Logo

    Starmer vs. The Media – Can Labour handle the press?

    Labour leader Keir Starmer under media pressure over Swiftgate/freebie scandal. Broadcaster Adam Boulton discusses Labour vs media and news business changes. Wes Streeting asked public for NHS solutions, got suggestions like 'beer on tap'. Is it worth asking the public for ideas? Podcast produced by Podmasters.

    1
    enOctober 25, 2024
    Oh God, What Now?

    576 Episodes

    What was the main topic of the podcast episode?
    Summarise the key points discussed in the episode?
    Were there any notable quotes or insights from the speakers?
    Which popular books were mentioned in this episode?
    Were there any points particularly controversial or thought-provoking discussed in the episode?
    Were any current events or trending topics addressed in the episode?

    In the latest episode of Oh God, What Now?, host Ros Taylor delves into the prickly relationship between Labour leader Keir Starmer and the British media amidst ongoing scrutiny from the press over issues around ethics and accountability, particularly the so-called "Swiftgate" scandal. Joining her are broadcaster Adam Boulton and political correspondents Ava Santina and Rafael Behr, who offer their expertise on the current state of British politics and the media landscape.

    The Media's Perception of Labour

    Continual Pressure on Starmer

    Starmer has faced intense media pressure, with accusations of hypocrisy and ethical missteps swirling since he took office. The media's portrayal casts him as someone who espouses high ethical standards while simultaneously indulging in perks that contradict his messaging. Adam Boulton emphasizes that while the alleged "freebies" may appear trivial, the optics are detrimental:

    • Unfavorable Comparisons: Starmer's acceptance of gifts like concert tickets has led to comparisons with previous Labour leaders who faced similar scrutiny, amplifying perceptions of hypocrisy.
    • Mismanagement of Media Relations: Starmer's team has struggled to control the narrative effectively, leaving room for the media to persistently question their integrity.

    Comparison to Past Labour Strategies

    Boulton draws parallels to New Labour's media strategy in the late '90s:

    • Proactive Engagement: New Labour was adept at courting the press, understanding the importance of creating relationships with journalists. Starmer’s approach seems less connect, leading to unfavorable press.
    • Transparency and Accountability: During Tony Blair's time, transparency following scandals helped quickly turn the narrative. Starmer’s administration seems to falter under similar scrutiny due to a lack of a cohesive response plan.

    The Changing Landscape of Journalism

    Current Media Dynamics

    The discussion moves on to the broader changes affecting journalism in the UK:

    • Revenue Losses: Traditional media outlets face significant financial pressure from digital platforms. This has created an environment where quality news gathering is under threat.
    • Shift Towards Commentary: There’s growth in the influence of commentary-led platforms, with less focus on traditional news reporting, posing risks for informed public discourse.

    The Role of Social Media

    • Misinformation Risks: The rise of social media as a primary news source has increased the prevalence of misinformation, complicating the task of holding political figures accountable.
    • Accessibility vs. Quality: While social media provides more diverse viewpoints, it can breed polarization and reduce the quality of public debate.

    Labour’s Handling of Scandals

    Swiftgate and Its Implications

    The so-called "Swiftgate" issue highlights Labour's media relations pitfalls:

    • Conflicts of Interest: The controversy involves questions of whether accepting concert tickets from the Premier League while planning regulatory oversight constitutes a conflict of interest.
    • Public Sentiment: The public reacts to these stories, creating a narrative that distracts from the party’s policy goals and achievements.

    Labour's Response Strategy

    The panel discusses potential strategies Labour could adopt to improve its media relations:

    • Better Communication: A more aggressive media strategy could help the party articulate its policies effectively, rather than allowing the press to dominate the narrative.
    • Building Trust: Establishing trustworthy relationships with journalists is essential to ensure that the party's messages are reported accurately.

    Engaging the Public

    Can Public Consultation Work?

    In the episode's extra segment, the panel critiques Labour's recent public engagement initiatives requesting suggestions for improving the NHS:

    • Receptiveness to Ideas: While public consultations can yield helpful suggestions, some ideas can appear trivial or impractical, complicating the genuine discourse on public services.
    • Potential for Frustration: The risk remains that such initiatives can frustrate the public rather than engage them positively.

    Conclusion

    The episode reveals a nuanced picture of the challenges facing Keir Starmer and the Labour Party in navigating a hostile media landscape. It suggests that without a proactive and structured approach to communication and transparency, Labour risks continued struggles against a backdrop of skepticism and critical media narratives. The panel's insights emphasize that reconnecting with both the media and public will be crucial for Labour’s effectiveness as they move forward in their parliamentary agenda.

    Was this summary helpful?

    Recent Episodes from Oh God, What Now?

    Harris-Trump finale: Fear of an orange planet

    Harris-Trump finale: Fear of an orange planet
    Discusses uncertainty around Trump's chances in US 2020 election and impact on the Republican Party, featuring guest Reed Galen, Republican campaign veteran who is an anti-Trumper. Also touches on Kemi Badenoch's leadership of the Tory party and lessons to be learned from Trump's tenure.
    Oh God, What Now?
    enNovember 05, 2024

    I like big budgets and I cannot lie

    I like big budgets and I cannot lie
    Labour's first budget since regaining power explained by former chief economist Jonathan Portes; discussion on angertainment shaping world events and potential influence on 2024 U.S. Presidential election; extra bit about UK bus fare increase.
    Oh God, What Now?
    enNovember 01, 2024

    Related Episodes

    We've picked the wingnuts by mistake!

    We've picked the wingnuts by mistake!
    Two candidates remain in the Tory leadership race: Kemi Badenoch and Robert Jenrick. The new government has been in place for 100 days, and it's unclear how long Keir Starmer has to start showing results. ITV’s Anushka Asthana discusses her book 'Taken as Red' this week.
    Oh God, What Now?
    enOctober 15, 2024

    The Labour Purge

    The Labour Purge
    Ed Campbell discusses SNP news from First Minister in Scotland, while Ava Santina talks about Labour de-selections following the Stand with Diane rally.
    Pubcast
    enMay 30, 2024
    Logo

    © 2024 Podcastworld. All rights reserved

    Company

    Pricing

    Stay up to date

    For any inquiries, please email us at hello@podcastworld.io