Logo

Q&A: The Efficient Frontier Was Perfect Until HR Got Involved

en

January 28, 2025

TLDR: Listeners learn about dealing with limited investment options in employer-sponsored 401k plans and how to identify oversights in rollovers from 401k to a traditional IRA. Molly shares her experience and Joe Saul-Sehy offers advice.

1Ask AI

In Episode #577 of the Afford Anything podcast, hosts Paula Pant and Joe Saul-Sehy delve into the concept of the Efficient Frontier—a crucial topic for those serious about maximizing their investment returns. Their discussion is framed around listener Kelsey’s dilemma, who finds herself limited by the investment options available in her employer-sponsored 401k. This episode provides valuable insights into how to effectively manage investment portfolios despite restrictions.

Understanding the Efficient Frontier

The Efficient Frontier is a financial theory pioneered by Nobel laureate Dr. Harry Markowitz. It suggests that, given a set level of risk, there is a most efficient portfolio mix that maximizes potential returns. The three factors influencing this are:

  • Timeframe: The duration until reaching a financial goal.
  • Risk Level: A personal assessment of how much risk can be tolerated.
  • Expected Returns: The anticipated outcomes needed to meet financial objectives.

Key Insights from the Podcast:

  1. Portfolio Construction: Joe shares that often, investors grapple with how many funds to include in their portfolio, ranging from two to ten. The optimal number doesn't just hinge on an arbitrary figure but rather on achieving an effective mix that aligns with one's investment strategy and goals.
  2. The 401k Dilemma: Kelsey’s question highlights a common frustration. Despite her awareness of the Efficient Frontier and its principles, the reality of having suboptimal fund choices in her 401k poses a significant barrier.
  3. Identifying Available Options: The hosts suggest evaluating the available funds in her 401k to see how they can fit into the broader goal of reaching the Efficient Frontier.

Tips for Navigating Limited Fund Options

The episode transitions into practical strategies for Kelsey—and listeners facing similar constraints:

  • Analyze Current Holdings: Investors should start by taking stock of the available options within their 401k. Understanding existing assets is critical.
  • Use Portfolio Visualizer: The hosts recommend using tools like Portfolio Visualizer, which can help users visualize expected returns against risk and assess how their current holdings align with the Efficient Frontier.
  • Asset Location Strategy: If someone has multiple investment accounts (like IRAs or HSAs), they can allocate more efficiently across these to counterbalance any limitations in their 401k offerings. For example, overweight positions in asset classes missing from the 401k can be placed in IRAs or brokerage accounts.

The Importance of Tracking Net Worth

Another insightful takeaway comes from Molly, a listener who reflects on the benefits of manually calculating net worth. She reveals how this practice enabled her to catch misallocations (like uninvested funds in a money market account). Key benefits identified include:

  • Awareness of Financial Oversights: Regular tracking can illuminate discrepancies that may otherwise go unnoticed.
  • Encourages Better Financial Habits: Tracking fosters a deeper understanding and respect for financial choices, akin to monitoring daily activity for fitness.

Conclusion: Empowering Investors with Knowledge

Throughout the episode, Paula and Joe stress that while tools and strategies are critical, the real power lies in understanding the underlying principles of investing. They encourage listeners like Kelsey to take initiative, explore resources, and make informed choices regarding their portfolios.

In summary, the Efficient Frontier is not merely a complex financial theory; it provides a practical framework for investors to optimize their portfolios, even within the confines of 401k limitations. With this knowledge and supportive tools, anyone can work towards achieving their financial goals more efficiently.

Was this summary helpful?

Recent Episodes

Treasury Tantrums, Arctic Routes, and McKinley's Ghost

Treasury Tantrums, Arctic Routes, and McKinley's Ghost

Afford Anything

#580: "If you want to understand what's happening in the economy, look at bonds," begins today's episode, where we explore how the bond market acts as a crystal ball for economic trends. The bond market has been sending some clear signals lately. Interest rates remain elevated, with 10-year Treasury yields about 1 percent higher than their September 2024 low. After a challenging 2024 where bond returns flattened to just 1.18 percent, both the U.S. and U.K. are seeing historically high yields. We break down what's driving these changes and explain key concepts like term premium — the extra return investors demand for holding longer-term bonds. The Federal Reserve's recent moves are shaping this landscape. After cutting rates by 1 percentage point between September and December 2024, Fed officials are now signaling a more cautious approach, wanting to see further inflation decline before considering additional cuts. Then we explore why President William McKinley is suddenly relevant again. McKinley, whose term began in 1897, was known for his imperialist expansion and love of tariffs. His presidency came towards the end of what historians call "the long 19th century" — a period from the French Revolution in 1789 to the start of World War I in 1914. This era was marked by massive social upheaval, major technological advancement, the First Industrial Revolution, and huge migration into cities. It also included the California and Klondike Gold Rushes. The episode then turns to what some are calling the "Cold Rush" — the race to claim influence in the rapidly changing Arctic. With ice melting four times faster than global averages and the potential for ice-free Arctic days by 2030, nations are competing for new shipping routes and access to resources. We examine three emerging paths: the Northern Sea Route along Russia's coast, the North-West Passage along North America, and the Transpolar Sea Route across the North Pole. Finally, we dive into an overlooked story: the global tax war. In 2021, 136 countries agreed to establish a 15 percent minimum corporate tax rate to prevent profit-shifting to tax havens. While the U.S. already exceeds this minimum with its 21 percent domestic rate, implementation faces challenges due to different methodologies for calculating tax bases and recent political developments that could affect its future. Resources mentioned: https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/the-treasury-tantrum-of-2023-20240903.html https://www.pimco.com/us/en/insights/will-the-true-treasury-term-premium-please-stand-up https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/empsit.pdf https://youtu.be/gQqcKepuQdA?feature=shared https://www.morningstar.com/bonds/how-largest-bond-funds-did-2024 https://www.npr.org/2025/02/05/1229167003/mckinley-trump-tin-tariffs https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2025/01/23/the-arctic-climate-changes-great-economic-opportunity https://www.clingendael.org/pub/2020/presence-before-power/4-greenland-what-is-china-doing-there-and-why/ https://www.clingendael.org/pub/2020/presence-before-power/ For more information, visit the show notes at https://affordanything.com/episode580 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

February 08, 2025

Q&A: Two Weeks Until My Tenants Move In And I Have Nowhere to Go

Q&A: Two Weeks Until My Tenants Move In And I Have Nowhere to Go

Afford Anything

#579: Todd is in a real estate bind. He found out six days before closing on a new home that it wasn’t legally sellable. And renters are moving into his current home in two weeks. What should he do? Anonymous is excited about expanding her real estate portfolio. Should she sell her $2.5 million rental property in the Bay Area to do this, or can she keep it and leverage the equity instead? Former financial planner Joe Saul-Sehy and I tackle these two questions in today’s episode. Enjoy! P.S. Got a question? Leave it at https://affordanything.com/voicemail For more information, visit the show notes at https://affordanything.com/episode579 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

February 04, 2025

The Hidden Cost of Playing It Safe With Money, with Dr. Margie Warrell

The Hidden Cost of Playing It Safe With Money, with Dr. Margie Warrell

Afford Anything

Dr. Margie Warrell discusses stepping out of the 'courage gap' to make brave financial decisions, such as taking concrete steps to build wealth and investing. She emphasizes that courage is taking action despite fear, even amidst market volatility. The podcast offers 5 critical steps: focusing on wants over fears, reframing narratives, practicing physical methods to manage fear, stepping into discomfort, and learning from setbacks.

January 31, 2025

The World's Richest People Are Weird by Design, with William Green

The World's Richest People Are Weird by Design, with William Green

Afford Anything

#576: The world's greatest investors have a secret: they're weird.  When one young fund manager met Bill Miller for the first time, he refused to shake hands. Instead, he locked eyes and declared: "I'm going to beat you, man." William Green joins us to share what he's learned from decades of conversations with investing legends — from the hyper-competitive to the deeply philosophical.  These conversations reveal that success isn't just about strategy; it's about understanding yourself and playing to your strengths. The best investors are mavericks who think differently. They're willing to look strange, be lonely, and diverge from the crowd. Templeton demonstrated this during WWII. When Germany invaded France and markets crashed, he bought 104 stocks trading under $1 — including 37 bankrupt companies. His contrarian bet paid off 5x when markets recovered. But Green emphasizes this isn't just about getting rich.  His decades of interviews reveal deeper wisdom about building a good life: Great investors focus on what they can control. They can't predict markets, but they can manage their behavior and emotions. They embrace simplicity. Jack Bogle advocated owning low-cost index funds rather than chasing complex strategies. They understand odds and risk. Howard Marks asks "What's the consequence if I'm wrong?" before making decisions. They play to their strengths. Charlie Munger says if you're 5'3", don't try to be a pro basketball player. They live below their means. As investor Tom Gaynor notes, "If you're living within your means, you're already rich." Green shares a practical framework called HALT PS — don't make important decisions when Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired, in Pain, or Stressed. This applies beyond investing to daily life. The conversation explores how to build resilience before market crashes through healthy habits, self-awareness, and preparation. Green notes that many successful investors practice meditation and read widely across disciplines. Even legends make mistakes. Bill Miller saw his assets drop from $77 billion to $800 million during the 2008 crisis. But he rebounded by staying true to his principles and learning from failure. Green's key message? Focus less on getting rich and more on building an "anti-fragile" life aligned with your values and strengths.  The best investors aren't just good at making money — they're skilled at creating lives of meaning and purpose. Find more from William Green at williamgreenwrites.com or on his podcast Richer, Wiser, Happier, featured on the We Study Billionaires feed. Timestamps: Note: Timestamps will vary on individual listening devices based on dynamic advertising run times. The provided timestamps are approximate and may be several minutes off due to changing ad lengths. (01:00) Meeting Sir John Templeton in the Bahamas (04:02) Templeton's WWII stock strategy during market crash (12:00) Wisdom vs survivorship bias in investing stories (14:55) Why great investors recommend index funds (23:34) Prioritizing freedom over wealth maximization (39:27) Bogle's client-first philosophy (51:32) Living below means for market volatility (01:01:37) HALT PS conditions leading to poor choices (01:06:45) Using data for better decision making (01:11:13) Bogle's emphasis on simple investing (01:14:30) Danoff's "stocks follow earnings" strategy For more information, visit the show notes at https://affordanything.com/episode576 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

January 24, 2025

AI

Ask this episodeAI Anything

Afford Anything

Hi! You're chatting with Afford Anything AI.

I can answer your questions from this episode and play episode clips relevant to your question.

You can ask a direct question or get started with below questions -

Sign In to save message history