Why Red, Rural Voters Want to Split From Big Blue Cities
en-us
November 18, 2024
TLDR: Joe Barrett discusses growing movements in California and Illinois for rural areas to breakaway from big cities, Ryan Felton talks about potential impact of Donald Trump's second term on the auto industry, and Drew FitzGerald discusses FCC nominee's plan to challenge big tech. Hosted by Tracie Hunte.
The podcast episode titled "Why Red, Rural Voters Want to Split From Big Blue Cities" discusses an emerging trend among Republican voters in rural areas of states such as California and Illinois who are pushing for the right to separate from Democratic-led cities. Hosted by Tracie Hunte, the episode features insights from WSJ reporters Joe Barrett, Ryan Felton, and Drew Fitzgerald, exploring both the political implications and economic considerations of these movements.
Key Takeaways
The Movement to Separate
- Historical Context: Movements attempting to split states or form new states are not entirely new in the U.S. Historical precedents include virtues such as independence declarations that had occurred during the Civil War.
- Current Status: In Illinois, seven counties recently voted in favor of pursuing state separation, with a total of about a third of counties supporting the idea. In California, rural counties have declared independence and plan to petition Congress directly.
- Public Support: Surveys indicate that these movements are gaining traction among rural voters, highlighting significant support in certain regions, like the 75% majority found in the recent Illinois counties vote.
Political Implications
- Redrawing the Political Map: The potential for creating new states would significantly alter the political landscape. For example, if Illinois became divided into a red state and a blue state, it could lead to additional Republican senators and shift the balance of power in the Senate.
- Future Consequences: The discussion raises concerns about a possible 'Pandora's box' effect, where future administrations might see similar movements arise depending on the political climate. The fracturing of states could lead to complex issues down the line.
Economic Considerations
- The Proposed "New Illinois": Proponents argue that a separate state could match Indiana in terms of population and economic output. They claim lower taxes and fewer regulations could create a competitive environment conducive to economic growth.
- Opposing Views: Critics argue that splitting off would leave the proposed new states without essential tax revenue generated from urban areas, ultimately leading to potential economic challenges.
Insights on Telecom and Automotive Industry
FCC Leadership Changes
- Brendan Carr's Vision: Brendan Carr, appointed to lead the FCC, aims to dismantle what he describes as a "censorship cartel" that hampers free speech and influences media coverage. His past statements indicate a tough stance against big tech, particularly regarding social media's influence.
- Impact on Regulations: As Carr assumes his new role, anticipations about deregulating telecom and media industries are on the rise. This could lead to further consolidation in broadcasting and a reevaluation of protections granted to technology companies.
Trump’s Influence on Auto Industry
- Proposed Tariffs: The podcast discusses how tariffs proposed by President-elect Trump might raise costs for consumers while motivating automakers to manufacture in the U.S. The automotive industry is bracing for significant changes under Trump’s administration, particularly regarding electric vehicles (EVs).
- Elon Musk's Position: Tesla's CEO Elon Musk is seen as a strong ally of Trump, especially as he advocates for self-driving vehicle regulations and the overall evolution of the automotive sector.
Conclusion
The episode underscores an important clash between rural and urban perspectives in American politics. With significant voter support for separating rural areas from metropolitan centers, the potential implications for governance, economic conditions, and political balance could drastically reshape the American landscape. Engaging discussions with reporters provide listeners with a strong understanding of both the local components of this issue and its national ramifications.
For interested listeners and readers, this exploration of red rural voters and their relationships with blue urban centers offers a multifaceted view of current political climates, further emphasizing how grassroots movements can lead to larger conversations about identity, governance, and economic viability.
Was this summary helpful?
Recent Episodes
U.S. Businesses Stockpile, Weigh Price Hikes Ahead of China Tariffs
WSJ What’s News
WSJ China economics reporter Hannah Miao discusses trade war preparations by companies reliant on Chinese imports, Linda McMahon's appointment as Education Department head by Donald Trump, and Comcast greenlighting a spinoff of NBCUniversal’s cable channels.
November 20, 2024
Donald Trump Jr. Bets on the Anti-Woke Economy
WSJ What’s News
WSJ reporter Peter Rudegeair discusses Donald Trump Jr.'s investment in a conservative-valued venture capital firm; Berber Jin explains why investors have received low payouts from AI startups; Russia-Ukraine tensions escalate as Ukraine strikes Russian targets using U.S.-provided long range missiles.
November 19, 2024
Biden Antitrust Officials Plan Final Salvo at Big Tech
WSJ What’s News
U.S. regulators aim to rein in tech firms before Inauguration; House Ethics Committee to investigate former Rep. Matt Gaetz. Canada and Mexico prepare for potential more protectionist America under a second Trump presidency.
November 19, 2024
Ukraine Gets OK to Use Long-Range Missiles Inside Russia
WSJ What’s News
Donald Trump's push for peace negotiations gains acceptance among European leaders, while he expands search for Treasury secretary amid job squabbles. Also, Nvidia's earnings report may signal next phase in AI trade. WSJ’s A.M. Edition and Take On the Week podcast update.
November 18, 2024
Ask this episodeAI Anything
Sign In to save message history