The Birth of “Irrational Exuberance”
en
November 19, 2024
TLDR: The podcast discusses John Law, France's minister of finance, who was influential before Alan Greenspan and is associated with turning the Federal Reserve into a 'Casino Central'.
In the podcast episode titled The Birth of 'Irrational Exuberance', host George Fort Smith delves into the historical financial phenomenon led by John Law, a Scottish financier, whose strategies during the early 18th century significantly influenced the economy of France. This summary highlights the journey of John Law, the creation of the Mississippi Bubble, and the enduring themes of irrational exuberance in financial markets.
Introduction to John Law
- Background: John Law was a visionary who believed that a scarcity of money was at the heart of economic problems. In his 1705 monetary tract, he proposed radical ideas to revive economies through enhanced money supply.
- Move to France: After gaining attention in Scotland, Law took his theories to France, presenting them to Philippe d'Orléans, the regent in charge of French finances, who was desperately in need of a rescue plan after his previous schemes failed.
Establishment of the Bank Royale
- Controller General: In 1716, Law was appointed the head of the Banc Générale, which later became the Bank Royale, granting him the power to issue banknotes and control the money supply.
- Innovative Backing: Law proposed backing his bank’s notes not just with gold, but with France's vast land holdings. This strategy aimed to combat the scarcity of money, although it lacked clarity on how these notes could truly be redeemed for land.
The Mississippi Company
- Formation: Law, along with the regent, developed the Compagnie des Indes, which had exclusive trading rights over the Louisiana territory.
- Investment Frenzy: Shares in this company could initially only be purchased with government bonds that had lost considerable value. This venture was soon dubbed the Mississippi System, igniting a wave of public interest and speculation.
- Economic Surge: As speculation climbed, the economy thrived with burgeoning share prices and a taste of prosperity. A wide demographic, from wealthy aristocrats to ordinary laborers, became investors in this scheme.
The Rise of Irrational Behavior
- Wealth Creation: With fortunes rapidly made, the term ‘millionaire’ emerged, and an economic frenzy took hold of the populace. Individuals like Law’s coachman turned into wealthy investors overnight.
- Population Dynamics: The excitement surrounding the Mississippi System caused a frenzied atmosphere in Paris, drawing all walks of life into a speculative bubble, leading to chaotic trading experiences.
The Downfall Begins
- Initial Cracks: By early 1720, the foundation of this bubble began to crumble. An aristocrat, Prince de Conti, challenged the Bank Royale by redeeming notes for gold, prompting a cascade of distrust among other aristocrats.
- Panic Sets In: As concerns about the currency’s value grew, individuals started withdrawing their funds en masse. This hoarding sparked panic, exacerbating the already precarious economic situation.
Government Responses and Consequences
- Failed Interventions: In response to the growing crisis, Philippe resorted to declaring hoarding illegal, driving people further away from trusting the bank. Additionally, the issuance of over a billion livres in worthless notes only inflated despair rather than alleviating it.
- Public Dissent: Ultimately, the grand parades of laborers with picks and shovels to mine in Louisiana only highlighted the absurdity of the promised wealth, culminating in widespread disillusionment.
The Legacy of John Law
- Historical Perspective: While John Law faced ruin, leaving France in economic disarray by the end of 1720, he is viewed sympathetically by modern economists.
- Economic Impact: Renowned economic historians place him among the greatest monetary theorists, acknowledging the lasting lessons that his experiments impart regarding money supply and public trust.
Conclusion: Lessons of Irrational Exuberance
John Law's story serves as a stark reminder of the thin line between financial innovation and reckless speculation. The allure of easy money swiftly leads to irrational behavior, magnifying risks and culminating in eventual collapse. As reflected in today’s economic context, the echoes of the Mississippi Bubble remind us that unchecked monetary policy and human behavior can lead to devastating outcomes. The episode wraps up with a thought-provoking reflection on the phrase 'End the Fed', evoking contemporary discussions on monetary policy and financial regulation.
This insightful examination not only charts the history of an economic disaster but also emphasizes the importance of trust, transparency, and sound economic principles in financial systems.
Was this summary helpful?
Recent Episodes
Copernicus Was Also Right in Economics
Audio Mises Wire
Nicolaus Copernicus, astronomer and creator of heliocentrism theory, made astute observations about economics in addition to his work on astronomy.
November 26, 2024
Free Markets Don’t Need Government Regulation
Audio Mises Wire
'Economic moderates' claim to support free-market capitalism but also advocate for some government oversight; free markets are argued to regulate themselves without such oversight.
November 26, 2024
Why People Pay Higher Prices for Some Goods Relative to Others
Audio Mises Wire
Carl Menger's 1871 Principles assert that people rank their preferences, valuing some things more than others, with substantial implications for economic theory.
November 19, 2024
If Republicans Are Against Lawfare, They Shouldn’t Have Unleashed It
Audio Mises Wire
The expansion of federal criminal law during Wall Street prosecutions 40 years ago is credited for the potency of lawfare as a political weapon today.
November 19, 2024
Ask this episodeAI Anything
Sign In to save message history