Logo
    Search

    Ritchie Torres and Ben Smith: Pride and Priors

    en-usJune 04, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Trump's Enduring Influence on GOPCongressman Ritchie Torres believes Trump's influence on the Republican party is significant and enduring, despite divisive actions and controversial policies. The GOP has transformed into a cult of personality around Trump, with traditional political values replaced by Trumpism. Biden should focus on addressing bread-and-butter issues to counter Trump's gains among voters of color.

      Representative Ritchie Torres, a democratic congressman from the Bronx, feels that the influence of Donald Trump on the Republican party is significant and enduring, despite his divisive actions and controversial policies. Torres grew up in public housing across from a Trump Golf Course and has experienced the impact of Trump's presence throughout his life. He acknowledges that some Republicans privately acknowledge Trump's negative influence but are fearful of him. The Republican party, according to Torres, has transformed into a cult of personality around Trump, with Trumpism replacing traditional political values. Despite the Bronx being overwhelmingly Democratic, Trump has made gains among working-class black and Latino voters, particularly men, at the margins. To address this trend, Torres believes President Biden should focus on bread-and-butter issues that matter to voters of color in areas like the Bronx, such as affordable housing, food, and safety.

    • Unifying against common enemiesThe Democratic Party should focus on unifying against common enemies, such as Donald Trump, and addressing economic issues that resonate with working class voters of color to win the election, despite significant internal divisions on certain issues like Israel.

      The Democratic Party needs to focus on unifying against common enemies, such as Donald Trump, and address economic issues that resonate with working class voters of color. The divide within the party, particularly on issues like Israel, while significant, may not be the deciding factor in the election. The media coverage of these divisions, however, can have a crowding out effect on a unified message against Trump. Regarding Biden's stance on Israel, the speaker believes he has been the most pro-Israel president in history, despite facing intense scrutiny and international pressure. The speaker also expressed concern about the actions of pro-Palestine activists who vandalized a pride flag honoring trailblazing LGBTQ+ members of Congress, while ignoring Hamas' oppression of queer Palestinians. Overall, the conversation emphasized the importance of staying focused on the larger issues and avoiding getting bogged down in divisive side issues.

    • Palestinian women and queer people's rightsDespite Israel's imperfections, it offers more protection for minority rights, women's rights, and LGBTQ rights than many countries in the Middle East and Muslim world.

      While supporting the cause for a free Palestine is important, it's crucial to consider the lack of a clear path for women and queer people in Palestine to live as citizens with rights. Israel may not be perfect, but it is more protective of minority rights, women's rights, and LGBTQ rights than many other countries in the Middle East and Muslim world. The speaker acknowledges concerns and potential backlash for taking a photo with someone who may hold different views, but emphasizes the importance of being judged by actions and statements rather than associations. The speaker also shares their personal experience as a politician dealing with mental health struggles and introversion, highlighting the importance of being authentic and finding ways to navigate the demands of public life.

    • Mental health, Media coverageMental health struggles are common and require professional help, not shame or self-reliance. The media continues to grapple with reporting on Donald Trump, emphasizing the need for accurate and responsible coverage.

      Mental health struggles are common and require professional care, not shame or self-reliance. Ritchie Torres, a Congressman from the South Bronx, shared his personal experience of dealing with depression and suicidal thoughts, emphasizing the importance of seeking help and never losing hope. He also highlighted the need for the Democratic Party to prioritize and represent the struggles of working-class people and single mothers, who often go unnoticed. In terms of media coverage, Ben Smith, editor in chief of Semaphore, discussed the ongoing challenge of reporting on Donald Trump and the media's role in his continued influence. He believes that the media still struggles to effectively cover Trump and that the public needs to remain vigilant against his manipulation tactics. Overall, the conversation underscores the importance of addressing mental health struggles with compassion and professional care, and the need for accurate and responsible media coverage.

    • Media's role in covering political controversiesThe media's role in covering political controversies is complex, as amplifying outrageous statements can fuel division and distract from important issues, but ignoring them may also allow extreme voices to gain power.

      The 2023 impeachment trial of a former president was marked by a media circus and uncertainty about the impact of the verdict on political coverage. The Trump campaign was quick to spin the outcome as persecution, while the Democrats lacked a clear plan. The White House also remained largely silent. The speaker questions the media's role in amplifying outrageous statements and the challenge of covering a candidate who intentionally provokes controversy. The answer is not straightforward, but focusing on what the candidate actually intends to do as president may be a more responsible approach. However, the question remains about whether to cover distractions like UFC events or not. The speaker expresses concern about the growing influence of extreme voices and the potential consequences if they gain power again.

    • Cable News Industry CollapseCable news networks are making business decisions based on demographics and political alignments, and it's crucial to distinguish valuable journalism from sensationalist content, while factual reporting remains essential.

      The cable news industry is facing a slow collapse, and networks like CNN are making business decisions based on their viewer demographics and political alignments. The debate over journalistic integrity comes into play when trying to represent conservative viewpoints without promoting blatant lies. It's essential to distinguish between valuable investigative journalism and the sensationalist content that can sometimes dominate cable news. The political landscape is shifting, and right-wing populist movements are becoming a significant force, with some politicians crossing party lines to collaborate on key issues. Ultimately, cable news should not be seen as the sole ethical compass for journalism, as it represents only one aspect of the complex media ecosystem. Instead, we should focus on the importance of factual reporting and understanding the motivations behind various political movements.

    • Media FragmentationMedia landscape is fragmenting with traditional platforms losing power to niche ones, but quality and originality of reporting can vary greatly, and access to factual information may be limited for some due to shift towards subscriber-based model

      The media landscape is becoming increasingly fragmented, with traditional platforms like CNN, Fox, and MSNBC losing power to newer, more niche platforms like YouTube, TikTok, and podcasts. While these new platforms offer a vast array of information and opinions, the quality and originality of reporting can vary greatly. The top-performing content creators, such as Joe Rogan, have a relatively small but dedicated audience, while most consumption happens in the middle of the tail. The shift towards a subscriber-based model raises concerns about the availability of quality, factual information for those who cannot afford to pay. However, it's important to note that not everyone values traditional "quality news" and that the barrier to accessing information is not always financial. The media ecosystem is complex, and it remains to be seen whether this fragmentation will lead to a healthier or less healthy information environment.

    • Media Business and Illicit ActivitiesMedia businesses may face challenges in addressing controversial content while ensuring truthfulness and avoiding illicit activities. The future of media may lie in formats that allow for reasonable disagreements and less sensationalism.

      Successful media businesses often find ways to incorporate both subscription models and advertising, recognizing that people's media consumption preferences span a wide range. However, the current media landscape, with its seemingly limitless options, poses a challenge: how to address the demand for controversial content and ensure that people are not being misinformed or lied to. The media industry's future may lie in formats like podcasts, newsletters, and long-form YouTube shows, which offer more space for reasonable disagreements and less focus on sensationalism. An intriguing media story that illustrates this complex landscape is the recent indictment of the Epoch Times publisher, Stephen Wan, on money laundering charges. The Epoch Times, which presents itself as a pro-Trump, anti-China newspaper, has been linked to the Falun Gong spiritual practice, which is in exile and has been brutally cracked down on by the Chinese government. The indictment alleges that the Epoch Times was used as a front for money laundering from other criminal enterprises. The case highlights the blurred lines between the media business and other illicit activities, as well as the potential for individuals and organizations to manipulate the media landscape for their own ends.

    • Global politics and media ambiguityThe media landscape is vast and diverse, presenting facts alongside personal views has been well-received, but acknowledging and representing uncertainty is an area for improvement in reporting global news

      The world of global politics and media can be complex and full of ambiguity, as illustrated by the case of Myles Guo, a Chinese dissident with unclear motivations and potential connections to Steve Bannon. The media landscape is vast and diverse, and Sema 4 aims to serve an audience that is engaged with global issues and values transparency and open-mindedness. The model of presenting facts alongside personal views has been well-received, providing readers with both the information and the perspective of the reporter. However, it's important to acknowledge that not all reporters may have a clear-cut view on every topic, and finding ways to represent that uncertainty in the format could be an area for improvement. Overall, the goal is to provide a nuanced and global perspective on the news, recognizing that fact and opinion often intertwine in the modern media landscape.

    Recent Episodes from The Bulwark Podcast

    Jane Coaston: He's So Not a Badass

    Jane Coaston: He's So Not a Badass
    Trump is not drawing support from black voters because of his criminality—that's just MAGA's bigotry of low expectations. Meanwhile, he's now promising a green card to every foreign Harvard grad to please tech bro donors. Plus, the attempt to create a race war over Caitlin Clark, the annoying liberals on the coasts are creating MAGA reactionaries, and more from the mailbag. Jane Coaston joins Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Reid Hoffman's reply to David Sacks
    Tim interviews Reid Hoffman
    Tim's playlist 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 21, 2024

    Adam Kinzinger: Bat**** Crazy

    Adam Kinzinger: Bat**** Crazy
    Felon 45 didn't even really like being president and no one is taking his ludicrous tariff plan seriously—but Republicans can't stop tripping over each other to show him their fealty. Plus, Putin's desperate trip to North Korea, Netanyahu shows his ingratitude to Biden, the national debt keeps growing, and Trump's fond memories for his glory days on The Apprentice.
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 20, 2024

    George Packer: Phoenix, the Most American City

    George Packer: Phoenix, the Most American City
    Phoenix is a microcosm of the big issues in the election and the country generally, including political extremism, climate change, and the border. But when it comes to the state's water crisis, Arizonians are showing signs of sanity—by accepting facts and downplaying partisanship. Could the city be a guide for America's future? George Packer joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    George's piece on Phoenix
    George's 2019 piece on his son's education

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 19, 2024

    Lauren Windsor and Ben Wittes: A Deep Rot

    Lauren Windsor and Ben Wittes: A Deep Rot
    Justice Alito and his wife seem to have some pretty deep and dark feelings about the people they dislike. Tim Miller also asks Lauren Windsor about the ethics of her undercover recordings. Plus, Ben Wittes shares his predictions for a presidential immunity ruling, his praise for Amy Coney Barrett's handing of the case, and his observations about the criminals Trump unapologetically hangs out with.

    show notes:

    Justice Alito's 2022 Notre Dame speech
    Lawfare's piece on a presidential self-pardon
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 18, 2024

    Will Saletan: Nonstop Shamelessness

    Will Saletan: Nonstop Shamelessness
    Trump visited an African American church in Detroit and the pews were filled with white people; Republicans keep flooding social media with cropped videos to smear Biden; and foreign policy hawks, like Tom Cotton, now say we should be standing up to our allies, not Putin. MAGA land can't quit its shamelessness. Will Saletan joins Tim Miller, who is back from vacation.

    show notes:

    Detroit reporter shared images from Trump's Black church event
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 17, 2024

    Jonathan V. Last and Ben Raderstorf: Retribution Agenda

    Jonathan V. Last and Ben Raderstorf: Retribution Agenda
    Republicans had a tête-à-tête with Trump to remind him how, if he wins, he should extend the tax cuts before he gets tied up with punishing all his enemies. Meanwhile, should Biden suggest extending the tax cuts so CEOs can end their flirtation with authoritarianism? Plus, the value of 'agreeing to disagree' in the pro-democracy coalition. JVL and Protect Democracy's Ben Raderstorf join guest host Amanda Carpenter.

    show notes:

    Protect Democracy's "If you can keep it" newsletter
    JVL's newsletter piece on Truth Social
    JVL's newsletter piece on the Epoch Times 
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 13, 2024

    Elizabeth Dias and Lisa Lerer: The Inside Story of the Fall of Roe

    Elizabeth Dias and Lisa Lerer: The Inside Story of the Fall of Roe
    A coalition of Christian lawyers, activists, and politicians methodically and secretly took down Roe, and in the process, outsmarted Democrats who believed they had permanently won on the issue of abortion. And the end of Roe v Wade is just the beginning of an effort to roll back the sexual revolution. Lisa Lerer and Elizabeth Dias join guest host A.B. Stoddard today.

    show notes:

    Elizabeth's and Lisa's book, "The Fall of Roe: The Rise of a New America"

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 12, 2024

    Jennifer Senior: Secrets and Lies

    Jennifer Senior: Secrets and Lies
    Pulitzer-Prize winning Jen Senior joins Tim Miller for a free-form conversation about jail-bound, faux martyr Steve Bannon, the debilitating reality of living with long Covid, unearthing a family trauma, and how Americans with differing political persuasions can find their way to back to each other.

    show notes:

    Jen's story on her Aunt Adele
    Jen's "On Grief," originally published as the Pulitzer-winning, "What Bobby McIlvane Left Behind." 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 11, 2024

    Bill Kristol: Tuberville's Policy Is the Same as Trump's

    Bill Kristol: Tuberville's Policy Is the Same as Trump's
    Tommy Tuberville's know-nothing appeasement of Putin lines up exactly with where the ex-POTUS is—Biden should be making Trumpworld squirm over that fact. Plus, the antisemitic white nationalists who could be back at the White House next year, the far-right's momentum in Europe, and the curious case of why Trump would be reluctant to release the Epstein file. Bill Kristol joins Tim Miller.

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 10, 2024

    Mike Madrid: The Latino Century

    Mike Madrid: The Latino Century
    Young Latinos are a giant emerging voter bloc with populist leanings—who also favor tougher border security. If Trump was to win reelection, it would ironically be because these voters put him over the top. How can Democrats reach them? Mike Madrid joins Tim Miller for the weekend pod. Plus, in a mega-mailbag segment, Tim gets personal and shares the story of his daughter's adoption.

    show notes:
    Mike's new book, "The Latino Century"
    Tim's playlist
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 07, 2024