109: Footies #4: Duel Narratives

    enJune 08, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • A96 promise transparencyThe Scottish Government's abandoned promise to dual the A96 trunk road between Aberdeen and Inverness without public announcement underscores the significance of investigative journalism in ensuring government accountability

      The Scottish Government's promise to dual the A96 trunk road between Aberdeen and Inverness by 2030, which is primarily a single-carriageway road, was scrapped more than three years ago without public announcement. This revelation was brought to light by journalist Lewis McBlaine from the Northern Scott and sister papers. The A96, which links Aberdeen and Inverness, is an important but relatively small road that has been a focus of campaigning by the Northern Scott for over 20 years due to the need for bypasses in major towns along the way. The lack of transparency regarding the abandoned promise has significant implications for the communities along the A96. This issue highlights the importance of investigative journalism in holding governments accountable for the promises they make to their citizens.

    • Elgin bypass projectThe Elgin bypass project, a long-standing campaign to link cities together with dual-carriageways in Scotland, has faced numerous delays and lack of transparency from the Scottish Government despite a pledge made in 2011.

      The Elgin bypass project in Scotland, which has been a long-standing campaign for over 80 years, has yet to be completed despite a pledge made by the Scottish Government in 2011 to link all cities together with dual-carriageways. The project faced numerous obstacles, including delays in transitioning from planning to construction. The Scottish Government's explanation for the delay is a climate-based compatibility assessment, but the pledge was actually scrapped before the review was launched. The lack of transparency around this change in plans is what makes this story a notable one, as it was kept hidden from the public. This is a classic example of a long-running campaign that has faced numerous hurdles and raises questions about government accountability and communication.

    • A96 road dualing commitmentThe Scottish Government's commitment to dual the A96 road by 2030 has seemingly vanished from public discourse after an email from a permanent secretary during Michael Matheson's tenure as transport minister removed the 2030 pledge from the project, leaving the public uncertain about its progress and timeline.

      The Scottish government's commitment to dual the A96 road by 2030, a promise popular among locals and crucial for road safety due to high fatalities, seems to have disappeared from public discourse after a significant email from a permanent secretary during Michael Matheson's tenure as transport minister. This email, which lacked the 2030 pledge, resulted in the project being removed from the list of imminent actions. Despite repeated requests for comment, the Scottish Government continues to maintain their commitment to the A96 dualing project but refuses to confirm or deny if it will be completed by 2030. This ambiguity leaves the public uncertain about the progress and timeline for this important infrastructure project.

    • Government transparencyLack of transparency in Scottish government's decision to drop pledge to electrify major road by 2030 raises concerns about accountability and meeting climate goals

      Transparency and trust in government initiatives, particularly those related to climate action and infrastructure projects, are of utmost importance. The discussion highlights the lack of transparency surrounding the Scottish government's decision to drop a pledge to electrify a major road by 2030. This revelation came to light after the announcement of a climate-based review, which seemed to indicate a change in plans. The speaker likened this situation to a scene from "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy," emphasizing the difficulty in obtaining information and the lack of communication from the authorities. Furthermore, the speaker mentioned the previous scrapping of a promise to complete another road project by 2035, raising concerns about the government's ability to meet its stated goals. The overall sentiment expressed was that the situation was absurd and that it was unclear what would happen next. The discussion also touched upon the financial constraints that might prevent the government from fulfilling its promises. In essence, the conversation underscores the importance of transparency and accountability in government initiatives, particularly those related to climate action and infrastructure projects.

    • Road project's uncertain completionDespite a long-standing pledge, the road project faces financial challenges and may not be completed due to budget constraints for other capital projects and lack of funding for climate review. The timeline for completion is uncertain.

      The dueling of a particular road project, which was pledged over six decades ago, is facing significant financial challenges and may not be completed anytime soon. The project's high price tag comes at a time when the budgets for capital projects, including hospitals and new wings, are already constrained. The climate review, which could suggest necessary improvements, also lacks funding. The optimism for the project's completion within the first 160 years of the pledge being made is uncertain. The journalist, Lewis, who has been following the story, expresses skepticism about the project's timeline but remains hopeful for a miracle. Despite the long-running nature of such campaigns, they often yield results, so there's still a chance. The journalist's tenacity and determination in tracking down correspondence related to the story are commendable. The project's delay may disappoint those who have been waiting for it, but the spirit of long-running campaigns is to keep pushing for results.

    Recent Episodes from Page 94: The Private Eye Podcast

    109: The Footies #3: Taking the OPIS

    109: The Footies #3: Taking the OPIS
    Humberto Rocha of the Oil Price Information Service on some dodgy dealing in Big Carbon... in part three of our new investigative mini-series interviewing the investigative reporters behind six remarkable pieces of journalism shortlisted for this year’s Paul Foot Award. 

    107: Paul Foot Awards Special #1

    107: Paul Foot Awards Special #1
    A brand new mini-series from Page 94: interviews with the reporters behind six remarkable pieces of investigative journalism, all shortlisted for the prestigious Paul Foot Award 2024. Today, Tristan Kirk of the Evening Standard on the scandal of the Single Justice Procedure.

    106: A Washed Up Government

    106: A Washed Up Government
    The team discuss the laws that are being shoved through parliament before the electoral iron curtain descends (and those that are being left on the other side), plus an update from Richard Brooks on the latest goings-on at the Post Office inquiry.