Logo
    Search

    Why Insurers Are Pulling Out of High-Risk Areas

    enSeptember 25, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Real Estate Manager Discusses Investing Opportunities and Insurance ConcernsReal estate manager discusses investing opportunities while highlighting concerns over rising insurance costs, particularly in natural disaster-prone areas, where insurance premiums surge and some companies exit the market, raising questions about government's role in providing insurance and future of development.

      Principal Asset Management, as a real estate manager, offers a comprehensive perspective on investing opportunities in real estate, combining local insights and global expertise across various sectors. However, the discussion also highlighted the increasing concern over the rising cost of insurance, particularly in natural disaster-prone areas. Hurricane Lee, currently a category 5 storm in the Atlantic, adds to the anxiety around property insurance, with some companies pulling out of certain markets due to unprofitability. Insurance premiums are surging, especially in regions like Miami, where they can reach an average of $5,000 compared to less than $2,000 nationwide. The potential abandonment of the private market in these areas raises questions about the role of the government in providing insurance and the future of development in natural disaster-prone regions.

    • Understanding Disaster-Related Financial RisksMeasuring and analyzing disaster-related financial risks is complex due to challenges in collecting property value data and disambiguating trends caused by population and building growth or an increase in disasters.

      The field of disaster management and the analysis of associated financial risks is complex and multifaceted. Melanie Gull, the co-director of the Center for Emergency Management and Homeland Security at Arizona State University, explained her unique background in geography and emergency management. She highlighted the challenges of measuring disaster-related data, including the collection of property value information and the disambiguation of trends caused by either an increase in disasters or an increase in population and building in a given area. The data used for analysis is primarily collected by local meteorologists and compiled by secondary users like the Center for Emergency Management and Homeland Security at Arizona State University. Understanding the complexities of measuring and analyzing disaster-related financial risks is crucial for insurance industries and policymakers as they navigate the growing attention towards climate risk and tightening financial conditions.

    • Measuring the Cost of Natural Disasters: A Complex TaskAccurately estimating natural disaster costs is crucial for effective contingency planning and investment in risk reduction measures, despite challenges in data collection and discrepancies in estimates.

      Measuring the cost of natural disasters is a complex task with various types of losses, including direct and indirect, insured and uninsured, and direct property damage being the primary focus. The data collection for natural hazards, especially landslides, has been a challenge due to limited availability. The discrepancies in estimates of disaster costs can lead to difficulties in justifying the need for investments in risk reduction measures. Communities rely on accurate documentation of past hazards for cost-benefit analysis. The approach to estimating losses can vary, with some organizations relying more on insured data, leading to discrepancies. Despite the challenges, it's crucial to be as accurate as possible to effectively plan for and mitigate the impact of natural disasters. Additionally, the cost of natural disasters is a topic of ongoing discussion. While the exact figures can vary, it's clear that the economic impact of these events is significant and continues to rise. Understanding the true cost of natural disasters is essential for effective contingency planning and investment in risk reduction measures.

    • Increasing natural disasters lead to higher losses for homeownersHomeowners in high-risk areas must navigate complex insurance policies for hurricanes, floods, and wind damage, with potential disputes over coverage, and need to understand their unique insurance needs to be adequately protected.

      The frequency and severity of natural disasters are increasing, leading to higher losses for homeowners. This is due to a combination of factors including more extreme events, more people living in high-risk areas, insufficient mitigation efforts, and less resilient infrastructure. The insurance industry is complex, with various layers of private insurance, federal support, and reinsurers. Homeowners in high-risk areas like Florida need to navigate different policies for coverage against hurricanes, floods, and wind damage. The process of getting reimbursed can involve disputes with insurers over what type of damage is covered. It's essential for individuals to understand their insurance needs and the specific policies required for their area to be adequately protected.

    • Increased costs forcing insurers to stop writing new policies in high-risk areasGovernments should consider incentives to bring insurers back to high-risk areas due to insurers' increased costs. Higher construction costs mean insurers need to be compensated accordingly, and insurers could discourage people from living in risk-prone areas by not providing insurance.

      Insurance companies are facing increased costs due to factors such as natural disasters, higher building costs, and increased reinsurance rates. As a result, some companies have stopped writing new policies in certain high-risk areas. This trend is not new, and it could be a signal for governments to reevaluate their partnerships with insurers and consider incentives to bring them back. Higher construction costs, driven by inflation and labor and material expenses, also mean that insurers need to be compensated accordingly. Another perspective is that insurers could discourage people from living in risk-prone areas by not providing them with insurance. However, research shows that people are more likely to take action and prepare for future disasters after experiencing one. Therefore, the best motivator for people to obtain insurance and take preventative measures is having gone through a disaster themselves.

    • Perception of likelihood of events influences insurance buying decisionsPeople underestimate the importance of insurance due to perceived low likelihood of events, but long-term planning and health concerns also factor in. Disasters can lead to implicit decisions to leave high-risk areas, and effective policy choices can attract insurers back to the market.

      People's decisions not to buy insurance are influenced by their perception of the likelihood of an event happening. If they believe an event is unlikely, they are less inclined to spend their resources on insurance. However, long-term thinking, such as retirement planning and health concerns, also plays a role in the importance of insurance. Regarding moving, the willingness and ability to do so varies greatly, and the decision to leave high-risk areas is often an implicit one following disasters. Companies leaving states may return due to negotiations with regulators and governments over policy changes that encourage competition and attract insurers back to the market. The state of Louisiana is often cited as an example of effective policy choices in the insurance industry.

    • Government's Role in Protecting Against Extreme RisksGovernments approach to protecting against extreme risks varies, from insurer of last resort to reducing risks, and the decision to insure or bear risk is complex, balancing affordability and incentives.

      The role of governments in protecting insurance companies and individuals from extreme risks varies greatly. Some states, like Louisiana, have an "insurer of last resort" where citizens can purchase insurance from the state at a higher premium, while others, like the Netherlands, have the government commit to reducing risks so that people don't have to purchase insurance. The decision of how much risk to bear and how much to insure against is a complex one, as setting insurance premiums too low can incentivize staying in high-risk areas, while setting them too high can make insurance unaffordable. The government could potentially step in with national disaster insurance, but the topic is subject to much debate. Ultimately, it's up to individuals and companies to make the decision to purchase insurance based on their risk tolerance and the level of protection they desire.

    • Government-offered insurance products come with financial risks and complexitiesGovernment's lack of adequate data and volatility in insurance markets pose challenges in offering insurance products, with alternatives like insuring buildings or constructing disaster-resistant homes proposed to effectively price risks.

      Offering insurance products by the government involves significant financial risk and complexities, including setting accurate premiums and dealing with data limitations. The insurance industry is highly data-driven, and the government may lack the necessary information to price products adequately. Furthermore, insurance markets can be volatile, with homeowners often unable to switch easily, unlike banks. The examples of Louisiana and Florida illustrate different approaches to state-level public insurers, with Florida's program being state-backed and holding significant risk, which raises concerns about financial soundness. A researcher named Howard Kanarethrum proposed an alternative approach, focusing on insuring buildings or constructing disaster-resistant homes, as the current system does not effectively price risks into home prices, leaving potential homebuyers to make decisions based on limited and often inadequate information.

    • Insurance complexities impact homebuying decisionsThe lack of transparency and complexity in insurance policies for natural disasters could potentially lead to risk being priced into home values, making it challenging for homebuyers to make informed decisions.

      The insurance market's struggles with buying insurance due to natural disasters and lack of disclosure of risks could potentially lead to risk being priced into home values. Homebuyers currently lack access to crucial information about a property's history of floods, wind damage, or other risks, making it difficult to make informed decisions. The complexities and separations of various insurance policies for floods, wind, and other disasters add to the confusion. The idea of tying insurance policies to houses to incentivize better construction methods is intriguing but comes with challenges. The sheer complexity of calculating and pricing these risks may lead insurance companies to leave the market, and the idea of a federal insurance option introduces new complications. The fear of bureaucratic paperwork and potential political fights further complicates the situation. Overall, there is a growing demand for transparency and information regarding the risks associated with purchasing a property.

    • Florida's Roofing Insurance Scandals and FraudsHigh litigation rates and potential fraudulent claims, particularly in the roofing sector, are causing chaos in Florida's insurance industry, driving some companies out of the state. Understanding the root causes can help shed light on this complex issue.

      The insurance industry in Florida is in a state of chaos due to high litigation rates and potential fraudulent claims, particularly in the roofing sector. The fear of lawsuits and the high cost of doing business in Florida have driven some insurance companies out of the state. This issue is complex and there are no easy answers, but understanding the root causes can help shed light on why this space is so challenging. If you're interested in learning more about Florida's roofing insurance scandals and frauds, be sure to leave a positive review on your favorite podcast platform. Additionally, check out Bloomberg's Odd Lots blog, podcast, and Discord community for more in-depth discussions on these topics. And if you enjoy Odd Lots, be sure to check out the new podcast "Money Stuff" with Matt Levine and Katie Greifeld, where they dive into Wall Street finance and other money-related topics every Friday.

    Recent Episodes from Odd Lots

    James van Geelen on Thematic Investing Right Now

    James van Geelen on Thematic Investing Right Now

    James van Geelen, founder of Citrini Research, scored big when he made his weight loss drug-related investments last year. He was also early into artificial intelligence investments, making bets on picks and shovels plays, like Nvidia. So what's interesting him right now? And how does a thematic investor grapple with uncertainty from things like the upcoming US election? We talk about the next stage of AI investing, constructing election-related portfolios, going long water, and more.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJuly 12, 2024

    Joseph Stiglitz on How to Build Shock-Proof Supply Chains

    Joseph Stiglitz on How to Build Shock-Proof Supply Chains

    Joseph Stiglitz is a Nobel Prize-winning economist known for his groundbreaking work on information gaps and risk-taking in markets. But he's recently turned his attention to supply chains and how to make them more resilient in the face of shocks like the 2020 pandemic. In this episode, we discuss why companies often hesitate to maintain extra inventories — and why this tends to be the case even during stable economic periods. We talk about possible solutions to incentivize firms to invest in larger capacity buffers and promote better long-term economic practices. The conversation also touches on industrial policy, the role of international institutions in the global economy, and strategies to ensure that economic growth benefits everyone more fairly. 

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJuly 11, 2024

    MMT's Godfather Says the US Government Is Spending Like a Drunken Sailor

    MMT's Godfather Says the US Government Is Spending Like a Drunken Sailor

    Modern Monetary Theory has gained prominence over the last several years by offering an alternative view on the constraints to fiscal policy. The basic gist is that the size of the deficit is not per se problematic. What matters are real resource constraints, and that if government spending gets too high — or is spent in unproductive ways — then inflation can materialize as too much money collides with insufficient supply. Another argument that some MMT adherents make is that the conventional path to fighting inflation (higher interest rates by the Federal Reserve) can actually be inflationary, because the coupon payments made by the government to Treasury holders constitute a form of government spending or fiscal expansion. In this episode of the Odd Lots podcast, we speak with Warren Mosler, the intellectual godfather of MMT, to explain the mechanisms at play and assess the current macro environment. Perhaps surprisingly, Mosler is concerned with the combination of high government debt loads, high deficits (which he characterizes as spending like a drunken sailor), and the orthodox approach the Fed is taking to fighting inflation. With debt as high as it is, the annual interest payments due to these rate hikes has gone up significantly, creating a situation that mainstream economists might call Fiscal Dominance. He explains how this environment is a recipe for consistently higher and sustained inflation in the years ahead.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJuly 08, 2024

    Lots More With Stinson Dean on Crashing Lumber Prices

    Lots More With Stinson Dean on Crashing Lumber Prices

    Lumber prices have tumbled dramatically in recent weeks, with benchmark futures falling about 20% in the past four months alone. What's more, this is happening at the height of the summer homebuilding season, when there should theoretically be lots of demand for construction materials. In this episode of Lots More, we speak to one of our favorite guests about what's going on in the lumber market right now, and what falling prices might say about this important part of the US economy. Stinson Dean is the founder and owner of Deacon Lumber and he talks to us about why prices are crashing, what he's seeing in the market right now, and how the current environment differs from 2020 and 2021, when lumber prices went parabolic and mills couldn't keep up with demand.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJuly 05, 2024

    How Brazil Gave Birth to One of the World's Greatest Jet Makers

    How Brazil Gave Birth to One of the World's Greatest Jet Makers

    There aren't many advanced manufacturing success stories in Latin America. And globally, there aren't many companies that can build commercial planes at scale. Yet somehow, one of the world's leading jet makers is Brazilian. Embraer is the third largest maker of commercial planes worldwide after Boeing and Airbus. On this episode, we talk about how the company came to be, what its opportunities are, and what lessons in economic development we can learn from its rise. We speak with two guests for the show. First, is Richard Aboulafia, a managing director at AeroDynamic Advisory, to understand the company's role in the aviation ecosystem. Then we speak with Juan David Rojas, a writer on Latin America, to understand the political conditions in Brazilian history that allowed the company to emerge and thrive.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJuly 04, 2024

    How Brad Jacobs Will Invest $4.5 Billion to Reshape Building Supplies

    How Brad Jacobs Will Invest $4.5 Billion to Reshape Building Supplies

    Brad Jacobs has made a career of starting, consolidating, and growing whole industries. He did a trucking company. He did a warehouse company. He has a freight brokerage. He created an equipment rental company. His new venture, dubbed QXO, aims to reshape the big and sprawling market for building supplies, which can encompass residential, infrastructure and commercial real estate. And he has $4.5 billion of his and his investors' money to go out and buy and build. In this special episode of the Odd Lots podcast, recorded live at the Bloomberg Invest conference in New York City, he talks about where he is in the new process, and what he plans to do once he's made his acquisitions.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJuly 02, 2024

    The Theory That Explains Why Everyone Went Crazy

    The Theory That Explains Why Everyone Went Crazy

    Does it feel to you like society has gone crazy? Well, you're not alone. There's a general view that all around the world, in the realms of politics, culture, business, and so forth, a lot of people are losing their minds. So if this is true, what's the reason for it? On this episode we speak with Dan Davies, the author of the new book The Unaccountability Machine: Why Big Systems Make Terrible Decisions - And How The World Lost Its Mind. Dan talks about the field of study known as cybernetics, and the inevitable outcomes of systems that grow more and more complex. This complexity -- which describes many things in the modern world, and leads to what Dan calls "accountability sinks," or entities that basically exist just to be blamed for things that have gone wrong. Dan walks us through how these emerged in the modern world, where things are headed, and how the trend could theoretically be reversed.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJuly 01, 2024

    Lots More With Neil Dutta on a Looming Fed Policy Error

    Lots More With Neil Dutta on a Looming Fed Policy Error

    Neil Dutta, the top economist over at Renaissance Macro, has generally been sunny and optimistic about the economy over the last four years or so. But now he's warning of a possible mistake by the Federal Reserve. In his view, the central bank is waiting too long to get confirmation that inflation is coming back to target. Meanwhile, unemployment is starting to creep up in a meaningful way. As he sees it, if you're still worried about upside risk to inflation at this point, you need to have a theory about where that inflation is going to come from — and it's really hard to come up with an answer for that right now, given the general downward momentum in hiring and the overall economy. In this episode of Lots More, we catch up with Neil to talk about the risk that the Fed will blow the soft landing.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 28, 2024

    The American Entrepreneurs Who First Opened The Chinese Market

    The American Entrepreneurs Who First Opened The Chinese Market

     From cars to toys to clothes, we're just used to seeing the label "Made In China" on all sorts of things. But how did China become a go-to destination for manufactured goods in the first place? Who actually recognized that there was a huge opportunity to tap the abundant, low-cost labor to sell goods to Western consumers? On this episode of the podcast we speak with Elizabeth Ingleson, a professor at the London School of Economics and the author of the book Made in China: When US-China Interests Converged to Transform Global Trade. Ingleson traces the roots of the US-China trade relationship to a handful of US entrepreneurs in the early 1970s who first went into the country and recognized its opportunity as an export powerhouse. We discuss who these individuals were, the obstacles they had to overcome, and how they reshaped the entire global economy.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 27, 2024

    Why Tom Lee Thinks We Could See S&P 15,000 by 2030

    Why Tom Lee Thinks We Could See S&P 15,000 by 2030

    The stock market has had a torrid run in 2024 despite the fact that interest rate cuts haven't materialized in the way people had expected at the start of the year. In fact, outside of a few blips here and there (like spring 2020), US stocks have been phenomenal performers for years. Tom Lee, the founder of Fundstrat and FS Insight has been bullish for a long time, having caught the correct side of this lengthy trend. On this episode, we speak to the former JPMorgan strategist about how he thinks about the market, what he sees happening right now in macro and demographic trends, and why he thinks it’s plausible that the market could roughly triple in the next six years.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 24, 2024

    Related Episodes

    It's Time to Pay More Attention to Your Personal Lines Insurance

    It's Time to Pay More Attention to Your Personal Lines Insurance

    For years, homeowners and personal automobile insurance has been an afterthought for most owners of homes and vehicles.  The policies reviewed annually without much fanfare or thought.  It seems that all of a sudden we have had a seismic shift in awareness and challenges.  2023 saw the largest number of billion dollar claim events and these were concentrated not only on the coasts but also in the interior of the country.  They ranged from flood, wind, fire, hail, and tornado activity.  This has resulted in significant profitability challenges for personal lines insurance carriers and changes in what is available in the market and what is expected of insurance purchasers.  The carriers all assume they will continue to be on the front line of these increased natural disasters and don't see a likelihood of a slow down in this activity in the coming years.  Matt Akin, leader of the personal lines business at Kraus-Anderson Insurance Agency joins us this month to shed some light on the current challenges and some possible solutions.  

    Direct Indexing Vs. Index Funds: Which Is Better? -Money Q&A

    Direct Indexing Vs. Index Funds: Which Is Better?  -Money Q&A
    In this episode of the Personal Finance Podcast, we're going to be talking about direct indexing vs. buying index funds and ETFs. Which is better? How Andrew Can Help You:  Don't let another year pass by without making significant strides toward your dreams. "Master Your Money Goals" is your pathway to a future where your aspirations are not just wishes but realities. Enroll now and make this year count! Join The Master Money Newsletter where you will become smarter with your money in 5 minutes or less per week Here! Learn to invest by joining  Index Fund Pro! This is Andrew’s course teaching you how to invest!  Watch The Master Money Youtube Channel!  Ask Andrew a question on Instagram or TikTok.  Learn how to get out of Debt by joining our Free Course  Leave Feedback or Episode Requests here.  Thanks to Our Amazing Sponsors for supporting The Personal Finance Podcast. Shopify: Shopify makes it so easy to sell. Sign up for a one-dollar-per-month trial period at  shopify.com/pfp Monarch Money: Get an extended 30 day free trial at monarchmoney/pfp Thanks to Fundrise for Sponsoring the show! Invest in real estate going to fundrise.com/pfp Indeed: Start hiring NOW with a SEVENTY-FIVE DOLLAR SPONSORED JOB CREDIT to upgrade your job post at Indeed.com/personalfinance Thanks to Policy Genius for Sponsoring the show! Go to policygenius.com to get your free life insurance quote. Chime: Start your credit journey with Chime. Sign-up takes only two minutes and doesn’t affect your credit score. Get started at chime.com/  Links Mentioned in This Episode:  The Easiest Way To Invest: Target Date Retirement Funds Simple Financial Steps with Massive Payoffs with Paul Merriman Connect With Andrew on Social Media:  Instagram  TikTok Twitter  Master Money Website  Master Money Youtube Channel   Free Guides:   The Stairway to Wealth: The Order of Operations for your Money  How to Negotiate Your Salary  The 75 Day Money Challenge  Get out Of Debt Fast  Take the Money Personality Quiz Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    59. “98% of our net worth is in real estate. Are we in trouble?”

    59. “98% of our net worth is in real estate. Are we in trouble?”
    Georgia and James bring a different problem to the table than we’re used to hearing about. In this one, we zoom in on where, exactly, their net worth has come from… and the real risks of these decisions. Having done well in the real estate market, Georgia and James just closed on a fourth property. The glaring issue is that they’re all located in the same neighborhood, amping up the risk of this investment class quite considerably. Georgia is becoming increasingly anxious in the shadow of this risk, urging a diversification from their overloaded 98% commitment to housing. James is not unwilling to hear the argument, which makes this episode more direct and tactical—I love it. There’s a lot to learn here. The biggest question we can ask in this case: Why are they even doing this? What is the end goal? Their answer paints a clear picture of what they need to do. Connect with Ramit Website Instagram Twitter Facebook YouTube Linkedin If you and your partner have a money issue and you want my help, I occasionally select a couple to work with, free of charge. Apply for my help here. Produced by Crate Media.