Logo
    Search

    Special Episode: Dr. Paul Offit & Tell Me When It’s Over

    enJune 04, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Mystery and KnowledgeMobile game June's Journey offers detective skills test while podcast This Podcast Will Kill You interviews Dr. Paul Offit, debunking COVID myths and discussing importance of science communication in post-pandemic world

      June's Journey is a mobile mystery game that offers players a chance to test their detective skills as they help the main character, June Parker, unravel a series of mysteries, including her sister's murder. The game allows players to join a detective club, where they can chat with other players and compete. Meanwhile, in the world of podcasts, This Podcast Will Kill You's latest episode features an interview with Dr. Paul Offit, discussing his book, Tell Me When It's Over. The book serves as a guide to navigating the post-pandemic world by debunking COVID myths and addressing the rise of anti-science sentiment. Offit's extensive background in vaccinology and public health makes him an expert on the topic. The book also touches on the origins of SARS-CoV-2, the virus responsible for the pandemic, and the importance of effective science communication. Overall, both June's Journey and Tell Me When It's Over provide unique perspectives on mystery and knowledge, inviting audiences to engage in captivating narratives and important discussions.

    • FDA's loss of public trustThe rush to approve hydroxychloroquine without sufficient evidence and the pressure to release a vaccine before the election significantly contributed to the FDA's loss of public trust during the COVID-19 pandemic, despite the subsequent development and distribution of effective vaccines.

      The COVID-19 pandemic brought about unprecedented challenges for public health agencies like the FDA, leading to a critical loss of trust from the public. The rush to approve hydroxychloroquine without sufficient evidence and the pressure to release a vaccine before the election were major contributors to this mistrust. The author, who served on the FDA's vaccine advisory committee, wrote a book detailing these events and the remarkable scientific accomplishments that followed, including the development and distribution of effective vaccines. However, despite these achievements, 30% of the population refused to get vaccinated due to distrust in public health agencies. The book explores how this trust was lost and offers insights on how it can be regained. The intended audience for the book is the general public, and the author believes it's a story of contrasting achievements and challenges in the fight against the pandemic.

    • Anti-vaccine movementThe anti-vaccine movement's political and partisan nature, fueled by social media, has led to a decline in vaccine compliance rates during the COVID-19 pandemic

      The decline in vaccine compliance rates during the COVID-19 pandemic is not what was expected, despite the widespread availability and effectiveness of vaccines. This phenomenon can be attributed to the strength and funding of the anti-vaccine movement, which has become increasingly political and partisan. Social media plays a significant role in facilitating the spread of misinformation and conspiracy theories about vaccines, making it easier for hesitant individuals to find and believe harmful information. The anti-vaccine movement's success in capitalizing on mandates and restrictions during the pandemic has led to a well-funded and influential libertarian anti-vaccine campaign that has gained support from the right. Identifying the drivers of anti-vaccine disinformation campaigns can be challenging, but understanding the political motivations and the role of social media is a crucial step in combating the spread of misinformation and promoting scientific literacy.

    • Financial motivations and personal freedomsFinancial motivations and personal freedoms can influence the appeal of certain beliefs, particularly in relation to unsupported claims in the dietary supplement industry. Effective communication of complex scientific issues is crucial to prevent misunderstandings and the spread of misinformation.

      The appeal of certain beliefs, such as those surrounding autonomy and scientific communication, can be driven by financial motivations and the desire for personal freedoms. This was discussed in relation to the alignment between groups promoting unsupported claims and the dietary supplement industry. The scientific community's training to be cautious and avoid going beyond the data can make it difficult to effectively communicate complex scientific issues to the public, leading to misunderstandings and the spread of misinformation. Conspiracy theories, like those surrounding microchips in COVID vaccines, are appealing because they offer clear explanations, even if they are not based in fact. It's important for scientists and medical professionals to find ways to communicate complex scientific information more effectively to the public, while also acknowledging the limitations of the scientific method.

    • COVID-19 originCOVID-19 originated from an animal spillover event at the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan, China, not a lab leak. Evidence includes the presence of the virus in animal cages and slaughtering tools, historical precedent, and lack of definitive evidence for a lab leak theory.

      The COVID-19 pandemic was not caused by a lab leak, but rather an animal-to-human spillover event. The evidence points to unsanitary conditions at the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan, China, where animals like raccoon dogs and red foxes, known to carry and transmit viruses, were sold. The virus, SARS-CoV-2, was found in various market environments, including animal cages and slaughtering tools. This theory is supported by the fact that pandemics have historically originated from animal spillover events, such as SARS and MERS. The idea of a lab leak is a conspiracy theory, as there is no definitive evidence to support it. Furthermore, the cognitive dissonance between people's desire for a vaccine and their skepticism or fear of it has contributed to the loss of trust in institutions and the spread of disinformation. Instances like the Provincetown COVID outbreak, where vaccinated individuals contracted the virus, were misreported as vaccine failures, perpetuating this mistrust. It's important to remember that vaccines are designed to prevent severe illness and hospitalization, not entirely eliminate the virus.

    • Vaccine protection against mild illnessInitially reported high efficacy rates against both severe and mild disease did not account for waning protection against mild illness over time, leading to frustration and mistrust

      While high levels of neutralizing antibodies can prevent severe COVID-19 infection, their protection against mild illness fades over time. This was initially misunderstood when Pfizer and Moderna's clinical trials, which only followed participants for three months post-vaccination, reported a 95% efficacy rate against both severe and mild disease. However, studies conducted six months later revealed that protection against mild illness had dropped to 50%. This misconception, combined with vaccine mandates and the CDC's initial messaging, led to frustration and anger when individuals experienced breakthrough infections. The difference between a deficit of knowledge and a deficit of trust regarding the COVID-19 vaccine is significant. Those who chose not to get vaccinated often had limited contact with the healthcare system, resulting in a lack of knowledge about the vaccine's benefits. To bridge this gap, community leaders and healthcare professionals who are trusted by underrepresented communities can play a crucial role in educating and encouraging vaccination. Improving communication skills and critical thinking education in schools, as well as providing resources and training for healthcare professionals, can also help address this issue.

    • Science in Public Health PoliciesThe immune response to COVID-19 decreases symptoms and reduces virus replication, but the politicization of public health policies has led to a distrust of science, threatening crucial measures like masking, isolation, and vaccine mandates. To combat this, there's a need to educate people about science and critical thinking at an early age.

      The immune response to COVID-19 plays a significant role in the decrease of symptoms and the reduction of virus replication. This means that a person who has gone a day without a fever may be in the process of recovering and is less likely to be shedding the virus. However, the politicization of public health policies during the pandemic has led to a distrust of science and a denial of its importance. This erosion of trust has resulted in the rejection of crucial public health measures such as masking mandates, isolation procedures, and vaccine mandates. The future of science in public health policy is uncertain, and there is a concern that it may continue to be overshadowed by various agendas. To combat this, there is a need to educate people about science and critical thinking at an early age. This will take time, but it is essential to ensure that science remains a trusted source of truth and guidance in public health policies. The debate over science should not be equalized with other agendas, as the scientific evidence has already been thoroughly debated through peer review and conferences. The recent example of the bivalent vaccine illustrates this, as the inclusion of the omicron variant in the vaccine was a reasonable idea, but it did not yield the desired results. The importance of science in public health policies cannot be overstated, and it is crucial that we continue to prioritize it in our decision-making processes.

    • Scientific understandingScientific understanding is not static and evolves with new information, requiring transparency and clear communication to maintain public trust.

      The scientific community, including advisory committees, is constantly learning and evolving, especially during a novel virus outbreak. During the COVID-19 pandemic, there were instances where advice given was not initially correct, but as more information became available, adjustments were made. For instance, the debate over the effectiveness of bivalent versus monovalent vaccines against the omicron variant. While initial data suggested a potential advantage to the bivalent vaccine due to imprinting, later studies showed no difference between the two. It's important to remember that scientific understanding is not static and that being transparent about the learning process is crucial for maintaining public trust. In terms of science communication, it's essential to explain complex concepts in simple terms and not shy away from discussing the science behind the news. Being honest and transparent, even when the information is evolving, helps build trust with the public. Additionally, the importance of a robust international surveillance system was highlighted during the pandemic. Relying on a single source for information can lead to missed opportunities for early detection and response.

    • Interconnectedness during crisesRecognizing interconnectedness and allowing outside researchers in during crises is crucial for progress and protecting vulnerable individuals. We must prioritize the greater good and combat anti-science sentiment to navigate future pandemics.

      During times of crisis, it's essential to recognize and embrace our interconnectedness as a global community. The inability to allow outside researchers in during a pandemic can lead to conspiracy theories and hinder progress. We must remember that there are vulnerable individuals who depend on us for protection, and we have a responsibility to prioritize the greater good. With the likelihood of future pandemics, it's crucial to emphasize our collective unity and the benefits of working together. Dr. Paul Offit's insights on the rise of anti-science sentiment and ways to combat it are valuable reminders for navigating the post-pandemic world. For more resources and information, visit thispodwilldoyou.com, where you can find links to Dr. Offit's website and other relevant content. Remember, we're all in this together, and our actions today can significantly impact tomorrow.

    Recent Episodes from This Podcast Will Kill You

    Ep 142 Leeches: It’s more powerful than magic, it’s nature

    Ep 142 Leeches: It’s more powerful than magic, it’s nature
    Did our episode on maggots leave you wanting more squirmy wormy yet oh so cool content? You’re in luck. Because this week, we’re following up our maggots episode with a companion piece on leeches. Leeches have been used by healers and physicians for millennia, and they’ve come back into style for treatments today, for very good reason. If you’ve ever wondered what makes leech saliva so magical, why barber poles are striped with red and white ribbons, or how leeches behave as parents, then this is certainly the episode for you. And we are so excited to be joined by friend of the pod Dr. Robert Rowe, who shares a tale of leeches from the front lines of plastic surgery. Dr. Rowe MD, MBA, MPH is a Preventive Medicine Physician who serves as adjunct faculty with both the University of North Carolina Preventive Medicine Residency Program and the Gillings School of Global Public Health. He is also the creator and host of TarHeal Wellness, a podcast dedicated to the health and wellbeing of medical residents, touching on physical and mental challenges many other people face as well. For those who have friends or family who are doctors or training to be, it's a great way to hear about some of the challenges of residency and how they can work through and overcome them. Available wherever you get your podcasts! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Special Episode: Dr. Paul Offit & Tell Me When It’s Over

    Special Episode: Dr. Paul Offit & Tell Me When It’s Over
    The COVID-19 pandemic started with a bang - lockdowns, grocery store shelves cleared of their goods, toilet paper shortages, and a pervasive sense of panic. But more recently, it has slowly faded into the background for many of us. The WHO says that while we’re no longer in crisis mode, we are still in a pandemic. What does that mean for us in our daily lives? In this TPWKY book club episode, we’re joined by Dr. Paul Offit to discuss his recent book Tell Me When It’s Over: An Insider’s Guide to Deciphering COVID Myths and Navigating our Post-Pandemic World [Interview recorded February 21, 2024]. Dr. Offit, who is a pediatrician, vaccine expert, vaccine co-inventor (rotavirus), member of vaccines advisory committees, and long-time vaccine advocate, explains some of the COVID disinformation that continues to circulate about the virus, discusses where government institutions went wrong during the early months of the pandemic, and what we can expect now that the pandemic is no longer the public health emergency it once was. Tune in for a fascinating reflection on where we are in the pandemic today and how we can all fight against the rise in anti-science that threatens the future of public health. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Ep 141 Maggots: Such noble work

    Ep 141 Maggots: Such noble work
    Just reading the title of this episode may have been enough to make you feel grossed out and creepy crawly. And now we’re asking you to listen to a whole episode about maggots? But trust us, it’s worth the journey. Because these little creatures have a hidden depth to them that will surprise, delight, and, we would venture to say, inspire. In this episode, we explore the many ways that maggots have been used by medicine over the centuries up to the present day and the properties they possess that make them heroes of healing. With a discerning palate and something called extracorporeal digestion, maggots can show us that, when it comes to wound healing, teamwork makes the dream work. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Ep 140 Nipah virus: Of Fruit and Bats

    Ep 140 Nipah virus: Of Fruit and Bats
    What does it take to make the WHO’s list of high priority pathogens of pandemic potential? Ask Nipah virus. Extremely deadly with a wide host range and no effective treatments or vaccine (yet), Nipah virus has certainly earned its place on this list. In this episode, we explore where this virus came from, how it can make us so very sick, and the 1998 outbreak in peninsular Malaysia that put Nipah virus on the map. But we don’t stop there! We bring on expert guest, Dr. Clifton McKee, research associate at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health to guide us through the ecological factors that drive Nipah virus spillover events and outbreaks. With Dr. McKee’s help, we explore what a One Health approach to Nipah virus looks like and how it integrates study across animals, humans, and the environment to help predict and control when and where this virus might spill over. Tune in to learn more about this deadly virus that inspired the 2011 movie Contagion. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Special Episode: Dr. Sara Manning Peskin & A Molecule Away from Madness

    Special Episode: Dr. Sara Manning Peskin & A Molecule Away from Madness
    We live on the edge. Whether we fail to acknowledge it or try not to think of it, that fact remains true for most of us. A chemical shift, a rogue protein, a marauding molecule - our brains are vulnerable to an array of attacks that could dramatically alter our connection with the world and ourselves. In this episode of the TPWKY book club, Dr. Sara Manning Peskin, MD, MS, assistant professor of clinical neurology at the University of Pennsylvania and author, joins us to discuss her book A Molecule Away from Madness: Tales of the Hijacked Brain. Deeply fascinating, occasionally terrifying, and always empathetic, A Molecule Away from Madness features individual cases of the brain gone awry. Dr. Manning Peskin artfully combines these emotional and personal stories with approachable explanations of how our brains work and historical descriptions of how we gained this understanding. Tune in to this captivating conversation wherever you get your podcasts! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Ep 139 Supplements: “This statement has not been evaluated by the FDA”

    Ep 139 Supplements: “This statement has not been evaluated by the FDA”
    Does it seem like the supplement section of your grocery store gets bigger every time you go in? Or that all television commercials these days seem to be advertising dietary supplements that promise to improve your concentration, help you lose weight, make you happier, healthier, smarter, stronger, cooler, poop better or some mix of those? You’re not imagining things. The explosion of the US dietary supplement industry over the past few years is very real, and when you’re inundated with ads for supplements everywhere you turn, it can be very difficult to navigate whether these things actually do what they say and how much they’re allowed to say without actually doing anything. That’s where this episode comes in. We take you through what supplements actually are, how their regulation in the US has changed over the past century, what dietary supplements can and cannot claim on their label, and how the supplement market has fared since the Covid pandemic (spoilers: it’s thriving). Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Ep 138 Fever: Take it to the limit

    Ep 138 Fever: Take it to the limit
    A dull pounding headache. Body aches that come and go. Chills that set your teeth to chattering and have you reaching for the fluffiest blankets to warm up. But the thing is, you’re already warm, hot even. At least according to the thermometer. That’s right, you’ve got a fever. Throughout the years of making this podcast, we’ve begun many a disease description with “it started with a fever” but we haven’t ever explored what that really means in depth until this episode. We take you through why fevers happen, how they work, why on earth you feel cold when you’re actually running a temperature, and whether they’re helpful, harmful, or somewhere in between. We then poke around in the history of thermometers, exploring when someone first thought to measure human body temperature and how that changed the concept of Fever the disease to fever the symptom. This is a red-hot fever dream of an episode with some very fun fever facts, so make sure to tune in! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Special Episode: Dr. Deirdre Cooper Owens & Medical Bondage

    Special Episode: Dr. Deirdre Cooper Owens & Medical Bondage
    The TPWKY book club is back in action, and we’re thrilled to be starting this season’s reading journey with Dr. Deirdre Cooper Owens, reproductive rights advocate, Associate Professor in the University of Connecticut history department, and award-winning author of Medical Bondage: Race, Gender, and the Origins of American Gynecology. The history of science and medicine often focuses on the achievements of wealthy, white male physicians and researchers whose names are etched on medical school buildings, libraries, and dormitories. Rarely do these stories give voice to those whose bodies or labor were exploited in the name of scientific progress. In the first book club episode of the season, Dr. Deirdre Cooper Owens joins us to discuss the Black enslaved women who worked alongside the so-called “Father of Gynecology”, James Marion Sims, as both patients and caregivers in nineteenth-century America. Our conversation takes us through the inherent contradictions in the way nineteenth-century physicians wrote and thought about race, gender, and health, and how broad changes in medical practice during this time promoted the dissemination of unfounded beliefs in how white and Black bodies experienced pain, health, and disease. Tune in for a fascinating conversation that will have you immediately adding Medical Bondage to your to-read list! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Ep 137 ME/CFS: What’s in a name? (A lot, actually)

    Ep 137 ME/CFS: What’s in a name? (A lot, actually)
    In many ways, this week’s episode on myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) is a companion piece to last week’s episode on Long Covid. The two share many similarities: a wide range of debilitating symptoms lingering long after infection, an illness which can transform from day to day or week to week, dismissal and downplaying by the medical community, a big question mark under “pathophysiological cause”, and so many others. These parallels can tell us a great deal about our concepts of disease and how we deal with uncertainty in science and medicine. But the differences between these two can be equally revealing. In this episode, we dig into what we know and what we hypothesize about the biological underpinnings of ME/CFS before tracing the twisty history of this disease, as popular perception switched back and forth and back again from “real” to “imagined” disease. We wrap up the episode with a look at some of the current research and promising treatments for ME/CFS. Both ME/CFS and Long Covid demonstrate the power of patients and patient advocates in raising awareness about poorly understood diseases and the impact that sharing personal stories can have. You can find more incredible work by Katie Walters, the provider of one of our firsthands for this episode, by clicking on this link. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Ep 136 Long Covid: A long time coming

    Ep 136 Long Covid: A long time coming
    We’re back with our season 7 premiere, and we’re kicking things off with a topic that we’ve wanted to cover for a long time, even if the topic itself hasn’t been around all that long. That’s right, we’re taking on Long Covid. When SARS-CoV-2 began making its way around the world in 2020, it was thought to cause a mild illness in most people, with complete recovery a couple of weeks after first getting infected. But just a short time into the pandemic, people began to report debilitating symptoms lingering for months after recovery was “supposed” to happen. What started out as a trickle of reports soon turned into a tsunami, and this condition, which came to be known as Long Covid, transformed our understanding of this viral infection. In this episode, we explore how the concept of Long Covid was defined by those who experience it, who also continue to advocate for better treatment, more research, and real compassion from medical professionals. We examine what we currently know about the biology of this condition, and delve into some of the most promising research avenues that may give us a greater understanding of or ability to treat Long Covid. This story is still being written, but already it can tell us so much about our concepts of infectious disease and how the medical system treats those with “invisible” illness. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices