Logo
    Search

    Podcast Summary

    • Exploring the Harmful Effects of Illiberalism and Wokeism from a Center-Left PerspectivePolitical scientist Yascha Mounk argues that recognizing systemic discrimination is important but universal values are crucial for justice, fairness, and social peace. Addressing both right-wing authoritarianism and left's identity politics and wokeism is necessary to prevent further polarization.

      Political scientist and author Yascha Mounk, in his upcoming book "The Identity Trap," explores the harmful effects of illiberalism and wokeism from a center-left perspective. Mounk, who has previously documented the threats to democracy from the right, believes that the current crisis in American democracy requires addressing issues from both sides. He argues that while recognizing systemic discrimination is crucial, universal values offer the most effective path to justice, fairness, and social peace. Despite the ongoing concerns about right-wing authoritarianism, Mounk believes that it's essential to address the left's identity politics and wokeism to prevent further polarization. His work provides a way out of the current trap and offers insights into the future of American democracy.

    • Two-front war on American democracyUnderstanding and addressing the impact of identity synthesis ideology on politics and society is crucial for reclaiming American democracy.

      The current political crisis in America is not just about the immediate threats from populist figures or demagogues, but also about the long-term dysfunctions and threats to democratic order. Liberal constitutional democracy is facing a two-front war, with ideas and mindsets that were once confined to university campuses now seeping into the general population. This new ideology, which can be called identity synthesis, goes beyond recognizing the importance of individual identities and interests. It advocates placing these identities at the core of political and cultural life, and can lead to harmful norms and practices, such as segregating children based on race in schools. To reclaim American democracy, it's essential to build broad, enduring majorities against these demagogues and populists, and to understand and address the impact of this new ideology on our politics and society.

    • Moving Beyond Racial Identity in EducationScholars suggest moving beyond focusing on race as primary identity in education to address underlying social issues instead of fighting for specific racial group interests.

      The goal of education should not be to instill a racial identity in children, as some organizations propose. Instead, it is crucial to move beyond the "defunct racial equality ideology" of the civil rights movement, as scholars like Derek Bell and Kimberle Crenshaw suggest. These scholars argue that focusing on race as the primary identity can lead to fighting for the interests of specific racial groups, rather than addressing the underlying social issues. The historical tradition of the American left seeks a middle ground, acknowledging the importance of teaching about American history and its injustices, while also being aware of discrimination that persists, without advocating for ripping up the Constitution. It is essential to have nuanced discussions about these ideas and understand their distinct differences.

    • Well-intended identity politics and wokeness leading to real injustices and inefficienciesGood intentions can lead to unintended consequences, such as limiting individual freedoms and creating divisions instead of unity, in the name of identity politics and wokeness. Empowering and respecting everyone, regardless of race or background, is the key to a fair and just society.

      The push for identity politics and wokeness, while well-intended, can lead to real injustices and inefficiencies in society. An example of this can be seen in education, where a black mother was denied her preference for a teacher for her children because the principal believed that black kids need to be in predominantly black classrooms to develop healthily. Another example is in public policy, where during the pandemic, elderly people, who are at the highest risk of mortality, were not prioritized for vaccines due to equity concerns, leading to thousands more Americans dying. These practices, while rooted in good intentions, can ultimately limit individual freedoms and create divisions rather than unity. It's important to strive for a society where everyone is empowered and respected, regardless of their race or background.

    • Policies with good intentions can disproportionately harm marginalized communitiesGood intentions alone aren't enough to prevent policies from harming marginalized communities. Addressing root causes like systemic racism and discrimination is crucial.

      The application of certain policies, even with good intentions, can disproportionately harm marginalized communities. Using the example of vaccine distribution during the pandemic, those who were more privileged were able to secure vaccines, potentially leading to a higher death toll among nonwhite Americans. This issue is not isolated, as it applies to broader debates such as cultural appropriation, free speech, and race-sensitive public policy. The critique of these debates, as presented in The Identity Trap, argues that they may address genuine injustices but often fail to provide effective solutions. Instead, efforts should focus on addressing the root causes of these issues, such as systemic racism and discrimination. It's essential to recognize the importance of mutual cultural influence and the progress that comes from learning and influencing each other, rather than instilling a general suspicion towards these interactions.

    • Limiting creativity based on race or ethnicityAvoiding racial and ethnic limitations in creativity fosters a diverse society where people can learn and influence each other.

      Limiting creativity and expression based on race or ethnicity is a slippery slope that can lead to a society where only certain perspectives are allowed. This was discussed in relation to the example of Bon Appetit Magazine and the notion that only people of a certain background can write about certain types of food or literature. This idea goes against the values of a diverse society where people are encouraged to influence and learn from each other. The speaker also touched upon the concept of standpoint theory, acknowledging that while people may come from different perspectives, it's important to listen, ask questions, and strive for understanding rather than delegating political judgment or dismissing others' experiences. Ultimately, the goal should be to build a society where we can all learn from and support each other, rather than being locked off from each other's ideas.

    • Understanding and standing in solidarity with marginalized communitiesAcknowledging the experiences and struggles of marginalized communities is crucial for creating a fair and just society, while upholding a culture of free speech preserves truth and authenticity.

      Understanding and standing in solidarity with the experiences and struggles of marginalized communities, such as black Americans with their interactions with law enforcement, is essential for creating a fair and just society. Another important takeaway is the significance of upholding a culture of free speech, which not only allows for the preservation of truth but also fosters trust and authenticity in society. The suppression of free speech, even if well-intended, can lead to a society where people are unable to express their true beliefs and can result in mistrust towards institutions. The balance lies in acknowledging the importance of both protecting vulnerable groups from harm and preserving the culture of free speech.

    • Free speech protects the powerlessFree speech is essential for a healthy democracy, allowing for diverse perspectives and the exchange of ideas, even if unpopular. Protecting it ensures power remains with the people.

      Free speech is a crucial defense for the powerless and a key component of a healthy and democratic society. It allows for the exchange of ideas, even those that may be unpopular or wrong, to be heard and debated. Without it, those in power will be the ones deciding what can and cannot be said. Frederick Douglass, a historical figure who fought against slavery, understood this and defended free speech as a means for the weak to press their case. However, there is a growing trend to view speech as a form of harm, and some argue that it should be restricted to protect certain groups from being offended or hurt. This argument, however, can be easily manipulated and used to suppress ideas that are politically inconvenient. It's essential to recognize the difference between physical violence and speech and to protect the latter to ensure that diverse perspectives continue to be heard and that power remains in the hands of the people.

    • Over-regulation of speech can lead to dangerous consequencesHistorically, over-regulation of speech can drive it underground, make it more transgressive, and lead to harmful or offensive content. Institutions should be cautious about making speech determinations, and maintaining a balance between student movements and established institutions is crucial.

      The over-regulation of speech, even with good intentions, can lead to dangerous consequences. The speaker argues that restricting speech can drive it underground and make it more transgressive, leading to an explosion of harmful or offensive content. Additionally, the blurring of lines between those in power and those feeling oppressed can lead to a temptation to censor, which is historically shortsighted. The speaker also expresses skepticism towards institutions making speech determinations and concerns about the current political climate in the US. The speaker reflects on the past and the importance of maintaining a healthy equilibrium between student movements and established institutions, and warns against the dangers of everyone thinking they're rebels when they're actually the establishment.

    • Affirmative Action: Unintended Consequences and ComplexityAffirmative action policies beyond education can lead to unintended consequences and perpetuate discrimination. More pressing issues like community college funding deserve attention. The admissions system needs reevaluation for a more equitable approach.

      The speaker expresses concerns about the unintended consequences and paradoxical nature of affirmative action policies, particularly when they extend beyond education into areas like business relief funds. He argues that these policies can lead to unfair outcomes and perpetuate discrimination in different ways. He suggests that there are more pressing issues, like funding for community colleges, that deserve greater attention. The speaker also expresses frustration with the complexity and absurdity of the current admissions system, which he believes should be fundamentally reevaluated. Ultimately, he calls for a more thoughtful and equitable approach to policy-making that avoids creating new forms of discrimination and unfairness.

    • Adopt a holistic perspective on discriminationRecognize that discrimination exists beyond identity categories and requires a nuanced, context-driven approach to address it effectively.

      While it's crucial to acknowledge and address issues of racism, gender, and sexual orientation discrimination, we should not limit our understanding of contemporary society to these identity categories alone. Instead, we need to adopt a holistic perspective that also considers other factors like social class, religion, individual attributes, and actions. Furthermore, while the universal values and neutral rules enshrined in the Constitution are essential, they are not enough to create a just society. We must actively work towards implementing these values and rules, recognizing that progress has not always been linear and that more needs to be done. In essence, we should avoid oversimplifying complex social issues by relying solely on identity categories and instead adopt a nuanced, context-driven approach to understanding and addressing discrimination.

    • Using American values to create a more just societyAmerican values of equality and freedom have been powerful tools for challenging and dismantling discriminatory practices and institutions, and we must strive to live up to them to create a society where individual identity becomes less defining in how we are treated.

      The values of equality and freedom enshrined in American political tradition are not just empty words, but powerful tools for creating a more just society. These values have been instrumental in challenging and dismantling discriminatory practices and institutions, from denying marriage rights to the LGBTQ+ community to the systemic racism faced by black Americans. It's offensive to suggest that we haven't made progress, especially when considering the experiences of those who have faced discrimination in the past. Instead of ripping up these principles, we must strive to live up to them and create a society where individual identity becomes less defining in how we are treated. The Identity Trap by Yascha Mounk is an important book that encourages this debate and offers insights on how we can create such a society. By recognizing and addressing injustices, we can build the institutions, policies, and social norms that help overcome them.

    Recent Episodes from The Bulwark Podcast

    Jeff Sharlet and Joe Perticone: The Confidence of a Bully

    Jeff Sharlet and Joe Perticone: The Confidence of a Bully
    Trump's shark/electrocution anecdote was not a sign of deterioration. Trump is actually getting better at communicating a solid message in a carnivalesque atmosphere—and he's reaching people outside of MAGA. Plus, when Republicans talk about a message of unity, they are referring to the party, not the country. Jeff Sharlet joins Tim Miller from New Hampshire, while Joe Perticone checks in from Milwaukee.

    show notes:

    The Andy Kroll piece about J.D. Vance that Jeff mentioned
    Joe's Press Pass dispatch from the convention on Tuesday

    We’re heading to Dallas on September 5 for An Evening with The Bulwark. For more information and tickets go to TheBulwark.com/events.

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 17, 2024

    Alyssa Farah Griffin: National Unity Is Not Where the GOP Is

    Alyssa Farah Griffin: National Unity Is Not Where the GOP Is
    J.D. Vance is an incredibly polarizing figure, and his addition to the ticket signals a complete realignment of the Republican Party. Plus, he gave the single-worst response to the assassination attempt on Trump. Meanwhile, democracy is a team sport, and Democrats are playing a dangerous game. Alyssa Farah Griffin joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Full speech from Mark Robinson, GOP gubernatorial candidate in North Carolina

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 16, 2024

    Bill Kristol: Not Resigned to a Trump Presidency

    Bill Kristol: Not Resigned to a Trump Presidency
    We begin with a rejection of the fatalist rhetoric from the left. It may be an uphill battle, but the pro-democracy forces have to keep our morale up and be creative. Also the debate around political rhetoric after the assassination attempt is way out ahead of the facts and needs some context. Plus, the Republican convention, Aileen Cannon’s ludicrous dismissal, Axios’ credulous report on Trump’s new tone, and the VP pick. Bill Kristol joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    The 2019 piece Tim referenced

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 15, 2024

    Amanda Carpenter: A Life or Death Bet

    Amanda Carpenter: A Life or Death Bet
    Not having dementia is not enough to change the dynamic. Biden needs a proactive message against Trump. Meanwhile, you don't have to play 'Connect the Dots' to see the overlap between Project 2025 and Trump—and members of the media claiming he has a 'new tone' are like frogs in boiling water. Plus, more from the mailbag. Amanda Carpenter is back with Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Tim's playlist
    The Authoritarian Playbook for 2025

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 12, 2024

    David French: Trump Tries To Run Away from the Christian Nationalists

    David French: Trump Tries To Run Away from the Christian Nationalists
    Inviting "populist slut hero" Amber Rose to speak at the Republican convention and adjusting the platform on abortion—Trump is trying to distance himself from MAGA's Christian fundamentalist ranks. Meanwhile, the Christian Nationalist project to turn the constitutional clock back 70 years continues apace. Plus, the effort to get Biden to leave the ticket is not a conspiracy—but the sign of a working party. David French joins Tim Miller.

    show notes
    David's recent column on the Supreme Court

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 11, 2024

    Bakari Sellers and Elaina Plott Calabro: The Case for Riding with Biden

    Bakari Sellers and Elaina Plott Calabro: The Case for Riding with Biden
    This is not a moment for a politician's origin story or soaring oratory. Some think that means dancing with the one that brung ya. But maybe it’s a moment for someone who could prosecute the case against Donald Trump—making it a perfect time to reintroduce Kamala Harris to voters. Elaina Plott Calabro and Bakari Sellers join Tim Miller.

    show notes
    Elaina's story, "The White House’s Kamala Harris Blunder"
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 09, 2024

    Bill Kristol: The Joe Biden Survival Plan

    Bill Kristol: The Joe Biden Survival Plan
    It would have been nice if Biden had gone on Morning Joe the day after the debate instead of waiting 11 days. But he still is not providing a forward-looking message or explaining why he's the one to beat Trump. Meanwhile, Kamala is showing what an aggressive, proactive campaign looks like. Plus, Project 2025 moves into the spotlight, and the good news for democracy coming from overseas.
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 08, 2024

    Annie Lowrey: The Worst Best Economy

    Annie Lowrey: The Worst Best Economy
    Housing prices, the cost of insurance, and sticker shock at the supermarket are still stressing Americans out even while the economy is booming. Annie Lowrey joins Tim Miller to discuss the limited housing stock, the economic benefits of immigrant labor, and shrinking income inequality. Plus, the media does shape opinion, but Joe Biden's oldness is self-evident.

    show notes:

    Annie's piece on the worst best economy
    Annie's book on universal basic income, "Give People Money"
    Annie's piece on inflation

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 05, 2024

    Related Episodes

    174. You're Next | Dr Rima Azar

    174. You're Next | Dr Rima Azar

    On Season 4, Episode 28 of the Jordan Peterson Podcast, Jordan is joined by Dr. Rima Azar. Dr. Rima Azar is an Associate Professor of health psychology at Mount Allison University, co-founder and co-director of NaviCare/SoinNavi, and a former holder of a CIHR New Investigator salary award in Developmental Psychoneuroimmunology.


    Dr. Rima Azar and Jordan sat down to discuss the importance of free speech and what happened with the recent controversy surrounding her blog, as well as what led to her suspension at Mount Allison University in Sackville, New Brunswick.

    Ep. 420 - The Rip Heard Round The World

    Ep. 420 - The Rip Heard Round The World

    Trump delivered a magnificent speech last night packed with made-to-go-viral moments. He also spoke about life and faith issues in a way that most other Republicans wouldn't dare. This should be our focus today, but instead everyone is talking about Nancy Pelosi tearing up the speech afterwards. I'll explain why Pelosi's stunt, while petulant and childish, may have been a brilliant political move. Also, a straight woman "politically opposed to heterosexuality" writes to Slate asking for advice. And I'll answer your emails.


    If you like The Matt Walsh Show, become a member TODAY with promo code: WALSH and enjoy the exclusive benefits for 10% off at https://www.dailywire.com/Walsh

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Bill Maher Stammers as Republican Corrects His Trump Lie with This Fact

    Bill Maher Stammers as Republican Corrects His Trump Lie with This Fact
    Dave Rubin of “The Rubin Report” talks about Republican Nancy Mace correcting “Real Time with Bill Maher” host Bill Maher with some basic facts about the Trump defamation lawsuit; ABC News host George Stephanopoulos’ failed attempt to shame rape survivor Nancy Mace for supporting Donald Trump after E. Jean Carroll’s assault allegations; Elon Musk helping to debunk the Trump “bloodbath hoax” before it even gets started; Don Lemon trying to smear Elon Musk’s views on DEI on “The View” after X canceled “The Don Lemon Show” before it even aired; Ron DeSantis reporting on the dangerous cargo found aboard a boat of migrants escaping the violence of Haiti; Muslim extremists being allowed to publicly call for jihad on the streets of London; Douglas Murray’s attack on “Sapiens” author Yuval Noah Harari ignoring the importance of a classical education curriculum; and much more. WATCH the MEMBER-EXCLUSIVE segment of the show here: https://rubinreport.locals.com/ Check out the NEW RUBIN REPORT MERCH here: https://daverubin.store/ ---------- Today’s Sponsors: Preserve Gold - Protect your retirement from inflation. Preserve Gold can get physical gold and silver delivered right to your door or inside your IRA, 401k or other qualified retirement account. Rubin Report viewers will get up to $10,000 in free Gold and Silver with a qualifying purchase or retirement account rollover. Preserve Gold will even throw in an immediate $500 account credit if you request your investor guide today. Go to: https://preservegold.com/dave The Wellness Company - Get your Medical Emergency Kit with 8 potentially life-saving medications for you to keep on hand in times of need. Rest easy knowing that you have emergency antibiotics, antivirals and anti-parasitics to help keep you and your family safe. Rubin Report viewers get 15% off at checkout. Kits are ONLY AVAILABLE IN THE USA. Go to: https://TWC.health/RUBIN and use CODE: RUBIN Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    This Is How They Plan To Interfere In The Next Election (Ep 2156)

    This Is How They Plan To Interfere In The Next Election (Ep 2156)
    They’ve ALREADY told us. In this episode, I dissect the most brazen article ever published in the liberal media, describing exactly how they interfered in 2020 and how they plan to do it again. The Secret Bipartisan Campaign That "Saved" the 2020 Election The Impossible Energy ‘Transition’ Biden to Apprentices: You’re Fired Copyright Bongino Inc All Rights Reserved Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices