Putting Our Assumptions to the Test

    Acknowledging uncertainty is crucial to seeking truthful answers, but it can be difficult to convey effectively. Experts must remain humble and recognize their susceptibility to being wrong.

    enMarch 07, 2022

    About this Episode

    Do you ever stop to wonder if the way you see the world is how the world really is?  Economist Abhijit Banerjee has spent a lifetime asking himself this question. His answer: Our world views often don't reflect reality. The only way to get more accurate is to think like a scientist — even when you're not looking through a microscope. 

    If you like this show, please check out our new podcast, My Unsung Hero! And if you’d like to support our work, you can do so at support.hiddenbrain.org.

    🔑 Key Takeaways

    • To gain a deeper understanding of the world, we must break away from our biases and see things from others' perspectives. Questioning our own theories and experiencing life firsthand can provide valuable insights.
    • Childhood experiences can have a profound impact on shaping one's perspective and driving innovative research. Skepticism and questioning inflated claims can lead to impactful breakthroughs.
    • Abhijit Banerjee's experiment-based approach to economics won him the Nobel Prize, proving the significance of combining theory with empirical evidence to solve real-world troubles, rather than depending on sweeping theories and complex mathematics.
    • Abhijit Banerjee's focus on observational studies emphasizes the need to go beyond traditional theories of poverty to create impactful change. Understanding the complex reality of poverty is key to creating sustainable solutions.
    • By conducting controlled experiments and focusing on details, breakthroughs have been made in medicine (the AIDS cocktail) and economics (understanding the impact of teacher numbers on students). Evidence-based decisions are essential in all fields.
    • Simply adding more teachers to a school cannot improve test scores in the Indian education system. It is important to reexamine assumptions and find ways to integrate students who fall behind.
    • By investing in better teaching methods and targeted interventions, we can help students make significant progress. Even small incentives like rewards can be effective in increasing vaccination rates and disproving traditional assumptions.
    • Offering practical incentives, like lentils, can improve vaccination rates among low-income communities. Experimentation teaches us about the human capacity for insight and humility, and boosts our understanding of how the body functions.
    • Relying on anecdotes and ideological arguments can be misleading in policymaking. Proper research and experimentation is crucial for effective policy-making, like the success of distributing free bednets to fight malaria.
    • While transparency is important, it can lead to bureaucracy and hinders skepticism. Randomized testing should be approached with humility and without preconceived notions for better public discourse. Don't let values overshadow critical analysis.
    • Acknowledging uncertainty is crucial to seeking truthful answers, but it can be difficult to convey effectively. Experts must remain humble and recognize their susceptibility to being wrong.

    📝 Podcast Summary

    The Importance of Questioning Our Perspectives and Understanding the World Through Experience

    The lens through which we view the world determines our understanding of events. Our cultural, ideological, and personal perspectives shape our theories about life. However, we must acknowledge that these are just theories and question their validity. Abhijit Banerjee, Nobel Prize winner in Economics, learned the importance of observing and experiencing life to truly understand it. His childhood experiences with the poorer neighborhood kids taught him valuable lessons about competition and wisdom. We must break away from our preferred stories and see the world through the eyes of others to gain a deep understanding and appreciation.

    Abhijit Banerjee's Childhood Experiences that Shaped his Nobel Prize-Winning Work

    Abhijit Banerjee’s childhood experiences helped shape his perspective on the world, leading to his Nobel Prize-winning work. He had close ties with kids from the slums but did not see them as objects of pity or scorn. Instead, he was more skeptical, questioning the armchair theorizing of the well-educated. Banerjee was a really bad student and was perceived to be untalented by his teachers. They developed a theory to fit the pieces together, satisfying Abhijit's parents, but it did little to change his trajectory. This shows how powerful stories generated unconsciously can obscure the truth. These experiences inspired Banerjee to be a skeptic and question inflated claims, leading to his innovative and impactful research.

    Abhijit Banerjee's Empirical Road to the Nobel Prize in Economics

    Abhijit Banerjee's teenage reaction to Marxist ideologies in his hometown, Calcutta, led him to develop an empirical approach to economics in his later career. He became known for asking irritating questions and challenging people's assumptions, favoring a more granular understanding of how things work rather than big sweeping theories. Despite following the norms of his field and spending years developing intricate models with complex mathematics and little field experiments, Banerjee, along with Esther Duflo and Michael Kremer, won the Nobel Prize in Economics for their experimental approach to alleviating global poverty. This award highlights the importance of combining theory with empirical evidence to effectively address real-world problems.

    Abhijit Banerjee's Approach to Understanding Poverty

    Abhijit Banerjee, an economist, found many theories of poverty to be shallow and unsatisfying. He realized that neither the libertarian nor the Marxist theories of poverty truly capture the complexity of poverty. Abhijit reflected on how medicine had experienced a revolution by shifting from theoretical reasoning to observational studies. He believed that the field of economics should also focus on observational studies to understand the true reasons for poverty. This inspired him to study the lives of poor people in India, leading to groundbreaking research in development economics. Abhijit's approach highlights the importance of going beyond superficial theories and understanding the complexities of poverty to create meaningful change.

    The scientific method in medicine and economics.

    The approach of conducting controlled experiments to determine the truth has revolutionized medicine and is now being applied to economics. This approach involves spending less time arguing about theories and more time studying details. Instead of grand theories, the focus is on granular details of how things work. This approach has led to major breakthroughs, such as the AIDS cocktail, which saved millions of lives. An example of this approach in economics is a field experiment conducted in Rajasthan, India, which aimed to understand how to run an experiment. The experiment tested the theory that doubling the number of teachers would lead to better test scores, but the results showed otherwise, demonstrating the importance of evidence-based decision making in all fields.

    The Impact of Increasing Teachers on Student Performance in India

    Doubling the number of teachers in a school does not necessarily improve test scores, as the Indian education system is designed to deliver content with no mechanism for integrating students who fall behind. This is especially true in underprivileged areas where students may not have parental support and may be shellshocked by the learning process. When confronted with data that goes against our preconceived models, it is important to not dismiss it and double down on our beliefs, but instead reexamine our assumptions and adjust accordingly.

    The Power of Targeted Interventions and Better Teaching Methods

    Focusing on better teaching methods for students rather than assuming they are unteachable can have a significant impact on their progress. Additionally, offering small incentives like rewards for vaccinations can increase vaccination rates. Traditional views and assumptions about lack of government supply systems or primitive beliefs can often be disproven with targeted interventions and solutions.

    Incentives Beyond Vaccination: Abhijit Banerjee's Experimental Approach.

    Giving incentives unrelated to the vaccine, such as lentils, can increase vaccination rates among poor communities. This approach focuses on practical solutions instead of blaming incompetence or primitive beliefs for low vaccination rates. Abhijit Banerjee's experimental approach to poverty alleviation has revolutionized economics by improving theories through experiments. Experimentation improves our understanding of how the body functions and can teach us about the human capacity for insight and humility.

    The Power of Evidence-Based Research for Effective Policy-Making

    Running experiments to determine the best public policy is a more effective approach than relying on ideological arguments or anecdotes. The success of distributing free bednets to fight malaria relied on evidence-based research rather than assumptions that people would not value them if given for free. Anecdotes can be seductive and lead to sweeping conclusions, but storytelling without adequate data can be misleading. The act of storytelling often pivots on extreme examples that are particularly compelling but tend to over inform us. Instead of relying on anecdotes, policymakers should prioritize evidence-based research and experimentation for effective policy-making.

    The Pitfalls of Transparency in the Workplace

    While transparency is often seen as a good thing, it can also have unintended consequences such as resentment and frustration in the workplace. The belief in transparency as a value can lead to inefficient bureaucracy and red tape. Our values often drive storytelling, which can obscure the truth and make it harder to be skeptical of our own stories. Randomized control trials can challenge preconceived notions, but the experiment must be conducted with an open mind and humility. The insistence on evidence-based methodologies is crucial for improving the public conversation. Ultimately, we must be careful not to let our values and theories guide our experimentation and analysis.

    Recognizing and Conveying Uncertainty in Seeking Answers

    Abhijit Banerjee highlights the importance of recognizing uncertainty when seeking answers and the difficulty of conveying uncertainty. People often hear what they want to hear and ignore the possible range of answers. As someone with expert status, Abhijit acknowledges the temptation to speak with certainty, but also recognizes the danger in doing so. He emphasizes the need for humility and acknowledges that everyone, including himself, is susceptible to being fooled. Ultimately, there is no perfect resolution to this dilemma, and economists like Abhijit must navigate this tension while recognizing the potential implications of their words and actions.

    Recent Episodes from Hidden Brain

    Innovation 2.0: Shortcuts and Speed Bumps

    Innovation 2.0: Shortcuts and Speed Bumps

    Most of us love to brainstorm with colleagues. But so often, our idea-generating sessions don't lead to anything tangible. Teams fill up walls with sticky notes about creative possibilities and suggestions for improvement, but nothing actually gets implemented. Some researchers even have a name for it: "innovation theater." This week, we explore the science of execution. Psychologist Bob Sutton tells us how to move from innovation theater . . . to actual innovation.

    You can find all the episodes in our Innovation 2.0 series in this podcast feed, or on our website, hiddenbrain.org

    Hidden Brain
    enMay 20, 2024

    Innovation 2.0: The Influence You Have

    Innovation 2.0: The Influence You Have

    Think about the last time you asked someone for something. Maybe you were nervous or worried about what the person would think of you. Chances are that you didn’t stop to think about the pressure you were exerting on that person. This week, we continue our Innovation 2.0 series with a 2020 episode about a phenomenon known as as “egocentric bias.” We talk with psychologist Vanessa Bohns about how this bias leads us astray, and how we can use this knowledge to ask for the things we need. 

    Did you catch the first two episodes in our Innovation 2.0 series? You can find them in this podcast feed or on our website. And if you're enjoying this series, please share it with a friend or family member. Thanks! 

    Hidden Brain
    enMay 13, 2024

    Innovation 2.0: Multiplying the Growth Mindset

    Innovation 2.0: Multiplying the Growth Mindset

    Have you ever been in a situation where you felt that people wrote you off? Maybe a teacher suggested you weren't talented enough to take a certain class, or a boss implied that you didn't have the smarts needed to handle a big project. In the latest in our "Innovation 2.0 series," we talk with Mary Murphy, who studies what she calls "cultures of genius." We'll look at how these cultures can keep people and organizations from thriving, and how we can create environments that better foster our growth.

    Do you know someone who'd find the ideas in today's episode to be useful? Please share it with them! And if you liked today's conversation, you might also like these classic Hidden Brain episodes: 

     The Edge Effect

    The Secret to Great Teams

    Dream Jobs

    Innovation 2.0: How Big Ideas Are Born

    Innovation 2.0: How Big Ideas Are Born

    Why is it so hard to guess where we're meant to be? To predict where we'll end up? Nearly all of us have had the experience of traveling down one road, only to realize it's not the road for us. At the University of Virginia, Saras Sarasvathy uses the lens of entrepreneurship to study how we plan and prepare for the future. We kick off our new "Innovation 2.0" series by talking with Saras about how we pursue goals and make decisions.

    Do you know someone who might benefit from our conversation with Saras about expert entrepreneurs? Please share it with them if so! And be sure to check out our other conversations about how to get out of ruts and figure out a path forward: 

    Who Do You Want to Be?

    You 2.0 : How to Break Out of a Rut

    Parents: Keep Out!

    Parents: Keep Out!

    If you're a parent or a teacher, you've probably wondered how to balance play and safety for the kids in your care. You don't want to put children in danger, but you also don't want to rob them of the joy of exploration. This week, we talk with psychologist Peter Gray about how this balance has changed — for parents and children alike — and what we can do about it.

    For more of our reporting on children and parents, check out these classic Hidden Brain episodes:


    Bringing Up Baby 


    The Curious Science of Cravings

    The Curious Science of Cravings

    We've all had those days when all we want is a little treat. Maybe it's a bag of chips, an ice cream sundae or a glass of wine. But sometimes, these desires become all-consuming. This week on the show, psychiatrist Judson Brewer helps us understand the science of cravings, and how we should respond to them. 

    If you liked today's conversation, be sure to check out other Hidden Brain episodes about ways to regain a feeling of control over your life: Creatures of Habit and Taking Control of Your Time.

    What Is Normal?

    What Is Normal?

    Anthropologist Tom Pearson was devastated after his daughter Michaela was diagnosed with Down syndrome. When he began to examine that emotional response, he found himself wrestling with questions that have roiled his field for decades. Early anthropologists would often compare people of different backgrounds and abilities, asking questions like: How is one group different from another? Which one is stronger or smarter? And how do we understand people who don’t fit our expectations? This week, we talk with Pearson about his family’s story, and the evolution of our thinking on disability and difference.

    If you liked today's show, be sure to check out these classic Hidden Brain episodes:

    "Emma, Carrie, Vivian"

    "Why You're Smarter than You Think"


    The Transformative Ideas of Daniel Kahneman

    The Transformative Ideas of Daniel Kahneman

    If you've ever taken an economics class, you were probably taught that people are rational. But about 50 years ago, the psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky began to chip away at this basic assumption. In doing so, they transformed our understanding of human behavior. This week, we remember Kahneman, who recently died at the age of 90, by revisiting our 2018 and 2021 conversations with him. 

    If you enjoyed this look at the work of Daniel Kahneman, you might also enjoy our conversations about behavioral economics with Kahneman's friend and collaborator Richard Thaler: 

    Misbehaving with Richard Thaler 

    Follow the Anomalies 

    Are You Listening?

    Are You Listening?

    Have you ever sat across from your spouse, colleague or friend and realized that while they may be hearing what you're saying, they aren't actually listening? Poor listening can lead to arguments, hurt feelings, and fractured relationships. But the good news is that active, thoughtful listening can profoundly benefit both people in the conversation. This week on the show, psychologist Guy Itzchakov helps us understand where interactions go awry, and how to become a more attentive listener. 

    For more of our work on how to better connect with the people in your life, check out these episodes:

     Why Conversations Go Wrong with Deborah Tannen

    A Secret Source of Connection with Amit Kumar

    Relationships 2.0: What Makes Relationships Thrive with Harry Reis

    Relationships 2.0: How to Keep Conflict from Spiraling with Julia Minson 


    The Ventilator

    The Ventilator

    Many of us believe we know how we’d choose to die. We have a sense of how we’d respond to a diagnosis of an incurable illness. This week, we revisit a 2019 episode featuring one family’s decades-long conversation about dying. What they found is that the people we are when death is far in the distance may not be the people we become when death is near.

    If you enjoyed today's episode, here are some more classic Hidden Brain episodes you might like:

    The Cowboy Philosopher

    When You Need It To Be True 

    Me, Myself, and Ikea 

    Thanks for listening!