Embracing Anomalies: Unveiling New Discoveries and Advancements: Paying attention to anomalies and embracing oddities can lead to valuable insights and new fields of study, unlocking opportunities for learning and growth.
Paying attention to anomalies can lead to important discoveries and advancements. Just as Abraham Ortelius noticed a strange coincidence in the shape of continents, scientists realized that continents do move and this led to the theory of continental drift. Similarly, Richard Thaler's fascination with anomalies in human behavior led to the development of the field of behavioral economics. Instead of dismissing oddities, having the humility and patience to explore them can teach us things we didn't know before. So next time you come across something that seems out of the ordinary, don't ignore it, but rather embrace it as an opportunity for learning and growth.
The Role of Self-Control and Context in Decision Making: Traditional economic models should consider the influence of self-control and context on decision making, as demonstrated by examples of excessive consumption and emotional attachment to possessions.
Traditional economic models often overlook the role of self-control and context in decision making. Richard Thaler's experience with the cashews and his friend Richard Roset's wine collection highlight the anomalies that economic models fail to address. People's inability to limit their consumption of cashews or their attachment to valuable bottles of wine challenge the assumption that more choices always make us better off. Additionally, the concept of opportunity cost is questioned when individuals perceive the cost of consuming an expensive bottle of wine differently than its monetary value. These examples emphasize the need to incorporate real-world behavior and psychology into economic models to better understand decision making.
Challenging Rational Economic Theories: Human decision-making often deviates from rational behavior, as evidenced by examples like the sunk cost fallacy and budgeting conundrums. Understanding these deviations is essential for designing better policies and interventions.
Human decision-making often doesn't align with rational economic theories. Examples like the sunk cost fallacy and budgeting conundrums show that people deviate from optimizing behavior. These anecdotes, initially seen as silly distractions by many economists, challenged the conventional wisdom of the field. Richard Thaler's collection of such stories exposed the flaws in classical economic models that assumed humans always make rational choices. The sweater dilemma and the lawn mowing scenario highlight how our behavior is influenced by factors beyond pure cost analysis. Understanding these deviations from rationality is crucial for designing more effective policies and interventions.
The Role of Psychology in Economic Decision-Making: Our economic choices are influenced by psychological factors and social norms, challenging the traditional economic model and highlighting the importance of understanding human behavior in its complexity.
Our economic choices are not solely driven by rational self-interest. Richard Thaler's research highlights the importance of psychological factors in shaping our decisions. We are not just economic actors, but individuals influenced by social norms, relationships, and hierarchies. This understanding challenges the traditional economic model that simplifies human behavior by ignoring these complexities. Thaler argues against labeling such behavior as irrational, as it carries negative connotations. Instead, he emphasizes that people's choices may not always align with economic rationality, but they have their own logic and optimization strategies. Additionally, Thaler points out that social norms, like tipping in restaurants, vary across cultures, highlighting the role of cultural context in shaping economic behavior.
The influence of social norms on behavior and the presence of systematic biases in decision-making.: Our behavior is not solely motivated by self-interest, but also by our concern for social reputation. The use of heuristics in decision-making can lead to predictable biases.
Social norms have a significant impact on our behavior. We aren't solely motivated by maximizing our own benefits, as we also care about our social reputations and what others think of us. We follow numerous social norms in our daily lives, even though some may vary depending on the specific context. Richard Thaler's discovery of Amos Ky and Daniel Kahneman's work in behavioral economics shed light on the cognitive biases that influence our decision-making processes. Their research showed that life is complex, and we often rely on heuristics or rules of thumb to navigate it. However, these heuristics can lead to predictable biases, highlighting the presence of systematic biases in our thinking. Therefore, our behaviors are not just random or disconnected, but rather exhibit underlying patterns that can be studied and understood.
Challenging the Assumption of Rational Decision-Making: People often make irrational decisions due to biases and external influences, highlighting the limitations of economic theory and the importance of behavioral economics in understanding human behavior.
Economic theory can be flawed when it assumes that people always make rational decisions. Richard Thaler's research disproves this assumption by showing that people often make systematic errors in their decision-making process. For example, they may fall victim to the sunk cost fallacy, where they continue investing money or resources into something because they have already invested in it, even when it's irrational to do so. Additionally, people's behavior is heavily influenced by seemingly irrelevant factors, such as the amount of money they paid for something. This insight challenges traditional economic models and highlights the need for behavioral economics to better understand and predict human behavior.
The Endowment Effect: Why we value what we have more than what we're willing to pay for.: People tend to overvalue their possessions and demand more to give them up, which can affect economic transactions and contribute to lower transaction volumes during a housing market downturn.
People tend to value things they already possess more than they would be willing to pay for them. This is known as the "endowment effect." A study conducted using coffee mugs showed that those who already had a mug demanded twice as much to give it up compared to what those without a mug were willing to pay to acquire one. This effect can have significant implications in various economic transactions, such as selling a house or trading goods for money. It explains why sellers often value their possessions higher than buyers would value them. Additionally, this effect can contribute to the decline in transaction volume during a housing market downturn, as sellers are reluctant to lower their prices.
The Impact of Target Income on Decision-Making: Insights from New York City Taxi Drivers: People's decisions can be influenced by their desired income, as seen in the behavior of taxi drivers who worked less on busy days and more on slow days to reach their target income, challenging traditional economic theories.
People's decision-making can be influenced by their target income or goals. This was evident in the study of taxi drivers in New York City, where they had a specific amount of income they aimed to make each day. As a result, on busy days, they worked less to reach their target income quickly, but on slow days, they worked more to compensate for the low earnings. This behavior contradicted traditional economic theories that assume individuals always strive for maximum income. This finding showcases the importance of understanding human psychology and the influence of personal goals and targets on decision-making, even in economic contexts such as the NFL draft, where teams strategically aim for the best deals to manage player salaries.
Teams' Flawed Perception of the First Pick in Sports Drafts: Teams should adopt a more evidence-based approach in player selection instead of overvaluing the first pick, as statistics show that the probability of the player chosen earlier being better than the next is only around 53%.
Professional sports teams, particularly in the National Football League, highly overvalue the first pick in drafts. Despite the lack of certainty about a player's future success, teams act as if the right to pick first is extremely valuable. However, research shows that the probability of the player chosen earlier being better than the player chosen next is only around 53%, indicating that teams are essentially throwing darts in their selections. This flawed understanding of player value can have significant consequences for teams, as they have a limited budget to work with and mispricing players means wasting resources that could be better spent on other players. Despite decades of evidence, teams have not improved in their decision-making, highlighting the persistent nature of this misconception. So, when it comes to player selection, teams would benefit from a more nuanced and evidence-based approach rather than assuming the first pick is the ultimate prize.
Follow the Anomalies
Recent Episodes from Hidden Brain
Sitting With Uncertainty
It can sometimes be exciting when we don't know what's coming next. Other times, the unknown can be deeply troubling. This week, we talk with researcher Dannagal Goldthwaite Young about how we respond to uncertainty, and why this psychological trait plays a surprisingly large role in shaping our behavior, perspectives — even our political beliefs.
If you'd like to learn more about the intersection between psychology and our political views, check out these other Hidden Brain episodes:
US 2.0: Not at the Dinner Table
US 2.0: What We Have in Common
Rewrite Your Money Story
Money worries are one of the biggest sources of anxiety in our lives. Psychologist Brad Klontz says these worries are shaped by more than the number in our bank accounts — they’re often driven by our unconscious beliefs. This week, we bring you a favorite 2022 conversation with Klontz, who says it’s possible to identify and change what he calls our “money scripts.”
For more of our work, please consider joining our podcast subscription, Hidden Brain+. It's our home for conversations and ideas you won't hear anywhere else. Plus, you'll be providing vital support for the work that we do. If you listen on Apple Podcasts, you can find us at apple.co/hiddenbrain. If you use other podcast platforms or devices, you can sign up at support.hiddenbrain.org. Thanks for your support!
You 2.0: Fighting Despair
Every morning, you wake up and face the world. What does it look like to you? Do you see a paradise of endless opportunities, where people are friendly and helpful? Or a world filled with injustice, where people cannot be trusted? In the final installment of this year's You 2.0 series, we talk with psychologist Jamil Zaki about how we become disillusioned and distrustful of the world, and how to balance realism with hope.
Did you miss any of the other episodes in the You 2.0 series? Make sure to give them a listen here or on our website:
- You 2.0: The Gift of Other People
- You 2.0: Taking Control of Your Time
- You 2.0: How To Say No
- You 2.0: Remember More, Forget Less
And if you like today's conversation with Jamil Zaki, be sure to check out our earlier conversation with him, "The Empathy Gym."
You 2.0: Remember More, Forget Less
It happens to the best of us — we blank on someone's name, or forget an important meeting, or bomb a test we thought we'd ace. In this week's installment of our You 2.0 series, we talk to cognitive scientist Daniel Willingham about the mysteries of memory: how it works, why it fails us, and how to build memories that stick.
For more of our You 2.0 series, listen to our episode on how to say no.
You 2.0: How To Say No
Saying no to someone who asks for something is often easier said than done. Maybe it's a boss who wants you to take on a new assignment. Or your kid's teacher, seeking volunteers for a field trip. Or a friend who asks you to lend her money. How should we respond to these demands on our time, energy, and resources? This week, psychologist Vanessa Patrick explores why it's so hard to say no, and how we can set boundaries that will make it easier to do so.
If you haven't yet caught the first two episodes in this year's You 2.0 series, you can find them in this podcast feed, or on our website:
You 2.0: The Gift of Other People
You 2.0: Taking Control of Your Time
Thanks for listening!
You 2.0: Taking Control of Your Time
Many of us feel like there aren't enough hours in the day. We struggle to make time for all the competing demands at work and at home, and inevitably feel like we're letting someone down. But what if there were a way to reclaim our time and, as a result, get more joy out of our lives? In the second episode of this year's You 2.0 series, psychologist Cassie Mogilner Holmes explains how we've fallen victim to the illusion of time scarcity, and what we can do to spend our time more wisely.
If you enjoy today's episode, check out last week's kick-off to our series, "You 2.0: The Gift of Other People."
You 2.0: The Gift of Other People
Are you someone who strikes up a conversation with the person next to you on the train? Or do you keep your eyes fixed on your phone? Do you offer gratitude to friends and family? Or do you assume that they already know how you feel? This week, in the kickoff to our annual You 2.0 series, we talk with psychologist Nicholas Epley about our interactions with other people, and how we can make them more rewarding.
If you enjoy today's episode, check out these classic Hidden Brain episodes:
You're Not the Boss of Me!
Whether in your personal life or at work, you've probably experienced what it’s like to have people reject your requests. To be told that what you want is unfair, or heavy-handed. And you've likely been in the opposite position as well — pushing back against requests that step on your freedom. This week, we talk to psychologist Benjamin Rosenberg about how we respond to infringements on our sense of autonomy, and how we can avoid sparking this resistance in our interactions with other people.
If you know someone who would like today's episode, please share it with them! And if you enjoy our show, please consider trying a free seven-day trial of our podcast subscription, Hidden Brain+. If you use an iPhone, you can sign up at apple.co/hiddenbrain. If you use an Android device, you can find Hidden Brain+ at support.hiddenbrain.org. Thanks for listening!
The Cure for Self-Importance
When we meet new people, we’re often drawn to those with a commanding presence or a dazzling personality. But it turns out that a very different trait — humility — is important in the long term. This week, in the first of a two-part discussion, we talk with psychologist Daryl Van Tongeren about different kinds of humility, and how this overlooked quality can play a powerful role in workplace dynamics and romantic relationships.
If you like today's episode, be sure to check out part two of our conversation, exclusively for Hidden Brain+ listeners. We talk with Daryl Van Tongeren about existential humility — being open to the idea we might be wrong about life's biggest unknowns. It's the episode called "Asking the Big Questions." To listen to Hidden Brain+ with a free seven-day trial, go to apple.co/hiddenbrain or support.hiddenbrain.org.
Where Truth Lies
When we think about misinformation, we often focus on blatant errors or deliberate attempts to deceive us. But in recent years, social scientists have found that misinformation comes in many flavors — many of which are far more subtle than obvious falsehoods. These forms of misinformation prey on our mental blindspots, and take advantage of our passions and loyalties. This week, economist Alex Edmans explores the many insidious forms of misinformation, and how we can all get better at separating fact from fiction.
For more of our work, please consider joining our podcast subscription. Hidden Brain+ is where you’ll find exclusive interviews and deeper dives into the ideas we explore on the show. You can try Hidden Brain+ with a free seven-day trial at apple.co/hiddenbrain. Or if you’re an Android user, sign up at support.hiddenbrain.org.
Related Episodes
#180 TKP Insights: Learning and Thinking
The guests on this episode are psychologist and economist Daniel Kahneman (Episode 68), engineering professor Barbara Oakley (Episode 31), author and global macro advisor Adam Robinson (Episodes 47 and 48), economist and professor Tyler Cowen (Episode 39), and author and organizational psychology professor Adam Grant (Episode 112).
--
Want even more? Members get early access, hand-edited transcripts, member-only episodes, and so much more. Learn more here: https://fs.blog/membership/
Every Sunday our Brain Food newsletter shares timeless insights and ideas that you can use at work and home. Add it to your inbox: https://fs.blog/newsletter/
Follow Shane on Twitter at: https://twitter.com/ShaneAParrish
Our Sponsors:
MetaLab: Helping the world’s top companies design, build, and ship amazing products and services. https://www.metalab.com
Aeropress: Press your perfect cup, every time. https://aeropress.com
Vanta: Helping you get compliance-ready, fast. https://www.vanta.com/
Cognitive Biases, Discrimination, Heuristics, Prejudice, Stereotypes, Racism, Sexism, Self-Serving Bias, Actor/Observer Bias, Change Bias.
Survey shows investors have lost faith in the Bank of England’s decision-making - (TREASURY NEWS)
Pushpendra Mehta meets with Paul Galloway, Senior Director, Advisory Services at Strategic Treasurer, and Ben Poole, Writer at CTMfile, to review the latest treasury news and developments. Topics of discussion include the following:
Perspectives Unveiled: Insights on Relationships, Growth, and Confronting Biases
Join Host Bruce Anthony as he shares invaluable insights on personal growth, relationships, and the importance of confronting biases in this engaging episode. Discover Bruce's thoughts on setting boundaries, finding purpose, and communicating in relationships. Explore his perspective on the significance of vulnerability and the impact of toxic people in our lives. Gain wisdom on effective communication in marriage and learn how it can prevent divorce. Dive into Bruce's personal journey, including his past biases and the transformative power of embracing diversity. Don't miss out on this eye-opening discussion packed with practical advice for personal development and fostering meaningful connections. #effectivecommunication #unsolicitedperspectivespodcast #LGBTQ+Issues #embracingdifferences #ConfrontingBiases
Ready to shop better hydration, use my special link https://zen.ai/unsolicitedperspectives2 to save 20% off anything you order.
Use my special link https://zen.ai/unsolicitedperspectives3 to save 10% at wongopuzzles.com. The discount will be applied at checkout!
What Would Socrates Do?
Humans have wrestled with questions about identity and purpose for millennia. So it’s no surprise that the insights of people who lived hundreds or even thousands of years ago have stood the test of time. This week, philosopher Tamar Gendler explores how three great thinkers from ancient Greece understood the human psyche, and what we can still learn from their wisdom today.
If you know someone who would enjoy this episode, please share it with them. And thanks for listening! We look forward to bringing you many new Hidden Brain episodes in 2024.