Logo

The Deal and its Political Fallout - with Amit Segal

en

January 28, 2025

TLDR: Amit Segal discusses opinions within Israel against the hostage deal, as a guest on Call Me Back podcast.

1Ask AI

In this insightful episode of Call Me Back, host Dan Senor sits down with Amit Segal, the chief political correspondent and analyst for Channel 12 News and Yediot Ahronot. They discuss the recent hostage deal involving Israel and its significant political implications, especially focusing on the conflicting opinions among the Israeli public.

Key Themes of the Episode

The Historical Context of Hostage Negotiations

  • Israel has historically taken a hard stance against negotiating with terrorists, resulting in deadly military operations to rescue hostages during the 1970s and 1980s.
  • A notable shift occurred over time as Israel began to make concessions, progressing from one-for-one trades to trading thousands of prisoners for hostages.
  • Amit highlights a pivotal moment: the release of over a thousand terrorists in exchange for Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit, raising concerns about the future implications of such agreements.

The Current Hostage Deal

  • The current deal has raised eyebrows among certain segments of Israeli society. Segal emphasizes that the decision-making process in such complex situations is incredibly challenging, often forcing leaders to choose between two undesirable outcomes.
  • Amit himself would lean towards supporting the deal but acknowledges that it is fraught with complications. He advocates for giving voice to dissenting opinions regarding its terms and implications.

Concerns About the Deal

  • The episode articulates the fears surrounding the potential for a resurgence of terrorist activity from those released. Segal refers to past deals that inadvertently strengthened terrorist positions, such as the leader of the recent October 7th attack being released during the exchange in 2011.
  • A critical aspect discussed is the military price paid as part of this deal, with Israel allegedly conceding its military accuracy in northern Gaza by allowing Hamas to reclaim territory, raising questions about national security and deterrence.

Perspectives on Israel's Geopolitical Standing

  • The conversation shifts towards Israel's strategic positioning in the region, noting that while Hamas has weakened, it still remains a considerable threat. The leaders highlight the importance of seizing a strategic opportunity now while Israel holds a stronger position compared to the past.
  • Both Segal and Senor suggest that while there's a risk in engaging with Hamas, the current geopolitical climate might justify cautious negotiations to maximize the opportunity for peace and security for Israel.

Reactions from the Public

  • The episode also delves into the public’s reaction, characterized by a mix of support and criticism. Segal underlines that the Israeli public must be allowed to freely discuss and debate the implications of these deals without being labeled negatively for their opinions.
  • The complexity of the situation is illustrated by contrasting the feelings of hostage families, who might prioritize immediate rescue, with strategic thinkers who ponder the long-term consequences of negotiating with terrorist groups.

Future Implications and Strategies

  • An essential discussion point revolves around how these negotiations could affect future Israeli policy. The concern is that these deals might incentivize future hostage-taking, leading to an escalatory cycle.
  • Amit stresses the importance of evaluating the long-term impacts rather than reacting out of immediate emotional responses.

Closing Thoughts on Leadership and Strategy

  • In wrapping up, Amit Segal expresses skepticism about the Israeli leadership's capacity to navigate these complex negotiations effectively, bearing in mind the distrust between Israel and Palestinian authorities.
  • The hope is that a strong leadership, regardless of prevailing political tides, can effectively manage these strategic engagements without damaging Israel's long-term security interests.

Conclusion

In this episode of Call Me Back, Amit Segal offers a nuanced perspective on the ongoing hostage negotiations, addressing both the historical context and the future of Israeli security. His insights reflect the deep complexities of making political decisions that involve immediate human lives with long-term national security implications. By illuminating the various public opinions surrounding the deal, Amit calls for a more inclusive discourse on the matters at hand, ultimately underscoring the importance of robust and thoughtful decision-making in Israel's political landscape.

Was this summary helpful?

Recent Episodes

EMERGENCY EPISODE: TRUMP & THE FUTURE OF GAZA - with Rich Goldberg

EMERGENCY EPISODE: TRUMP & THE FUTURE OF GAZA - with Rich Goldberg

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor

Watch Call me Back on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CallMeBackPodcast To contact us, sign up for updates, and access transcripts, visit: https://arkmedia.org/ Dan on X: https://x.com/dansenor Dan on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/dansenor Yesterday, in a dramatic and unexpected press conference with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, President Trump called for a U.S. takeover of Gaza, and to relocate its two million Palestinian residents to alternative countries. President Trump also issued a series of executive orders impacting Israel and the Middle East, including one imposing maximum pressure on Iran. To discuss these fast-moving developments, Rich Goldberg returns to the podcast. Rich is a senior advisor at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD). From 2019-2020, he served as Director for Countering Iranian Weapons of Mass Destruction for the Trump White House National Security Council (NSC). He previously served as a national security staffer in the U.S. Senate and U.S. House and is an officer in the U.S. Navy Reserve with military experience on the Joint Staff and in Afghanistan. CREDITS:ILAN BENATAR - Producer & EditorMARTIN HUERGO - EditorREBECCA STROM - Director of OperationsSTAV SLAMA - ResearcherGABE SILVERSTEIN - Research InternYUVAL SEMO - Music Composer 

February 05, 2025

The Road to Riyadh - with Nadav Eyal

The Road to Riyadh - with Nadav Eyal

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor

Watch Call me Back on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CallMeBackPodcast To contact us, sign up for updates, and access transcripts, visit: https://arkmedia.org/ Dan on X: https://x.com/dansenor Dan on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/dansenor As Israelis welcome home more hostages after 15 months in Hamas captivity, we sat down with Nadav Eyal to discuss what their stories reveal about their captivity, their role in Israel’s national healing process, and the broader implications for Israeli society. We also discuss the ongoing negotiations for the next phase of hostage releases, the political stakes surrounding Netanyahu’s visit to Washington, and how these developments could shape Israel and the region. Nadav Eyal is a columnist for Yediiot. He is one of Israel’s leading journalists. Eyal has been covering Middle-Eastern and international politics for the last two decades for Israeli radio, print and television news. CREDITS: ILAN BENATAR - Producer & Editor MARTIN HUERGO - Editor REBECCA STROM - Director of Operations STAV SLAMA - Researcher  GABE SILVERSTEIN - Research Intern  YUVAL SEMO - Music Composer

February 03, 2025

Decoding Trump’s Foreign Policy - with Walter Russell Mead

Decoding Trump’s Foreign Policy - with Walter Russell Mead

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor

Discussion on U.S. foreign policy under Trump with Walter Russell Mead, Global View columnist at WSJ and distinguished fellow at Hudson Institute. Topic includes interpretation of the president's approach, geopolitical implications for Middle East & other hotspots, and the relevance of the hostage/ceasefire deal.

January 30, 2025

A new U.S. president and the Middle East - with Tal Becker

A new U.S. president and the Middle East - with Tal Becker

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor

Discussion about potential opportunities for U.S.-Israel relations, featuring Dr. Tal Becker, a veteran member of Israeli peace negotiation teams and expert scholar who contributed to the Abraham Accords. Tal served as Legal Adviser at the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs and won awards like Rabin Peace Prize and Guggenheim Prize.

January 24, 2025

AI

Ask this episodeAI Anything

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor

Hi! You're chatting with Call Me Back - with Dan Senor AI.

I can answer your questions from this episode and play episode clips relevant to your question.

You can ask a direct question or get started with below questions -

Sign In to save message history