Logo
    Search

    You Ask Us: How might a Labour government manage a Trump government?

    enSeptember 22, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Shopping for a special purchase online with Blue NileOnline shopping with Blue Nile offers convenience and customization for unique purchases like engagement rings, while Labour Party leader Keir Starmer focuses on foreign policy, preparing to renegotiate the post-Brexit trade deal and advocating for a special tribunal to prosecute Vladimir Putin for war crimes.

      When it comes to making a special and meaningful purchase, such as a unique engagement ring, the convenience and customization options of shopping online with companies like Blue Nile can provide peace of mind. Meanwhile, in the realm of politics, the Labour Party under Keir Starmer has been focusing on various issues, including foreign policy. Although foreign policy may not always be at the forefront of the news, Starmer has been traveling to meet with international leaders and has expressed intentions to renegotiate the post-Brexit trade deal with the EU. Starmer's team argues that he spends a significant amount of time preparing for the job and building relationships with world leaders. Notably, Starmer and David Lammy have advocated for a special tribunal to prosecute Vladimir Putin for war crimes and have strong connections with the Biden administration.

    • Rebuilding relationships with EU and USA potential Labour government would focus on rebuilding ties with the EU and maintaining close relations with the US, with Starmer's background in the Obama administration and Lammy's respect in Washington DC signaling this priority.

      During Keir Starmer and David Lammy's recent visits to the EU, it became clear that a potential Labour government would prioritize rebuilding relationships with the EU and maintaining close ties with the US. Starmer's background working closely with the Obama administration and Lammy's respect in Washington DC highlight this focus. Regarding the TCA negotiation, it seems the EU views it as a check-in rather than a renegotiation, leaving questions about how much change can be made. The consensus between the two parties on foreign policy issues, such as Ukraine and China, also minimizes the dominance of this topic in Westminster. Lammy has also advocated for anti-corruption and green commitments in foreign policy, although these issues may not receive as much attention as his media appearances. The upcoming elections could test Labour's foreign policy priorities, particularly in relation to the US and Trump.

    • UK-US relationship under a Labour governmentA potential Labour government in the UK could face challenges in its relationship with a Trump administration, including pressure to fill US aid gaps and complicated dynamics due to political tensions.

      The relationship between a potential Labour government in the UK and a Trump administration in the US could present significant challenges. If the US withdraws aid to Ukraine, for instance, there could be pressure on the UK to fill the gap. The toxic relationship between Trump and UK Labour politicians, as seen in Trump's clashes with Sadiq Khan, could make this dynamic even more complicated. Keir Starmer's comment that Trump is not his desired candidate for president could also provoke a reaction from Trump. While some argue that Trump's hostility to NATO and the western security establishment justifies such comments, others believe that distancing oneself from a future US president carries risks. The potential benefits of such a move are unclear, especially since Biden has not been asking for endorsements and Starmer has not yet visited the White House. Ultimately, navigating this relationship will require careful consideration and diplomacy.

    • Sunak's preferred chancellor vs actual choiceDespite preferring allies for Chancellor role, Sunak's economic policy remained consistent under Hunt's leadership

      During Rishi Sunak's tenure as prime minister, he was required to keep Jeremy Hunt as chancellor for the sake of stability following the chaos of the Liz Truss mini-budget. Sunak reportedly preferred allies like Oliver Dowden or Mel Stride for the role, but the economic policy under his government has largely remained consistent with the "treasury brain" or Thatcherite economics. The debate over who might have been chosen as chancellor raises interesting questions about Sunak's preferred brand of economics and potential differences from Hunt's approach. However, the consensus on economic policy, including headlines about benefit cuts and calls for tax cuts, suggests that both men share a similar outlook. In essence, while Sunak may have preferred a closer ally in the role, the economic policy under his leadership has not seen significant deviation from the current consensus.

    • Political rivalry led to tax cuts race and economic instabilityJeremy Hunt and Rishi Sunak's leadership campaigns featured tax cuts, resulting in economic instability. Hunt's focus on corporation tax cuts defined his campaign, and both men were vindicated when the mini-budget debacle occurred. After taking over from Liz Truss, Hunt prioritized stability over new policies.

      The political rivalry between Jeremy Hunt and Rishi Sunak during their leadership campaigns led to a race to the bottom on tax cuts, resulting in significant economic instability. Hunt's call for massive corporation tax cuts defined his campaign, and both men saw themselves vindicated when the mini-budget debacle occurred. When Hunt took over from Liz Truss, he focused on restoring stability rather than implementing new policies. If Rishi Sunak had become prime minister earlier, he might have had more time and a more stable economic environment to present his vision for the country. However, due to the dominating influence of the coronavirus crisis during his tenure as Chancellor, it's challenging to determine his true economic policy priorities.

    • Rishi Sunak's Economic Beliefs: Free Market Principles and Fiscal ResponsibilityRishi Sunak's economic policy is rooted in free market principles and a focus on fiscal responsibility, evident in his clashes with Boris Johnson over spending and his stance on climate policies and net zero targets.

      Rishi Sunak's economic policy is driven by a strong belief in free market principles and a concern for fiscal responsibility, despite his public image as a generous and centrist leader. This became evident during his tenure as Chancellor under Boris Johnson, when he clashed with the Prime Minister over economic spending and growth plans. Sunak's resignation letter made clear that their disagreements were primarily economic in nature. Sunak's instincts lean towards limiting government intervention and consumer choice, as seen in his stance on climate policies and net zero targets. Additionally, his concern for the long-term financial impact of government spending was a significant factor in his resignation. Overall, Sunak's economic policy is shaped by a commitment to free market principles and a focus on fiscal responsibility, which has been a consistent theme throughout his political career.

    • Rishi Sunak's Economic Beliefs as ChancellorRishi Sunak prioritizes education, innovation, and low taxes in his economic theory, but his policy alignment has been a challenge.

      During his time as chancellor, Rishi Sunak emphasized the importance of education, innovation, and low taxes in his economic theory. However, these beliefs have not been at the forefront of conservative policy in recent years. Sunak has inherited numerous problems and has expressed frustration about managing them, which sometimes comes across as defensive and ungrateful in his public demeanor. Despite this, he has not been able to fully align his budgets and speeches with his beliefs. Education, innovation, and low taxes remain key components of Sunak's economic philosophy.

    Recent Episodes from The New Statesman Podcast

    What does Labour's "growth worth having" actually mean?

    What does Labour's "growth worth having" actually mean?

    Labour want to distinguish themselves from Boris Johnson's "levelling up". What are they planning instead?


    Hannah Barnes, Rachel Cunliffe and Freddie Hayward answer listener questions on Labour's growth strategy, and whether the new government's plans will impact individuals' personal finances.


    They also discuss the new "rising star" Labour MPs to look out for, and whether polling during election campaigns impacts the final result.


    Articles mentioned in this episode:

    Labour's next generation: the new MPs to watch

    https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2024/06/labours-next-generation-election-2024-new-labour-mps


    George Eaton interviews Torsten Bell

    https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/politics-interview/2024/06/torsten-bell-social-democrats-need-to-become-insurgents


    New Labour MP Yuan Yang on the deep class anxiety in China

    https://www.newstatesman.com/encounter/2024/05/labours-yuan-yang-there-is-deep-class-anxiety-in-china


    Yuan Yang: Democracy begins with us

    https://www.newstatesman.com/ideas/2024/07/democracy-begins-with-us-yuan-yang


    Labour MP Sarah Sackman on the tensions between her Labour values and her Jewish identity

    https://www.newstatesman.com/encounter/2024/06/sarah-sackman-my-labour-values-my-jewish-identity-tension





    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Conservative party's very public nervous breakdown

    The Conservative party's very public nervous breakdown

    The Conservative party are scrapping it out to have their visions of the future of the party heard and things are getting messy.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, and Freddie Hayward, political correspondent.


    Read: Kemi Badenoch is the early front-runner for the Tory leadership


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How will global affairs define the Starmer era?

    How will global affairs define the Starmer era?

    Today is the day we see our Labour government on the world stage for the first time. Starmer is in Washington today for the 75th summit of the Nato defence alliance. Ahead of the summit Starmer has met with President Joe Biden and praised the UK-US special relationship. Starmer has also told reporters that his plan to raise defence spending to 2.5% was “cast iron” - but has not committed to a timeline.


    In an increasingly volatile world, how will global affairs define the Starmer era?


    Read: Why foreign affairs will define the Starmer era


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Andrew Marr: "The smell in Whitehall? An invigorating reek of change."

    Andrew Marr: "The smell in Whitehall? An invigorating reek of change."

    A record number of new MPs are flooding through Westminster, Starmer has been on a tour of the UK, and this morning the metro mayors gathered in Downing Street.


    What is the new reality for the UK? Do we need to think seriously about electoral reform? And how is Macron going to get out of his political deadlock?


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Andrew Marr, political editor; and Freddie Hayward, political correspondent.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    What can we learn from Labour's first days in power?

    What can we learn from Labour's first days in power?

    Since forming a new government on Friday, Keir Starmer's cabinet has been hard at work across the weekend to prove to the nation that they are a government of service.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, and Freddie Hayward, political correspondent, to discuss surprise appointments, early policy announcements, and the results of France's shock election this weekend.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Election results: Welcome to Labour Britain

    Election results: Welcome to Labour Britain

    The UK has just voted in its 7th ever Labour prime minister, Keir Starmer. As the results from yesterday’s general election trickled in overnight it became clear that this was not so much a story of Labour victory, as it was of Tory defeat. The last 14 years of conservative rule has dismantled both the country and much of the party’s once loyal supporters. ‘The work of change begins immediately’ said Keir Starmer this afternoon upon arrival at Downing Street straight after accepting the King’s invitation to form a new government.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, and Freddie Hayward, political correspondent.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us





    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    What to expect when you're expecting ... a new government

    What to expect when you're expecting ... a new government

    Today the country heads to the polls to decide who will be in government for the next five years.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, and senior data journalist to go through the key timings and processes of the day, what we know so far and what to look out for.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The penultimate day of Tory Rome

    The penultimate day of Tory Rome

    In a final poll published before the election things have never looked worse for the Conservatives, Rishi Sunak has expressed fear that he might lose his seat, and Boris Johnson has been wheeled out at the 11th hour. How long will it take for the Tories to come back from this and where will they begin?

     

    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by the New Statesman’s senior editor George Eaton and David Gauke, former Conservative MP and New Statesman columnist.

     

    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    How many hours a week should a prime minster be working?

    How many hours a week should a prime minster be working?

    Another Reform UK candidate has stepped down to back the Tories as the “vast majority” of her fellow candidates are “racist, misogynistic and bigoted”, the Conservatives have launched an attack campaign on Keir Starmer, claiming he is work-shy, and the Tory leadership contest may or may not be underway.


    Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, is joined by Freddie Hayward, political correspondent.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Andrew Marr: To succeed, Starmer must upset a lot of people

    Andrew Marr: To succeed, Starmer must upset a lot of people

    In order to succeed in a first term in government, to deliver for working people, Keir Starmer will need to enforce some quietly radical change. And doing so will upset quite a lot of people ...


    It's the last week of the campaign and Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by political editor Andrew Marr, and political correspondent Freddie Hayward.


    As well as looking at what's happening on our own shores, the team also discuss the election prospects across the channel with the success of the right yesterday in France, and across the pond with the widespread trepidation around Biden's future in US government.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Related Episodes

    18. Keir Starmer, Northern Ireland, and disagreeing 'agreeably'

    18. Keir Starmer, Northern Ireland, and disagreeing 'agreeably'
    Join Rory and Alastair as they discuss the performance and future of Keir Starmer, what they both think of Wes Streeting, Rory's appearance on BBC Question Time, austerity, what Labour needs to do to win, train strikes, Tony Blair, Northern Ireland, the ERG, Liz Truss, and disagreeing 'agreeably'. Reading list: Paul Krugman - The Austerity Delusion Anton Spisak - Fixing the Northern Ireland Protocol: A Way Forward Instagram: @restispolitics Twitter: @RestIsPolitics Email: restispolitics@gmail.com Producer: Dom Johnson Exec Producers: Tony Pastor + Jack Davenport The New European Offer: theneweuropean.co.uk/trip Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices