Marx's Economic Analysis: Jamie Edwards and Brian Lighter examine Marx's economic theories, acknowledging flaws in his labor theory of value. They argue that if we reject this theory, Marx's predictions about capitalism’s downfall and the rise of socialism are undermined.
In their work, Jamie Edwards and Brian Lighter explore the ideas of Karl Marx, arguing that while some of his theories are flawed, his analysis of capitalism stands out. They discuss how the value of goods comes from the labor needed to produce them, leading to questions about how capitalists profit. Marx believed that when workers are paid for their labor power but produce more value than what they were paid for, that extra value is called surplus value, generating profit for capitalists. However, Edwards and Lighter note that this concept is problematic and must be rejected, as it cannot resolve key issues within Marx’s theories. If we abandon the labor theory of value, then Marx's predictions about capitalism being replaced by socialism lose their strength, raising doubts about the foundation of his economic analysis.
Capitalism's Dilemma: Marx's theory implies capitalism will fail as workers lose buying power due to reduced wages. Although he argues this through labor value, Edwards and Leiter show that the same outcome can be reached by examining the economic dynamics between workers and capitalists without relying solely on that theory.
Marx's idea of historical materialism suggests that the way a society produces goods influences its social structure. As technology advances, workers may lose their jobs or face reduced pay, resulting in less ability to buy products. Capitalists may try to cut wages to maximize profits, but this can backfire as workers lose purchasing power, making it hard for businesses to sell their goods. Although Marx's labor theory of value argues that capitalism will eventually collapse due to this profit squeeze, Edwards and Leiter suggest that the same conclusion can be reached without it. They emphasize that the balance of power between employers and workers is crucial; if workers can't negotiate fair wages, it could lead to significant societal shifts.
Wages and Socialism: Wages must match worker productivity to prevent losing talent. Automation's job creation is debated, and without market prices, economies may struggle. Some argue that socialism is morally necessary, despite its unclear implementation from Marx's perspective.
Wages should reflect a worker's value; otherwise, other firms will hire them away. Automation has previously created jobs, but now experts question if it will do so again. Prices that adapt to supply and demand mean the economy doesn't need constant spending. Socialism, according to Marx, will replace capitalism, but he didn't explain how it would work. Critics like Mises argue that without market prices, economies fail. Some modern socialists focus on the moral necessity of socialism rather than see it as an inevitable outcome. They highlight moral arguments to support their views, suggesting that even if early economic theories were mistaken, the moral case for socialism still stands strongly.
New “Engels” on Marx
Audio Mises Wire
149 Episodes
Recent Episodes from Audio Mises Wire
The Denarius and the Dollar: Price Controls Then and Now
The more things change, the more they remain the same. In our present age of inflation, we are reminded of how Diocletian and other Roman authorities ordered price controls and other measures to hold down prices. None of these edicts were successful in bringing down prices.
Original article: The Denarius and the Dollar: Price Controls Then and Now
An Economy So Strong It Requires Crisis-Level Fed Action
The Fed’s specialty is propaganda through data, with a long record of failure. This is by design. Their communication tools must work in overtime, particularly in the face of a decision like this, to avoid “spooking markets”, though this veneer is easy to see through.
Original article: An Economy So Strong It Requires Crisis-Level Fed Action
Understanding the Basics of Modern Banking
Banking systems around the world have huge effects on our lives, yet few people understand how banks work. Worse yet, even fewer understand the malign powers of central banks and how this system undermines economies. Thus, it is important to demystify these systems.
Original article: Understanding the Basics of Modern Banking
The Fed Hits the Panic Button and Slashes the Fed Funds Rate
The Fed is desperate for you to think that “this time is different.” Unfortunately, Powell can’t seem to come up with explanation of why that is the case.
Original article: The Fed Hits the Panic Button and Slashes the Fed Funds Rate
Tariffs, Protectionism, and Why Borders Matter
The political zeitgeist is to embrace protectionism, leading some who support free trade to embrace open borders. However, as Murray Rothbard explained, people and societies are complex entities and what may work for trade does not work for open immigration.
Original article: Tariffs, Protectionism, and Why Borders Matter
The Second Trump Shooter Believed Exactly What the Establishment Media Wanted Him to Believe
After Trump narrowly escaped another assassination attempt, the establishment seems uninterested in the motives of the would-be shooter. Perhaps that’s because he’s echoing the same simplistic narratives about the Ukraine war and Trump that they demand we all believe.
Original article: The Second Trump Shooter Believed Exactly What the Establishment Media Wanted Him to Believe
The Gradual Leftward Shift in US Politics and Economy
This year's presidential election is presented in stark terms of right and left, Trump on the right and Harris on the left. However, it is more realistic to say that both candidates are to the left of where electoral politics was located just a couple decades ago.
Original article: The Gradual Leftward Shift in US Politics and Economy
Yes, We Should Defend the Term “Capitalism”
Many proponents of free markets have tried to cast aside the name “capitalism” as a descriptor of the market system. They should take caution before doing so.
Original article: Yes, We Should Defend the Term “Capitalism”
Understanding the Real Costs of Slavery: It’s Not Cheap labor
The standard belief is that slavery was about obtaining “cheap labor,“ yet nothing could be further from the truth. Slavery comes with high opportunity costs, which is why American slave owners depended upon several government regulations to subsidize their “peculiar institution.”
Original article: Understanding the Real Costs of Slavery: It’s Not Cheap labor
New “Engels” on Marx
It is understood that Marx's theories stand entirely upon his Labor Theory of Value. If that theory is discredited, so is the scenario that leads to the inevitable triumph of communism. That fact, however, doesn't stop Marx's disciples from employing other fallacies.
Original article: New “Engels” on Marx