inert, can still produce positive outcomes and are being considered for addressing opioid addiction.
    • Our expectations and beliefs can affect our pain levels, so managing our thoughts and reducing anxiety can help alleviate chronic pain and improve overall well-being.
    • Our thoughts and beliefs have a significant impact on physical symptoms. Adopting a positive mindset and managing negative thought patterns can help alleviate pain and improve sleep.
    • Health and fitness tracking devices and genetic tests can provide valuable information but may also lead to false expectations and anxiety. It's important to recognize their limitations and not let them dictate our perception and motivation for exercise.
    • By changing our perception of everyday tasks and meals, we can enhance physical fitness, nutrient absorption, and hormonal response, leading to better exercise and diet outcomes.
    • 32 Words
    • Changing our mindset on stress and aging can lead to improved well-being, reduced long-term effects of anxiety, increased lifespan, and enhanced performance and personal growth.
    • Cultivating a positive outlook on aging is crucial for maintaining physical and mental well-being, as it can help us make healthier choices and reduce stress, ultimately leading to a longer, more fulfilling life.
    • Our expectations can become a self-fulfilling prophecy, so it's important to recognize their influence and actively shape them to lead fulfilling lives.

    📝 Podcast Summary

    Discover the Mind-Body Connection: How Our Expectations Shape Our Reality

    Our expectations and mindset have a profound impact on our experiences and physiology. Henry Beecher's field expedient placebo treatments during World War II shed light on the power of our expectations in reducing pain and discomfort. This led to decades of research into the mind-body connection and the placebo effect. Even when someone's pain or condition is real, the placebo effect can still produce real physiological changes. On the other hand, the nocebo effect demonstrates that negative expectations can actually manifest negative side effects. Our minds operate as prediction machines, shaping our reality based on our expectations. This understanding extends beyond the medical world and affects various areas of our lives, including sleep, diet, and fitness. By harnessing the power of our expectations, we can enhance performance, improve health, and influence how we age physically and mentally.

    Discover how your brain creates your own version of reality!

    Our brain operates as a prediction machine, constantly forming simulations of the world around us to make sense of sensory data. These simulations are based on the context of our surroundings and previous experiences. By tidying up and processing sensory data, the brain constructs a version of reality that is shaped by its predictions. This prediction machine also influences our physiological responses and prepares us for action. Factors such as emotions, social interactions, culture, and information from doctors all contribute to the calibration of these simulations. While there may be some error in the brain's predictions, it is still the most efficient way for our brain to process the world and focus on the most important information.

    Discover the Power of Brain Predictions and Boost Your Well-being!

    Our brains are prediction machines that help us navigate the world and deal with ambiguity. By relying on our past experiences and making predictions about what will happen next, our brains help us adapt and be more flexible. Even if our predictions turn out to be incorrect, there can still be benefits to being cautious. This is demonstrated through the placebo effect, where a fake treatment can actually have objective outcomes on our physiology. The placebo effect can result in physiological changes such as increased levels of natural painkillers and reductions in inflammation. It shows that our beliefs and expectations can have a tangible impact on our bodies. So, being open to the power of our brain's predictions can actually be beneficial for our overall well-being.

    You won't believe how even fake treatments can heal you!

    The placebo effect can still have profound results even when people know they are taking a fake treatment. This concept of open-label placebos has been studied and shown to be effective in various medical situations, such as chronic pain, inflammatory bowel syndrome, fatigue, and allergies. The ritual of receiving treatments and the feeling of being taken care of can trigger physiological benefits, including reducing inflammation. Conditioning, where previous treatments have conditioned the brain to produce its own painkillers, also plays a role in the placebo effect. The more invasive the placebo intervention, such as injections or sham surgeries, the stronger the placebo effect tends to be. This highlights the power of the mind in influencing our well-being.

    The Surprising Power of Placebos: Why They're Getting Stronger

    The placebo effect plays a significant role in various medical treatments, including surgical procedures and drug trials. It has been observed that the placebo effect is getting stronger over time, making it more challenging for drugs to get approved by regulatory authorities. One possible explanation for this phenomenon is the increasing knowledge of the mind-body connection and the media coverage surrounding the placebo effect. Interestingly, studies have shown that open-label placebos, where patients are aware that they are taking placebos, can still yield positive results. While prescribing placebos raises ethical concerns, some doctors have admitted to using them in their practice. Furthermore, there is growing excitement around using open-label placebos to address issues like opioid addiction.

    Discover the shocking truth about the power of your mind!

    Our expectations and beliefs can have a significant impact on our pain and physical experiences. The placebo effect, where patients experience pain relief from a fake treatment, and the nocebo effect, where negative expectations create real symptoms, demonstrate the power of our minds in influencing our physiological responses. This means that the warnings and suggestions we receive about medications or conditions can actually shape our reality, resulting in either positive or negative outcomes. Understanding the potential of the nocebo effect can help individuals with chronic pain by recognizing and challenging catastrophic thoughts that amplify their pain. By managing their expectations and reducing anxiety, individuals may be able to alleviate some of their pain and improve their overall well-being.

    Discover how your thoughts can worsen pain and insomnia!

    Our thoughts and beliefs can have a significant impact on our physical symptoms, including pain and insomnia. The nocebo effect, which is the negative counterpart of the placebo effect, can amplify our perception of pain and worsen symptoms. Conversely, adopting a more objective and positive mindset can help manage and alleviate symptoms. Cognitive behavioral therapy, similar to what is used for depression and anxiety, can be effective in addressing these negative thought patterns. Additionally, our expectations about sleep can influence how we feel the next day. Those who expect to suffer from sleep loss are more likely to experience negative effects, while those with a positive attitude can mitigate the effects of disturbed sleep. Ultimately, understanding the power of our thoughts and expectations can help us better manage our health and well-being.

    Are Health Trackers and Genetic Tests Harming Our Well-being?

    Health and fitness tracking devices may have unintended consequences on our well-being. While these devices can provide valuable information about our sleep quality and physical performance, they are not always accurate and may lead to obsessive anxiety or a nocebo effect. Inaccurate readings or false feedback from genetic tests can influence our expectations and ultimately impact our actual performance. For example, participants in a study who were falsely informed about their genetic potential for endurance exercise showed significant differences in their treadmill performance, highlighting the power of expectations. In the case of fitness trackers and genetic tests, it's crucial to recognize their limitations and not allow them to dictate our perception and motivation for exercise.

    You won't believe how reframing your daily chores can improve health!

    Our expectations have a significant impact on our exercise and diet. The study showed that when hotel cleaners were informed about the physical activity they were doing through their work, despite not perceiving it as exercise, they experienced improvements in their overall health. This suggests that reframing our daily chores as exercise and acknowledging their benefits can lead to better physical fitness. Similarly, research showed that having a positive attitude towards meals and perceiving them as nutritious can increase nutrient absorption. Furthermore, expectations can influence the hormonal response to food, with labeling and perceptions affecting the hunger hormone ghrelin. Therefore, being aware of and adjusting our expectations can have a profound effect on both exercise and diet outcomes.

    10 Words

    The way we describe food can have a significant impact on our appetite and how our bodies respond to it. Research shows that using more enticing and descriptive language when discussing food can increase satisfaction and anticipation, leading to a more positive physiological response. Additionally, the expectation effect can also be applied to anxiety and stress. By recognizing the potential benefits of uncomfortable feelings, such as a racing heart or heightened cortisol levels, individuals can improve their performance and prevent panic. This reframing of emotions can also expedite recovery from stress, allowing the body to resume essential functions like digestion and tissue repair more quickly. Therefore, setting realistic expectations and embracing the adaptive nature of stress can positively influence both our eating habits and mental well-being.

    Discover the surprising ways stress and aging can benefit you!

    Reframing our perceptions of stress and aging can have significant positive impacts on our well-being. By viewing stress as a natural response preparing us to face challenges, we can reduce the long-term effects of anxiety and stress, such as burnout and cardiovascular disease. Similarly, by fostering positive expectations about aging and avoiding negative associations, we can actually extend our lifespan. This mindset shift not only applies to ourselves but can also be taught to others, such as our children or those we coach. Changing our mindset allows us to harness the energy and discomfort of stress, turning it to our advantage and ultimately enhancing our performance and personal growth.

    This Surprising Attitude Towards Aging Could Be Hurting You!

    Our attitude towards aging has a significant impact on our physical and mental well-being. If we have a defeatist mindset and view aging as something terrible, we are less likely to take care of our health through exercise and a healthy diet. This leads to a higher risk of diseases and shorter longevity. Additionally, feeling vulnerable and seeing challenges as threats triggers a heightened stress response, which can accelerate the aging process at a cellular level. On the other hand, having a positive view of aging acknowledges the risks but also recognizes the benefits, such as personal growth, wisdom, and improved decision-making skills. Our perception of aging can shape our physical and mental experiences, making it important to cultivate a positive outlook to maintain vitality and functionality as we age.

    Discover how our expectations shape our bodies and minds!

    Our expectations can greatly impact our physiology, psychology, and overall experience of life. In the past, people expected to be old and frail at 65, and that's exactly what they experienced. However, in modern times, we expect to remain vibrant and active for longer, resulting in 70-year-old grandmas wearing tank tops and doing Tae Bo. This highlights the powerful effect expectations can have on our bodies and minds. What we expect can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. It's important to recognize the influence our expectations have on our lives and actively shape them to better align with the outcomes we desire. By challenging limiting beliefs and cultivating positive expectations, we can lead more fulfilling and vibrant lives.

    Recent Episodes from The Art of Manliness

    Patton and the Bulge: Blood, Guts, and Prayer

    Patton and the Bulge: Blood, Guts, and Prayer

    General George S. Patton is known for his aggressive, action-oriented tactical brilliance.

    His character was also marked by a lesser-known but equally fundamental mystic piety.

    Those two qualities would come together in the lead up to and execution of Patton's greatest achievement during WWII: the relief of Bastogne during the Battle of the Bulge.

    Alex Kershaw tells this story in his new book Patton's Prayer: A True Story of Courage, Faith, and Victory in World War II. Today on the show, Alex shares how, when the Third Army's advance into Germany was stalled by plane-grounding clouds and road-muddying rain, Patton commissioned a prayer for better weather that was distributed to a quarter million of his men, and how that prayer became even more urgent after the commencement of the Battle of the Bulge. We also talk about Patton's qualities as a leader and a man, including his reading habits, how he combined a profane assertiveness with a pious faith and a belief in reincarnation, and what happened to him as the war came to a close.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Alex Kershaw

    Book cover of
    The Art of Manliness
    enMay 20, 2024

    Embracing the Strive State

    Embracing the Strive State

    We often think happiness will be found in the completion of a goal. We often think happiness will be found in ease and comfort. My guest says real joy is found in the journey rather than the destination, and that if difficulty and discomfort are part of that journey, that's all the better.

    Dr. Adam Fraser is a peak performance researcher and the author of Strive: Embracing the Gift of Struggle. Today on the show, we talk about what Adam calls the "strive state," where we have to grow and be courageous to tackle a meaningful challenge, and why this state is the source of the greatest fulfillment in life. We discuss why we often resist embracing the strive state and what happens when we don't have to struggle in life. We also talk about what successful strivers do differently.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Adam Fraser

    Book cover of
    The Art of Manliness
    enMay 15, 2024

    The Dude's Guide to Laundry: How to Save Time, Money, and Your Wardrobe

    The Dude's Guide to Laundry: How to Save Time, Money, and Your Wardrobe

    If you didn’t grow up doing your own laundry, once you headed out on your own, you probably just figured things out on the fly, hoped for the best, and have been doing things the same way ever since. But, while you may be getting the job done okay, you also might be making some mistakes that are costing you time, money, and cleaner clothes.

    In this episode from the Art of Manliness department of essential life skills, we’ll cover all the things you should have learned as a young man but never did, and how to do your laundry effectively. Our guide is Patric Richardson, aka the “Laundry Evangelist,” a laundry expert who runs how-to-do-laundry camps, hosts the television show The Laundry Guy, and is the author of Laundry Love. Today on the show, Patric shares the one cycle and water temperature you should use for all of your clothes, exactly how much detergent you should be using (which is a lot less than you think), how often you should wash your clothes (which is less often than you think), why you shouldn’t ever use dryer sheets (and what to throw in your dryer instead), how regardless of what the tag says, you can wash anything at home (including a wool suit), how to easily get rid of stains (including yellow pit stains), and many more tips that will save you time, money, and hassle in doing your laundry.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Patric Richardson

    The Art of Manliness
    enMay 13, 2024

    How to Get Better at Anything

    How to Get Better at Anything

    Life revolves around learning—in school, at our jobs, even in the things we do for fun. But we often don’t progress in any of these areas at the rate we’d like. Consequently, and unfortunately, we often give up our pursuits prematurely or resign ourselves to always being mediocre in our classes, career, and hobbies.

    Scott Young has some tips on how you can avoid this fate, level up in whatever you do, and enjoy the satisfaction of skill improvement. Scott is a writer, programmer, and entrepreneur, and the author of Get Better at Anything: 12 Maxims for Mastery. Today on the show, Scott shares the three key factors in helping us learn. He explains how copying others is an underrated technique in becoming a genius, why, contrary to the sentiments of motivational memes, we learn more from success than mistakes, why experts often aren’t good teachers and tactics for drawing out their best advice, why you may need to get worse before you get better, and more.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Scott Young

    Podcast #989 featuring the book cover of

    Of Strength and Soul — Exploring the Philosophy of Physical Fitness

    Of Strength and Soul — Exploring the Philosophy of Physical Fitness

    When you’re lifting weights, you might be thinking about setting a new PR or doing your curls for the girls.

    But throughout history, philosophers have thought about physical fitness on a deeper level and considered how exercise shapes not only the body, but also the mind and the soul.

    My guest today, Joe Lombardo, is a strength enthusiast who follows in this tradition and has explored the philosophy of bodily exercise in his writing. Today on the show, Joe and I discuss several different ways the philosophy of strength has been expressed over time.

    We begin our conversation with how the ancient Greeks thought of physical training as a way to develop personal as well as social virtues, and why they thought you were an "idiot," in their particular sense of the word, if you didn't take care of your body. We then discuss early Christianity's relationship with physical exercise and the development of the muscular Christianity movement in the 19th century. We end our conversation by looking at the philosophy of physicality espoused by the Japanese writer Yukio Mishima, and what he had to say as to how strength training moves us out of the life of the night and towards the light of the sun.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Joe Lomabrdo

    The No-BS Secrets of Success

    The No-BS Secrets of Success

    Jim VandeHei didn’t have an auspicious start in life. His high school guidance counselor told him he wasn’t cut out for college, and he went on to confirm her assessment, getting a 1.4 GPA at the University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh and spending more time drinking beer than planning his career.

    Eventually, though, Jim turned things around for himself, going on to co-found two of the biggest modern media outlets, Politico and Axios.

    Jim shares how he started moving up the rungs of success and building a better life for himself in his new book Just the Good Stuff: No-BS Secrets to Success (No Matter What Life Throws at You). Today on the show, Jim shares the real-world lessons he’s learned in his career. We discuss the importance of matching passion to opportunity, making your own luck, surrounding yourself with the right people, keeping the buckets of your happiness matrix filled, understanding the difference between wartime and peacetime leadership, harnessing the energy of healthy revenge, and more.

    Connect With Jim VandeHei

    Book cover for


    How to Eliminate the Two Biggest Sources of Financial Stress

    How to Eliminate the Two Biggest Sources of Financial Stress

    There are different philosophies one can have when it comes to money. Jared Dillian’s is built around eliminating as much anxiety around it as possible, so you hardly think about money at all.

    Jared is a former trader for Lehman Brothers, the editor of The Daily Dirtnap, a market newsletter for investment professionals, and the author of No Worries: How to Live a Stress-Free Financial Life. Today on the show, Jared talks about the two biggest sources of financial stress — debt and risk — and how you can eliminate the stress they can cause. We discuss how three big financial decisions — buying a car, buying a house, and managing student loans — ultimately determine your financial health, and how to approach each of them in a stress-eliminating way. We also talk about how to minimize risk by creating what he calls an “awesome portfolio,” a mix of assets that has nearly the return of the stock market with half its risk. And Jared shares whether cryptocurrency fits into his “no worries” financial philosophy.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Jared Dillian

    Cover of the book

    The Secret World of Bare-Knuckle Boxing

    The Secret World of Bare-Knuckle Boxing

    Have you ever noticed the guy in a fighting stance on the Art of Manliness logo? That’s not just some random symbol; it’s an actual dude: John L. Sullivan, the greatest bare-knuckle boxer of the 19th century.

    While most people think bare-knuckle boxing came to an end during Sullivan’s era, in fact, it never entirely went away. In his new book, Bare Knuckle: Bobby Gunn, 73–0 Undefeated. A Dad. A Dream. A Fight Like You’ve Never Seen, Stayton Bonner charts bare-knuckle boxing’s rise, fall, and resurgence, as well as the improbable story of its modern chapter’s winningest champion. Today on the show, Stayton describes bare-knuckle boxing’s incredible popularity a century ago, and why gloved boxing took its place while bare-knuckle got pushed into a shadowy, illicit underground. Stayton takes us into that secret circuit which still exists today, revealing the dark, sweaty basements and bars where modern bare-knuckle fights take place and the ancient code of honor that structures them. And Stayton introduces us to a dominant figure in that world, Bobby Gunn, an undefeated bare-knuckle fighter who combines a love of faith, family, and fighting and has helped turn bare-knuckle boxing into what is now the world’s fastest-growing combat sport.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Stayton Bonner

    Book cover of

    Why Your Memory Seems Bad (It’s Not Just Age)

    Why Your Memory Seems Bad (It’s Not Just Age)

    Do you sometimes walk to another room in your house to get something, but then can’t remember what it was you wanted? Do you sometimes forget about an appointment or struggle to remember someone’s name?

    You may have chalked these lapses in memory up to getting older. And age can indeed play a role in the diminishing power of memory. But as my guest will tell us, there are other factors at play as well.

    Charan Ranganath is a neuroscientist, a psychologist, and the author of Why We Remember: Unlocking Memory’s Power to Hold on to What Matters. Today on the show, Charan explains how factors like how we direct our attention, take photos, and move through something called “event boundaries” all affect our memory, and how our current context in life impacts which memories we’re able to recall from the past. We also talk about how to reverse engineer these factors to improve your memory.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Charan Ranganath

    Book cover titled

    Grid-Down Medicine — A Guide for When Help Is NOT on the Way

    Grid-Down Medicine — A Guide for When Help Is NOT on the Way

    If you read most first aid guides, the last step in treating someone who’s gotten injured or sick is always: get the victim to professional medical help.

    But what if you found yourself in a situation where hospitals were overcrowded, inaccessible, or non-functional? What if you found yourself in a grid-down, long-term disaster, and you were the highest medical resource available?

    Dr. Joe Alton is an expert in what would come after the step where most first aid guides leave off. He’s a retired surgeon and the co-author of The Survival Medicine Handbook: The Essential Guide for When Help is NOT on the Way. Today on the show, Joe argues that every family should have a medical asset and how to prepare to be a civilian medic. We discuss the different levels of first aid kits to consider creating, from an individual kit all the way up to a community field hospital. And we talk about the health-related skills you might need in a long-term grid-down disaster, from burying a dead body, to closing a wound with super glue, to making an improvised dental filling, to even protecting yourself from the radiation of nuclear fallout.

    Resources Related to the Podcast

    Connect With Joe Alton

    Cover of