Logo

    387. What You See and Feel is Not Reality | Dr. Donald Hoffman

    Our understanding of reality is shaped by consciousness, which seeks to know itself through different perspectives, highlighting the importance of independent and innovative thinking in scientific progress.

    enOctober 12, 2023

    About this Episode

    Dr. Jordan B Peterson and cognitive neuroscientist Dr. Donald Hoffman discuss what we know as reality, why space time is now being considered a “doomed” framework, and how consciousness can be understood as a vast probability space within which we orient ourselves.

     

    Hoffman received a Bachelor of Arts degree in quantitative psychology from the University of California at Los Angeles, and then his Doctorate of Philosophy in computational psychology at MIT. He briefly worked as a research scientist at the MIT Artificial Intelligence Lab, before taking on the role of assistant professor at the University of California at Irvine. He is now a professor in the department of Cognitive Sciences. He has written four books (below), on the topics of human vision, perception, consciousness, and the effects of/reasons for evolution on each. He is also a key proponent of MUI (Multimodal User Interface) theory, which states that "perceptual experiences do not match or approximate properties of the objective world, but instead provide a simplified, species-specific, user interface to that world." Hoffman argues that conscious beings have not evolved to perceive the world as it actually is but have evolved to perceive the world in a way that maximizes "fitness payoffs.”

     

    - Links -

     

    For Dr. Donald Hoffman:

     

    "The Case Against Reality: Why Evolution Hid the Truth from Our Eyes" (Book) https://www.amazon.com/Case-Against-Reality-Evolution-Truth-ebook/dp/B07JR1FDXH/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1OMOD0ZGPHCT9&keywords=the+case+against+reality&qid=1697060197&s=digital-text&sprefix=the+case+against%2Cdigital-text%2C189&sr=1-1

     

    "Visual Intelligence: How We Create What We See" (Book) https://www.amazon.com/Visual-Intelligence-How-Create-What/dp/0393319679/ref=sr_1_1?crid=QZBIXXULF7VC&keywords=Visual+intelligence+hoffman&qid=1697060273&s=digital-text&sprefix=visual+intelligence+hoffman%2Cdigital-text%2C138&sr=1-1-catcorr

     

    Dr. Hoffman on X https://twitter.com/donalddhoffman?lang=en

     

    Dr. Hoffman's Ted Talk https://www.ted.com/talks/donald_hoffman_do_we_see_reality_as_it_is?language=en 

    🔑 Key Takeaways

    • Our sensory systems prioritize efficiency and heuristics over perfect accuracy, shaping our perception of reality based on the interplay between the world, the organism, and its actions.
    • The probability of fitness payoff functions aligning with the structure of the world is low, and evolutionary theory does not provide guidance in determining their structure. The complexity of perception and various constraints shape our understanding of the world.
    • Our perception of reality is a simplified interface that serves specific goals, allowing us to navigate and make choices that contribute to our long-term survival and reproductive success.
    • Our perception of reality is a subjective and constructed version that is shaped by our motivations, needs, and pragmatic ends. It is not an objective truth.
    • While there is a causal connection between what happens inside a computer and what we perceive on the screen, there is no direct replica or homomorphism of structure between the two.
    • Physicists are proposing a new framework for physics that goes beyond space-time, while Jordan Peterson discusses the importance of understanding through manipulation and grip, highlighting the connection between mythological structures and neuroscience findings on perception.
    • Embracing the idea that consciousness is more fundamental than objective reality opens up a realm of possibilities, urging us to navigate the probability space and make choices that align with our desired outcomes.
    • Emotions like positive emotion and anxiety can be explained by the reduction or increase in entropy, reflecting the progress or obstacles towards desired outcomes.
    • Our perception of time, entropy, and reality is subjective and influenced by our goals and projections, raising questions about the nature of reality and the definition of truth.
    • Scientific theories are built upon foundational assumptions, highlighting the philosophical nature of scientific inquiry and the potential limitations of these theories themselves.
    • Scientists rely on assumptions to explore complex subjects, but challenging these assumptions can reveal hidden complexities and uncertainties. By continually refining and expanding assumptions, scientific inquiry can never reach a complete theory of everything. However, current theories have still led to significant advancements in technology and understanding.
    • Reproduction involves more than immediate sexual gratification and is influenced by a pattern of behavior, including investing time and effort in raising and nurturing offspring for successful reproduction across generations. Additionally, considering deeper spiritual principles beyond evolutionary theory is necessary.
    • Our understanding of reality is shaped by consciousness, which seeks to know itself through different perspectives, highlighting the importance of independent and innovative thinking in scientific progress.
    • Scientific theories are defined by the mathematics used to describe them, revealing their boundaries and limitations. Truth in science is relative and subject to change over time and assumptions.
    • Evolutionary game theory is a powerful tool for understanding evolution, but it is not an ultimate truth. Science constantly evolves, seeking new discoveries and expanding our understanding.
    • Embracing the idea of consciousness as more than our physical selves challenges our beliefs, raising profound questions about identity and the meaning of our existence.

    📝 Podcast Summary

    Challenging the Perception of Reality

    Dr. Donald Hoffman's research challenges the notion that our sensory systems are shaped by evolution to perceive reality as it truly is. While many believe that seeing aspects of reality accurately would increase our fitness and likelihood of reproduction, Hoffman's findings suggest otherwise. Using evolutionary game theory, he and his team analyzed fitness payoffs, which are the points organisms gain for being in certain states and taking certain actions. They discovered that the chance of perceiving reality as it is, according to Darwinian principles, is essentially zero. This surprising result implies that our sensory systems prioritize efficiency and heuristics over perfect accuracy. Ultimately, our perception of reality is shaped by the interplay between the state of the world, the state of the organism, and its actions, rather than reflecting an objective truth.

    Alignment Between Fitness Payoff Functions and the Structure of the World

    The probability of a generically chosen payoff function preserving a structure like a metric or a total order is very low. This means that most fitness payoff functions do not align with the structure of the world. Evolutionary theory, which is indifferent about the shape of payoff functions, does not provide any guidance in determining their structure. To assess the likelihood of preserving a structure, certain equations must be satisfied by the payoff function. However, these equations are highly restrictive and most functions do not meet the criteria. Additionally, the complexity of perception should not be underestimated, as there are numerous assumptions and constraints that shape our understanding of the world. This includes both practical considerations, like building a bridge, as well as Darwinian constraints related to shared perceptions and motivations.

    The Constructed Interface of Reality

    Our perception of reality is not a direct reflection of the objective world, but rather a simplified and purposefully constructed interface that allows us to navigate and interact with our environment effectively. Evolution has shaped our sensory systems to provide us with this user interface, much like the desktop on a computer. Just as we don't need to understand the intricate workings of our computer's circuits to use it, we do not need to comprehend the complexity of reality to function in it. Our perception is optimized to serve specific goals and functions, translating the external world into manageable and meaningful information. This understanding helps us navigate the inherent conflicts and constraints that arise from our various motivational systems, enabling us to make choices that contribute to our long-term survival and reproductive success.

    The Constructed Nature of Perception

    Our perception of reality is not a direct representation of objective truth. Instead, we perceive a low-resolution version of reality that is shaped by our motivations and needs. Just like the icons on a computer screen or animated characters in a show, our perception is a functional tool that helps us navigate the world. This idea is analogous to the concept of kenosis, where a low-resolution representation of God is used to establish a relationship between the infinite and the bounded. Similarly, our perception of objects contains an unbiased sampling of reality, although it is bent towards pragmatic and motivational ends. Ultimately, our perception is a constructed version of reality rather than an objective truth.

    Causal Connection vs. Homomorphism: Exploring Supercomputer Architecture

    There is a distinction between causal connection and homomorphism in the supercomputer architecture. Donald Hoffman argues that although there is a causal connection between what happens inside the computer and what we perceive on the screen, there is no direct replica or homomorphism of structure between the two. The pattern of electrons in the computer, for example, has no color, yet the programmed sequence generates specific colors on the screen. Jordan Peterson suggests that there may still be a pattern or homomorphism at certain levels of multi-level patterning, even if it is not present throughout the entire system. The analogy of the immune system further illustrates the idea of generating a sufficient homolog to accomplish a specific goal. However, Hoffman maintains that we cannot rely on homomorphism and that what we perceive is akin to a headset, separate from the underlying reality.

    Exploring new frameworks in physics beyond space-time and quantum theory, and the debate between structure, function, and consciousness.

    Physicists, including Donald Hoffman, are suggesting the need for a new framework for physics that goes beyond space-time and quantum theory. They are exploring structures like decorated permutations that exist outside of space-time. Hoffman also aligns this view with Darwin's theory, stating that space-time is not fundamental, but rather just a headset. On the other hand, Jordan Peterson brings up the concept of homology and the importance of understanding through manipulation and grip. While Peterson acknowledges the possible limitations of homology, he still sees some indication of it, especially when it comes to the relationship between cause and effect. Ultimately, a debate arises between the concepts of structure and function and their connection to consciousness. Peterson also highlights the idea of three fundamental causal agents or structures found in mythological stories, which can be related to neuroscience findings on perception.

    Consciousness as the Fundamental Reality: Exploring the Nature of Space-Time

    Consciousness is more fundamental than objective reality, according to the views of Jordan Peterson and Donald Hoffman. They argue that space-time, which has long been considered the fundamental reality, is actually just a trivial headset. Scientists are now searching for structures beyond space-time, and consciousness is seen as a fundamental reality outside of it. Hoffman's theory of conscious agents proposes a probability space as a realm of potentiality, similar to Peterson's concept of a probability landscape. Both suggest that the world should be understood as a place of possibilities and differing probabilities, rather than a fixed and deterministic system. The key question then becomes how to best orient ourselves to navigate this probability space and contend with the potentialities it offers.

    Understanding Conscious Experiences and Emotions through Probability Spaces and Entropy

    Conscious experiences can be represented by a probability space, where different agents may have different sets of possible experiences. The simpler an organism is, the more limited their probability space becomes, collapsing into a few choices. Emotions, such as positive emotion and anxiety, can be understood in terms of reducing or increasing entropy in relation to desired outcomes. Positive emotion arises when steps are taken towards a goal, reducing the number of potential pathways. Anxiety, on the other hand, emerges when the probability space expands, making desired goals more difficult to achieve. Additionally, it is possible to model a reality outside of space-time where entropy does not increase, but when projected onto our world, the arrow of time and increasing entropy emerge.

    The Subjective Nature of Time and Reality

    Our perception of time and reality may be subjective and influenced by our goals and projections. Entropy, or disorder, is often defined in relation to a posited state of order, making it subjective as well. Our perception of objects is based on conditional probabilities and the likelihood of certain outcomes. We interact with the probability space around objects, shaping our perception and actions. The concept of entropy and natural selection in Darwinian theory may be artifacts of projection rather than fundamental insights into reality. Time, considered a limited resource, may also be an artifact of projection, making the arrow of time subjective. This raises questions about the nature of reality and the definition of truth.

    The Role of Assumptions in Scientific Theories

    Scientific theories rely on certain assumptions, or axioms, that cannot be proven within the framework of the theory itself. Jordan Peterson and Donald Hoffman discuss how scientific theories, such as Einstein's theory of special relativity or Darwin's theory of evolution, start with these foundational assumptions and build upon them. Peterson raises the idea that the practice of science itself requires faith in certain beliefs, such as the existence of objective truth and the discoverability of that truth. These axioms are essential for scientists to make progress and communicate their findings. However, there is a recognition that these assumptions may not be universally true or supported by empirical evidence. This highlights the philosophical nature of scientific inquiry and the potential limitations of scientific theories themselves.

    The importance of assumptions in scientific theories and the need for continual refinement and exploration.

    Scientific theories are built upon assumptions or axioms that serve as the foundation for further exploration and understanding. These assumptions can be seen as the starting point for scientific discourse, allowing researchers to delve into the complexities of a particular subject. However, challenging these axioms can lead to the release of hidden complexities and uncertainties, which many people may find uncomfortable. It is important for scientists to explicitly state their assumptions so that the scope and limits of their theories can be understood. This process of continually refining and broadening assumptions ensures that scientific inquiry never reaches a complete theory of everything, providing infinite job security for scientists. Despite the limited certainty provided by current theories, they have still allowed for remarkable advancements in technology and understanding, proving their practical value. Ultimately, the pursuit of knowledge involves continually aiming upwards, making sacrifices, and exploring new pathways for maximum understanding and progress.

    The complexity of reproduction goes beyond sex and lust, involving long-term investment and a pattern of behavior that ensures reproductive fitness.

    The drive for reproduction is more complex than simply sex or lust. Evolutionary biologists like Dawkins have often made the mistake of closely equating reproduction with short-term sex, overlooking the long-term investment required for successful reproduction. Human beings, for instance, not only rely on sex for reproduction but also invest significant time and effort in raising and nurturing their offspring for many years. This shows that reproduction extends beyond immediate sexual gratification and is influenced by an ethos or pattern of behavior that ensures reproductive fitness across generations. Moreover, when considering deeper spiritual principles, evolutionary theory alone may not be sufficient as it is limited to the framework of space-time projection. Consciousness, which is primary, operates within this framework but is not confined by it.

    Consciousness and reality: exploring the interconnectedness and infinite perspectives.

    Reality and consciousness are deeply intertwined. Donald Hoffman suggests that consciousness is the primary reality, and it uses projections to navigate and survive in the world. He proposes that there is one ultimate infinite consciousness that seeks to know itself. However, due to certain theorems, no system can fully know itself. So, the infinite consciousness looks at itself through different perspectives, like putting on different headsets. This perspective, like space-time, gives rise to our experience of reality, including evolution and quantum field theory. Jordan Peterson adds that different perspectives and narratives in various traditions all point to the same underlying reality. This exploration of consciousness and reality ties into the scientific enterprise and the pursuit of comprehensive understanding. Although Hoffman's ideas may face resistance, the progress of science often comes from independent and innovative thinking.

    The Scope and Limits of Scientific Theories

    Scientific theories, including Darwin's theory of evolution and Einstein's theory of gravity, have both a scope and limits that are defined by the mathematics used to describe them. The equations reveal the boundaries of our concepts and assumptions, showing us how far they can go and no further. This understanding of science tells us that truth is not a fixed, all-encompassing definition, but rather a reflection of what works within a specific timeframe and set of implications. It aligns with the idea that truth is more like the functionality of a bridge, determined by whether it can withstand the weight of a hundred cars crossing it. Therefore, while science is valuable, we should always acknowledge that our theories are not a final or complete representation of reality.

    Evolutionary game theory: Exploring the dynamics of evolution and truth.

    Evolutionary game theory is a valuable tool within the field of evolutionary theory, as it helps us understand various phenomena. While there is always debate and ongoing research, evolutionary game theory is widely accepted as the best mathematical framework for analyzing Darwin's theory of evolution. It allows scientists to rigorously examine the concept of truth within this theory. However, it is important to note that evolutionary game theory is not the final word or ultimate truth. It is simply the current state of play in the scientific community. The goal of science is to continually push the boundaries of current theories and find their limits, ultimately transcending them. As we make new discoveries, our understanding expands and the patterns of science continue to evolve.

    Donald Hoffman's Mind-Expanding Journey to Transcendent Consciousness

    Donald Hoffman's radical conception of consciousness has forced him to confront his own self-image and contemplate the purpose of his life. Rather than seeing himself as a purely physical being confined to space and time, he now perceives his body as just an avatar in a larger network of conscious agents. This realization has challenged his beliefs as a physicalist and materialist, causing a significant shift in his existential understanding. While he acknowledges the rules of morality within this avatar projection, he ultimately views himself as the transcendent consciousness that exists beyond space and time. This perspective raises questions about the true nature of identity and the significance of individual existence.

    Recent Episodes from The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast

    450. Reagan, Star Wars, Trump, & Power | Dennis Quaid

    450. Reagan, Star Wars, Trump, & Power | Dennis Quaid

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down in person with legendary actor Dennis Quaid. They discuss his upcoming film in which he portrays the titular Ronald Reagan, what the former president understood about Marxism, how he dealt with the Soviet cold war, how an actor learns to leave the character after each take, the responsibility to portray flaws as well virtues, existing as an Independent in Hollywood, and the state of the industry as well as the country today.

     

    Dennis William Quaid is an American actor and gospel singer. He is known for his starring roles in Breaking Away (1979), The Right Stuff (1983), The Big Easy (1986), Innerspace (1987), Great Balls of Fire! (1989), Dragonheart (1996), The Parent Trap (1998), Frequency (2000), The Rookie (2002), The Day After Tomorrow (2004), In Good Company (2004), Flight of the Phoenix (2004), Yours, Mine & Ours (2005), and Vantage Point (2008). He received a Golden Globe Award nomination for his role in Far from Heaven (2002). Quaid has appeared in over a hundred and twenty feature films, and The Guardian named him one of the best actors never to have received an Academy Award nomination.

     

     

    - Links -

     

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events  

     

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

     

    For Dennis Quaid:

     

    On Instagram https://www.instagram.com/dennisquaid/

     

    Reagan (Upcoming film) https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1723808/ 

    449. Trauma and the Demolition of Faith | Ronnie Janoff-Bulman

    449. Trauma and the Demolition of Faith | Ronnie Janoff-Bulman

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down with social psychologist and author, Ronnie Janoff-Bulman. They discuss how most implicit beliefs are consciously unknown to those who hold them; the human reactions to fear, disgust, pain, and the destruction of hope; why people blame themselves for truly random events; what the experts get wrong about motivation; and the difference between proscriptive and prescriptive morality.

     

    Ronnie Janoff-Bulman is Professor Emerita of Psychology and Brain Sciences at the University of Massachusetts-Amherst. She is a social psychologist and the author of two books and over 90 published papers. Her first book, “Shattered Assumptions: Towards a New Psychology of Trauma,” has been cited over 9,500 times. She was awarded a National Science Foundation grant for her research on morality, which serves as the backbone of her recent book, “The Two Moralities: Conservatives, Liberals, and the Roots of Our Political Divide.” She is the recipient of teaching and mentoring awards and is the former editor of Psychological Inquiry, an international journal devoted to advancing theory in psychology.  A mother and grandmother, Dr. Janoff-Bulman lives in Amherst, Massachusetts with her husband of over 50 years.

     

     

    - Links -

     

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events  

     

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

     

    For Ronnie Janoff-Bulman:

     

    Shattered Assumptions (Book) https://www.amazon.com/Shattered-Assumptions-Towards-Psychology-Trauma/dp/0743236254

     

    The Two Moralities (Book) https://www.amazon.com/Two-Moralities-Conservatives-Liberals-Political-ebook/dp/B0BX1JDL8C/?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_w=qQoj5&content-id=amzn1.sym.cf86ec3a-68a6-43e9-8115-04171136930a&pf_rd_p=cf86ec3a-68a6-43e9-8115-04171136930a&pf_rd_r=138-3764402-1287437&pd_rd_wg=H5RDI&pd_rd_r=fccdebc5-a090-4e01-b536-33c552e5005f&ref_=aufs_ap_sc_dsk 

    448. Alternative Walk of Fame | Brett Cooper

    448. Alternative Walk of Fame | Brett Cooper

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down in person with actor, podcaster, and host of “The Comments Section,” Brett Cooper. They discuss the adversity Cooper faced early on which prompted her to try out theater, the landscape of growing up as a child actor, her positive and negative experiences with Hollywood and university, the psychology of exploitation, why she joined The Daily Wire, her upcoming film and television projects, and her motivation to be a voice for young women who embrace their femininity.

     

    Brett Cooper is a viral internet personality, content creator, and actress. She’s best known as the charismatic host of “The Comments Section with Brett Cooper” on YouTube, captivating over 4 million subscribers with her irresistibly irreverent opinions on current news and cultural phenomena. Brett’s rise to digital fame was meteoric, amassing 1 million followers within just six months of launching her show and surpassing 4 million within two years. She moved from Tennessee to Los Angeles at the age of 10 to pursue acting. After years of balancing homeschooling and a professional acting career, Brett honed her art of storytelling while studying English at UCLA. At just 20 years old, Brett returned to Tennessee to launch “The Comments Section with Brett Cooper” at The Daily Wire. Following the show’s rapid success, the rising star is returning to acting in the forthcoming DailyWire+ animated sitcom “Mr. Birchum” and the historical fantasy series “The Pendragon Cycle.” In a debut role, Brett will star as Snow White in “Snow White and the Evil Queen” in the first feature-length production for Bentkey, The Daily Wire’s children’s entertainment platform.

     

     

    - Links -

     

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events  

     

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

     

    For Brett Cooper:

     

    Brett Cooper on X https://twitter.com/imbrettcooper?lang=en

     

    Brett Cooper on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/imbrettcooper/?hl=en

     

    The Comments Section With Brett Cooper on X https://twitter.com/CommentsSection

     

    The Comments Section With Brett Cooper on Youtube https://www.youtube.com/@TheCommentsSection 

    447. Nuclear Power Is Safer Than Wind and Solar | James Walker

    447. Nuclear Power Is Safer Than Wind and Solar | James Walker

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down with nuclear physicist and CEO of Nano Nuclear, James Walker. They discuss why nuclear power is continuously sidelined for less efficient, less safe forms of power, the change from civic — massive — reactors to truck-sized units, the refinement process of uranium, and the true environmental cost of mass poverty.

     

    James Walker is a nuclear physicist and was the project lead and manager for constructing the new Rolls-Royce Nuclear Chemical Plant; he was the UK Subject Matter Expert for the UK Nuclear Material Recovery Capabilities and the technical project manager for constructing the UK reactor core manufacturing facilities. Walker’s professional engineering experience includes nuclear reactors, mines, submarines, chemical plants, factories, mine processing facilities, infrastructure, automotive machinery, and testing rigs. He has executive experience in several public companies, as well as acquiring and redeveloping the only fluorspar mine in the United States.

     

     

    - Links -

     

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events  

     

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

     

    For James Walker:

     

    Nano Nuclear on X https://twitter.com/nano_nuclear

     

    Nano Nuclear (Website) https://nanonuclearenergy.com/

     

    Nano Nuclear on Linkedin https://www.linkedin.com/company/nano-nuclear-energy-inc/ 

    446. War, PTSD, & Psychedelics | Kelsi Sheren

    446. War, PTSD, & Psychedelics | Kelsi Sheren

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down in person with veteran, entrepreneur, podcaster, and author, Kelsi Sheren. They discuss her upbringing, the discipline required for service, the necessity and reality of women in the armed forces, the lapse in standards at the hands of DEI, the trauma and PTSD incurred from combat, and how soldiers find solace when reintegrating with civilized life.

     

    Kelsi Sheren is CEO of Brass & Unity and author of “Brass and Unity, One Woman’s Journey Through the Hell of Afghanistan and Back.” Kelsi is a distinguished Canadian veteran, who served as a Gunner and Female Searcher during her deployment in Afghanistan. At Brass & Unity, Kelsi transforms bullet casings into jewelry, donating a portion of the profits to support veterans battling mental health issues. In addition to her work in the military, Kelsi is a champion in Taekwondo, and host of the Brass & Unity podcast.

     

     

    - Links -

     

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events  

     

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

     

    For Kelsi Sheren:

     

    On X https://twitter.com/KelsiBurns?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor

     

    On Instagram https://www.instagram.com/kelsie_sheren/?hl=en

     

    “Brass & Unity: One Woman’s Journey Through the Hell of Afghanistan and Back” (Book) https://www.amazon.com/Brass-Unity-Journey-Through-Afghanistan/dp/1637588917

     

    Brass & Unity Podcast https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCWCy2PRfqQZraiSCocX4Gyw

     

    Brass & Unity Website https://brassandunity.com/ 

    444. The Collective Unconscious, Christ, and the Covenant | Russell Brand

    444. The Collective Unconscious, Christ, and the Covenant | Russell Brand

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down with actor and podcaster Russell Brand. They discuss the language of symbols, the collective unconscious, the evolution of theology, and why so many public intellectuals are coming back to Christ.

     

    Russell Brand is an English comedian, actor, podcaster, and commentator. He first established himself as a stand up comedian and radio host before becoming a film actor. He presented for MTV UK and made appearances across media and TV throughout the 2000’s. In 2008, he leapt from British to U.S. film acting, appearing in the hit film “Forgetting Sarah Marshall,” followed by numerous international successes. In 2013, Brand guest-edited an edition of the weekly publication the New Statesman, launching his interest and later career as a political activist and commentator. His current podcast, Stay Free, sees Brand calling out major news, governments, and corporations for affronts to free speech, expression, spirituality, and thought.

     

     

    - Links -

     

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events  

     

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

     

    For Russell Brand:

     

    Stay Free on Rumble https://rumble.com/c/russellbrand

     

    Stay Free on Youtube https://www.youtube.com/@RussellBrand

     

    On X https://twitter.com/rustyrockets 

    443. The Brutal Reality of the Middle East | Mosab Hassan Yousef

    443. The Brutal Reality of the Middle East | Mosab Hassan Yousef

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down in person with Mosab Hassan Yousef. They discuss the ongoing conflict in the Middle East, the chaos created by Yasser Arafat, how Palestine has globalized their radical cause, Mosabs time as a prisoner, what set him free, and the far-from-paved road going forward.

     

    Mosab Hassan Yousef (born in 1978) is a Palestinian ex-militant who defected to Israel in 1997 where he worked as an undercover agent for the Shin Bet until he moved to the United States in 2007. Yousef was considered the Shin Bet's most reliable source in the Hamas leadership, earning himself the nickname "The Green Prince.” The intelligence he supplied to Israel led to the exposure of many Hamas cells, as well as the prevention of dozens of suicide bombings and assassination attempts on Jews. Yousef's father is Sheikh Hassan Yousef, a co-founder of Hamas.

     

     

    - Links -

     

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events  

     

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

     

    For Mosab Hassan Yousef:

     

    On X https://twitter.com/MosabHasanYOSEF?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor

     

    “Son of Hamas: A Gripping Account of Terror, Betrayal, Political Intrigue, and Unthinkable Choices” (book) https://www.amazon.com/Son-of-Hamas-Mosab-Hassan-Yousef-audiobook/dp/B006PJC4H2/?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_w=PheAV&content-id=amzn1.sym.cf86ec3a-68a6-43e9-8115-04171136930a&pf_rd_p=cf86ec3a-68a6-43e9-8115-04171136930a&pf_rd_r=138-3764402-1287437&pd_rd_wg=fLHUm&pd_rd_r=8445617a-f7bd-45ef-bcff-98e77e6b26f5&ref_=aufs_ap_sc_dsk 

    442. BILL C-63 - Everything You Need to Know | Bruce Pardy & Konstantin Kisin

    442. BILL C-63 - Everything You Need to Know | Bruce Pardy & Konstantin Kisin

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down in-person with Canadian lawyer Bruce Pardy and podcaster Konstantin Kisin. They discuss Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Bill C-63 (aka The Online Harms Act), what powers it gives to the government, what rights it strips from citizens, and why even Americans should be concerned.


    Bruce Pardy is executive director of Rights Probe, a law and liberty thinktank, and professor of law at Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario, Canada. He is a lawyer, academic, columnist, and outspoken critic of the illiberal managerial state, fighting at the front lines of the culture war inside the law. Bruce writes for the National Post, Epoch Times, and the Brownstone Institute, among others, and serves as senior fellow at the Fraser Institute, the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, and the Frontier Centre for Public Policy. He has taught at law schools in Canada, the United States and New Zealand, practiced civil litigation in Toronto, and served as adjudicator and mediator on the Ontario Environmental Tribunal. The legal ground, Bruce has written, is shifting beneath our feet. The individual is losing to the collective. An ever-expanding bureaucracy regulates life from cradle to grave, including private behavior and speech, in the name of common good. The law has become discretionary, arbitrary, and unequal. The end of Western liberal civilization, as we have known it, is conceivable.
     

    Konstantin Kisin is a Russian-British satirist, social commentator, and co-host of the TRIGGERnometry Youtube show. He is also the author of “An Immigrant's Love Letter to the West,” a Sunday Times bestseller. He has written for several publications, including Quillette, The Spectator, The Daily Telegraph, and Standpoint, on issues relating to tech censorship, woke culture, comedy, and other topics, but he currently publishes articles on his popular Substack. Kisin made headlines in 2018 when he refused to sign a "safe space contract" to perform comedy at a British college and again in 2023 when he participated in an Oxford Union debate on the motion of "This House Believes Woke Culture Has Gone Too Far." His speech at the debate received viral attention and has been seen by over 100 million people around the world.

     


     

    - Links -

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events   

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

    For Bruce Pardy:

    On X https://twitter.com/pardybruce?lang=en

    Rights Probe: https://www.rightsprobe.org/


    For Konstantin Kisin:

    TRIGGERnometry Podcast    / @triggerpod  

    Substack https://konstantinkisin.substack.com/

    Twitter https://twitter.com/KonstantinKisin?r...

    441. TBD | Tor Nørretranders

    441. TBD | Tor Nørretranders

    Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down with author and speaker Tor Nørretranders. They discuss the entropy of emotion, the nature of pointlessness, the over-civilization of societal structures, how relationships shape perception, and why play might be the antithesis to tyranny.

     

    Tor Nørretranders is an independent author, thinker and speaker based in Denmark, serving an international audience. He has published over 30 books on topics ranging from society to human consciousness.

     

     

    - Links -

     

    2024 tour details can be found here https://jordanbpeterson.com/events  

     

    Peterson Academy https://petersonacademy.com/  

     

     

    For Tor Nørretranders:

     

    The User Illusion:

    https://www.amazon.com/User-Illusion-Cutting-Consciousness-Penguin/dp/0140230122

     

    The Generous Man:

    https://www.amazon.com/Generous-Man-Helping-Others-Sexiest/dp/B005SNMU4I

     

    Wild food and agriculture:

    https://madfeed.co/video/from-wild-to-tame-and-back-again/

    https://madfeed.co/video/we-are-here-because-we-have-appetite/

    https://madfeed.co/video/whos-got-the-guts/

     

    Website https://www.tor.dk/

     

    Article “We Are Waking Up” : https://www.tor.dk/2019/05/06/we-are-waking-up/