Logo
    Search

    Who's going to win the "£2,000" debate?

    enJune 05, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Political Debates, TaxationClaims about additional household costs in political debates require factual basis and not speculative policies or misrepresentations from special advisers

      During a recent debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer, Sunak made a claim about Labour's plans leading to an additional £2,000 in costs per household. However, the calculation behind this figure was controversial, as it originated from Tory special advisers and not the impartial civil service as Sunak suggested. Labour and other parties have criticized this claim, arguing it's based on speculative policies. Despite this, Sunak has continued to emphasize the figure. This episode highlights the significance of taxation as a major attack point for political parties and the potential for misleading or misrepresented figures in political debates. In other news, Ryan Reynolds announced a significant price drop for Mint Mobile's Unlimited plan, cutting it from $30 to $15 a month. Additionally, Sharon introduced the Olive and Jude mani system, offering salon-perfect nails for just $2 a manicure. These stories illustrate the ongoing political landscape and the importance of factual information in both business and politics.

    • Political dishonestyBoth Conservative and Labour parties used misleading figures during the debate, detracting from the political discourse and lacking transparency

      Last night's political debate was marked by misleading figures, with both the Conservative and Labour parties engaging in questionable tactics. The Conservative Party's claim of a £2,000 tax cut for workers was called into question by the most senior civil servant in the Treasury, who stated that civil servants had not been involved in the production or presentation of the document. This misleading figure echoes past instances of political dishonesty, such as the £350 million claim for NHS funding from Brexit. Labour, on the other hand, also used misleading figures in their tax dossier, calculating potential tax rises based on suggestions rather than confirmed policies. Keir Starmer, the Labour leader, missed an opportunity to shut down the Conservative Party's misleading figure by not bringing up the letter from the permanent secretary of the Treasury that debunked it during the debate. The lack of substantial new information and the deteriorating quality of the debate were other notable takeaways. Ultimately, the debate was marked by a lack of transparency and a focus on misleading figures, which is detrimental to the political discourse.

    • NHS and election debateRishi Sunak's background as a son of NHS workers and his stance on respecting the healthcare system raised questions during the election debate. Keir Starmer was criticized for lacking a clear plan, while tax issues dominated post-debate conversation.

      That the NHS issue played a significant role in the election debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer. Sunak's background as a son of NHS workers and his stance on respecting the healthcare system raised questions about his actions during a hypothetical personal crisis. Meanwhile, Starmer was criticized for lacking a clear plan. Sunak also made an implicit appeal to voters to prevent a potential Farage victory. The debate saw some humorous moments, but its impact on the election outcome is uncertain, as evidenced by the decrease in viewership compared to the 2019 debate. Despite the lackluster performance, both parties were generally satisfied with their leaders' performances. The tax issue dominated the post-debate conversation, with Sunak taking a more aggressive stance and Starmer playing a more defensive game due to his polling lead. Ultimately, the fundamentals of the election have not changed, and it remains to be seen if any significant developments will emerge in the coming weeks.

    • Leaders debate impactThe recent leaders debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer did not significantly shift public perception among debate viewers, but Labour holds a significant lead in the election and the debate may have influenced the enthusiasm of certain voter groups in the short term.

      The recent leaders debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer did not significantly shift public perception based on available polling data among debate viewers, which may not accurately represent the larger voting population. Keir Starmer led on economic issues, but Rishi Sunak had a notable lead on tax concerns, touching on voters' existing prejudices about what Labour might do to taxes. However, this election stands out as Labour holds a significant lead, and the outcome may not be heavily influenced by the debate. The debate did capture narratives and potentially influenced the enthusiasm of certain voter groups in the short term, but the impact was likely minimal beyond that.

    • UK election taxes and economyVoters' priorities have shifted from debt and austerity to wages, prices, and cost of living, and openness about raising taxes on specific items could give credibility to a candidate.

      The economic narrative and voters' perception of taxes in the UK election are not mutually exclusive. While the economy and taxes are related, voters' priorities have shifted from austerity and debt to wages, prices, and cost of living. Starmer's openness about raising taxes on specific items, such as private schools and non-doms, could even give him credibility with some voters. However, Sunak's hardline stance on taxes might not be as damaging if he can frame it as targeting specific groups or items, like private schools and non-doms, rather than the broader population. Ultimately, voters' decisions are influenced by a complex interplay of factors beyond just taxes and the economy.

    • Farage's impact on Conservative votesReform UK, led by Nigel Farage, could draw significant votes from the Conservative Party, potentially costing them around 60 seats in the next election

      Nigel Farage's return to frontline politics could potentially draw more voters from the Conservative Party to Reform UK, especially among Boris Johnson's 2019 base. According to the polls, Reform UK currently has around 11.6% of the votes, which is not far from UKIP's 12.6% in 2015. While it's too early to tell if this trend will continue, it could potentially cost the Conservatives around 60 seats if they lose 1-2 points of their votes to Reform UK, and those votes are added to Labour's total. This shift in voter preferences could be due to Rishi Sunak's lack of popularity among the Conservative base compared to Farage. However, it's important to note that these numbers are based on current polling data and could change as the election approaches.

    • UK Election OutcomeThe UK election outcome is uncertain with a significant margin of error, and the Conservative Party could experience a surprising comeback or annihilation.

      The upcoming UK election results are uncertain and could lead to significant shifts in the political landscape. The Conservative Party, which has historically been one of the most successful in the western world, is currently facing the possibility of an annihilation or a surprising comeback, with the range of potential outcomes being quite narrow. The polls indicate a large lead for Labour, but there is a significant error margin, which could result in a surprising outcome. Additionally, the increasing number of marginal seats due to population changes and boundary adjustments adds to the uncertainty of the election results. It's important to keep in mind that the eventual outcome could be quite different from current polling data, and the margin of error is significant.

    • UK General Election Gains for Liberal DemocratsPotential Liberal Democrat gains in UK General Election could exceed current polling predictions due to tactical voting and local election results, emphasizing the importance of considering the quality and representativeness of polling data.

      The upcoming UK general election could see significant gains for the Liberal Democrats, potentially winning over 60 seats based on local election results and tactical voting patterns. This is more than current polling predictions, and it's important to note that different polling models, like MRP, have varying methods and sources of data. MRP models use large, complex statistical samples, while some other models, like Britain Predicts, base their predictions on local election results and demographic data. The quality of the sample data is crucial, and skewed samples can lead to inaccurate results. As we move forward with polling and election predictions, it's essential to consider where the data is coming from and how representative it is.

    • UK Election OutcomeDespite deep irritation among some voters, Labour is more likely to survive the upcoming UK election than the Conservatives, according to current data and analysis.

      The current political landscape in the UK, as of now, does not seem to favor a Conservative victory in the upcoming election. According to the data and analysis discussed, the Conservatives are not expected to regain power on July 5th. However, it's important to note that bookies' odds and polls don't always accurately predict election outcomes. For instance, George Galloway's surprising win in the Bradford West by-election in 2012, despite having long odds against him, serves as a reminder of this. While there is deep irritation among some voters, particularly British Muslims and British Asians, over Labour's handling of issues like Israel and Palestine, the majority still seem to support Labour. A high turnout may not be enough for a surprise win for non-mainstream candidates. Overall, the current situation suggests that Labour is more likely to survive the election rather than winning it outright.

    Recent Episodes from The New Statesman Podcast

    Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

    Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

    "Vote SNP for Scotland to become an independent country" - bold letters shout from the first page of the SNP manifesto. But is there still momentum for independence in Scotland? And what else is John Swinney pledging in his fight to retain seats from the hands of Scottish Labour.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Chris Deerin, Scotland editor, and Ben Walker, senior data journalist.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Andrew Marr: Labour must prepare for the turning tide

    Andrew Marr: Labour must prepare for the turning tide

    Labour are set to win a majority, if not a supermajority, but in these politically fragmented times will people who vote for the party necessarily stay loyal in their support after July the fifth?

     

    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by political editor Andrew Marr to discuss the changing political tides, Starmer's continued struggle with tax and Corbyn, and the potential return of Boris Johnson.

     

    Register to vote: https://www.gov.uk/register-to-vote

     

    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    How Reform UK found £50billion down the back of the sofa

    How Reform UK found £50billion down the back of the sofa

    Nigel Farage and Richard Tice have been playing good cop bad cop today in Merthyr Tydfil, not launching Reform UK's manifesto, but the party's "contract". The pitch contains some dramatic pledges and mathematical gymnastics.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call


    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Why is Jeremy Hunt love bombing affluent voters in Surrey?

    Why is Jeremy Hunt love bombing affluent voters in Surrey?

    On today's episode of listener questions: How many of them 2019 manifesto commitments have been met?; Who will be the biggest name to lose their seat?; If Jeremy Corbyn wins as an independent, assuming he'd like to continue to sit with old allies, could he sit on the government benches?; Is there a reason why D-Day is a bigger deal than eg Boris stealing a journalist's phone and hiding in a fridge?; What is the best response when a candidate that you do not want to win knocks on your door?


    Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, is joined by senior editor George Eaton.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Money Money Money (Keir Starmer's version)

    Money Money Money (Keir Starmer's version)

    In the words of ABBA, and Keir Starmer, Money Money Money - the Labour leader announced this morning in Manchester that wealth creation was the ‘number one priority’ for the party.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, and senior editor George Eaton to analyse the final manifesto's of the week from Labour and Plaid Cymru, and to review the odds on the latest Tory gaff.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Conservatives are headed for a "superdefeat"

    The Conservatives are headed for a "superdefeat"

    Grant Shapps has said that Labour could be on course for a “supermajority”, perhaps a more accurate way of viewing it is that the Conservatives are on course for a "superdefeat". But if the Tory vote crashes the votes aren't necessarily going to Labour, so how will they be split?


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by senior data journalist Ben Walker to review the polls and also analyse the Green manifesto launch.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Andrew Marr: Could Tory tax cuts hurt the poorest?

    Andrew Marr: Could Tory tax cuts hurt the poorest?

    It's Tory manifesto Tuesday and the party is leading with pledges to make homes more affordable for first time buyers as well as a fresh new batch of tax cuts. But where is the money coming from to afford this? When the Conservatives say "welfare reform", what exactly do they mean?

     

    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by political editor Andrew Marr. Together they also discuss the rise of the far right in Europe and what this might mean for a Labour-led Britain.

     

    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Does the Lib Dem manifesto add up?

    Does the Lib Dem manifesto add up?

    It's manifesto week! It's week three of the election campaign and parties are set to deliver their manifestos in the coming days. This was kicked off today with the launch of the Lib Dem manifesto. So what have they pledged? Do the numbers add up? And does it really matter if they don't?


    The team also discuss what's been happening politically over the weekend, including Friday's seven headed debate, the continuation of Sunak's D Day-gate, and Macron's decision to call a snap election.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor; Chris Deerin, Scotland editor; and Will Dunn, business editor.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Has Rishi Sunak just destroyed his own campaign?

    Has Rishi Sunak just destroyed his own campaign?

    Freddie, Ben and podcast newcomer Finn McRedmond answer listener questions.


    By deserting the D-day commemorations, Rishi Sunak has dealt his own campaign a massive blow and handed Keir Starmer and Nigel Farage explosive attack lines.


    In this special election edition of You Ask Us, the team answer your questions about the threat to the Conservatives from Reform UK and the impact of TV debates. Also polling expert Ben Walker reveals the shocking impact tactical voting could have on the Liberal Democrats election hopes.


    See the latest polls on the New Statesman's State of the Nation: https://sotn.newstatesman.com/


    Read:

    Rishi Sunak's D-Day departure was far worse than a gaffe

    https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2024/06/rishi-sunaks-d-day-departure-was-far-worse-than-a-gaffe


    The Conservative party may not survive this election

    https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2024/06/conservative-party-may-not-survive-election-nigel-farage



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Who really holds power on the left?

    Who really holds power on the left?

    The most powerful person on the left of British politics is not Keir Starmer. So who is it?


    This week the New Statesman published the 2024 Left Power List, which ranks the 50 most influential people in British politics. George Eaton edited the list and joins Hannah Barnes and Freddie Hayward on the New Statesman podcast to discuss who's up, who's down, and what their influence means for the general election.


    Hannah, Freddie and George also discuss the latest events from the general election campaigns including Vaughan Gethin's confidence vote, more questionable Tory donations and Ed Davey's moving campaign video.


    See the Left Power List in full here: https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk-politics/2024/06/new-statesman-left-power-list-2024



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.