How the White House Censored Americans During Covid (& Got Caught) | 9.24.23

    enSeptember 24, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • White House, FBI, and CDC potentially violated First Amendment by pressuring social media companies to censor COVID-19 postsA federal court ruled that the White House, FBI, and CDC likely pressured social media companies to censor COVID-19 posts, threatening regulatory action if they didn't comply. The ruling bars the Biden administration from communicating with these platforms, and the White House has filed an emergency appeal to the Supreme Court.

      The 5th Circuit Court recently ruled that the White House, FBI, and CDC likely violated the First Amendment by pressuring social media companies to censor posts related to COVID-19. This includes threats of regulatory action if the companies did not comply. The ruling bars the Biden administration from communicating with these platforms. The White House has filed an emergency appeal to the Supreme Court, and the outcome is pending. Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, a Stanford epidemiologist and plaintiff in the case, discussed on MorningWire how federal agencies were involved in censoring his posts. Depositions revealed threats from the White House to take down posts or face regulatory action, even if the information was true and contradicted government pandemic policies. The court compared the White House's actions to those of a mob or Orwell's Ministry of Truth.

    • Government agencies involved in content moderation raise concerns about free speechAmerican values of free speech are at risk with government agencies censoring both true and false speech, potentially harming individuals and suppressing opposing ideas

      The involvement of various government agencies, including the White House, in content moderation raises serious concerns about free speech and the suppression of opposing ideas. This is particularly concerning given the American commitment to the First Amendment and the historical rejection of similar overreaches in American history. The censorship of both true and false speech, even if inconvenient to government policies, is a breach of American values and has the potential to harm individuals professionally and personally. If given the opportunity, I would express these concerns to those involved and emphasize the importance of upholding free speech and allowing for open scientific debate.

    • Government censorship during pandemic silences scientistsGovernment censorship during the pandemic stifled open debate and self-censored scientists, damaging scientific progress and the reputation of dissenting ideas.

      During the pandemic, the American government engaged in censorship to silence scientific critics and protect a preferred narrative, making it difficult for scientists to speak up and challenge established views. This resulted in self-censorship among scientists due to fear of reprisals and reputational damage. The suppression of free speech in science undermines the scientific process, as science relies on open debate and the exchange of contradictory ideas. This unique situation, where a high-ranking government official dictated scientific truths, was unprecedented in the United States and represented a significant threat to the scientific community. The consequences of censorship extend beyond silencing individuals, as it also damages the reputation of dissenting ideas and stifles scientific progress.

    • Government-funded nonprofits flagging content for censorshipGovernment cannot force social media companies to censor based on nonprofits' lists, but the role of nonprofits in flagging alleged misinformation is problematic and may require legislation to prevent infringement on free speech.

      The role of nonprofits, funded by the government, in flagging alleged misinformation and influencing social media companies to censor content is problematic. The recent ruling by the 5th Circuit Court narrowed the scope of an injunction, allowing such organizations to continue identifying content for review. However, the companies cannot be forced to censor based on these lists. While the government has a responsibility to protect citizens' health and safety, this responsibility should not infringe upon free speech. The consequences of censorship, as seen in the past, can have detrimental effects on individuals and society as a whole. The solution may lie in legislation prohibiting the government from engaging in such activities and generating hit lists aimed at silencing specific individuals or ideas online.

    • School closures in blue states violated children's rights and freedom of speechDuring the pandemic, some blue states' school closures went beyond necessary science, suppressing evidence and censoring opposing views, causing harm to children's health and well-being, and infringing on Americans' freedom of speech.

      During the pandemic, school closures in some blue states lasted much longer than necessary based on scientific evidence. This suppression of evidence, coupled with censorship, led to detrimental health and well-being consequences, particularly for poor and minority children. The censorship environment, reminiscent of authoritarian countries, violated the rights of all Americans, preventing them from expressing their views freely. The ongoing case, Missouri v Biden, is not just about the individual plaintiffs but represents a larger issue for every American's freedom of speech.

    Recent Episodes from Morning Wire

    Support for Kamala Harris & Cheatle Under Fire | 7.23.24

    Support for Kamala Harris & Cheatle Under Fire | 7.23.24
    Most Democrats endorse Kamala Harris, will anyone challenge her for the nomination, and Secret Service head Kimberly Cheatle criticized by Democrats and Republicans. Get the facts first on Morning Wire. Ramp: "Now get $250 off when you join Ramp. Go to http://www.ramp.com/WIRE" ZBiotics: "The drink before drinking with ZBiotics. Get 15% off your order with promo code WIRE at http://www.ZBiotics.com/Wire"
    Morning Wire
    enJuly 23, 2024

    Latino Vote Momentum | 7.21.24

    Latino Vote Momentum | 7.21.24

    The Latino vote could make or break the 2024 election with Trump appearing to have all the momentum. In this episode, we sit down with Texas congresswoman Monica De La Cruz about the former President’s appeal to the demographic amid Biden's historic border crisis. Get the facts first with Morning Wire.

    Morning Wire
    enJuly 21, 2024

    Trump Accepts Nomination & The Forgotten Voters | 7.19.24

    Trump Accepts Nomination & The Forgotten Voters | 7.19.24

    Trump delivers first address since the attempt on his life, the secret service remains in hot water over their response to the attack on the former President, and the Republican party gives a voice to “forgotten Americans.” Get the facts first with Morning Wire.

    Netsuite: Take advantage of no payments and no interest for six months at http://www.NetSuite.com/MORNINGWIRE

    Rhone: Upgrade your closet with Rhone and use WIRE to save 20% at https://www.rhone.com/WIRE

    Morning Wire
    enJuly 19, 2024

    Related Episodes

    Miriam Cates and her Horrible Mates

    Miriam Cates and her Horrible Mates
    Meet this week’s Tory game-changer: Miriam Cates and her New Conservatives. Will their wizard scheme to kick out foreign care-home workers and stamp out sex education save the Tories’ bacon? Is she real or a cartoon rightist from a British version of The Handmaid’s Tale? Plus: Farage Against The Cash Machine. Can Zuckerberg’s new idea Threads kill Twitter? Our special guest Henry Morris AKA mischievous mega-tweeter ‘The Secret Tory’ tells how he hoodwinked everyone from your pub pals to the commanding heights of politics. And in the Extra Bit… Streaming TV is in trouble. Why? Tickets for Origin Story Live are here: https://www.tickettext.co.uk/ZwCihZbENZ Listen to our new newspaper review podcast PAPER CUTS here. https://listen.podmasters.uk/PCogwn • “Cates’s ‘Labour will nationalise our children’ thing reminds me of Emma Barnett asking if Labour were going to nationalise sausages.” – Zöe Grünewald • “As they say, the first casualty of the Culture War is the will to live.” – Henry Morris • “Maybe we DO need antagonists on social media? Otherwise people are just too nice?” – Marie le Conte Presented by Dorian Lynskey with Marie le Conte and Zöe Grünewald. Audio producer: Alex Rees. Producer: Chris Jones. Assistant Producer: Adam Wright. Art: James Parrett. Theme music by Cornershop. Managing Editor: Jacob Jarvis. Group Editor: Andrew Harrison. OH GOD, WHAT NOW? is a Podmasters production. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Twitter Accepts Elon Musk’s $44billion Acquisition Offer

    Twitter Accepts Elon Musk’s $44billion Acquisition Offer
    Twitter has announced that it has accepted Musk’s offer to acquire the publicly traded company at $54.20/share, valuing the social media platform at $44 billion.
    Twitter’s Independent Board Chair Bret Taylor says the Twitter Board conducted a thoughtful and comprehensive process to assess Elon’s proposal with a deliberate focus on value, certainty, and financing.
    He says the proposed transaction will deliver a substantial cash premium, and we believe it is the best path forward for Twitter’s stockholders.
    Musk repeated that free speech is the key to Twitter’s future adding that new products, fighting spam and opening up its algorithms, are things the company was already in the process of doing prior to his dramatic intervention.

    Testing Unknowns and Assumptions - Starting Something New - DO THE WORK #547

    Testing Unknowns and Assumptions - Starting Something New - DO THE WORK #547


    A dailyish show focusing on the reality of being a dad, running multiple businesses and all of the  organization, productivity, and life hacking that is in place to make it all work.  The show will make you cry, laugh, like me, and hate me, but most importantly it will remind you to remember what is truly important in your life.


    Each week the episodes follow a specific theme and that theme is covered in this podcast and two other platforms - Instagram and YouTube.


    Follow the all three parts of the intra-platform programming:

    Instagram: @DiegoFooter: http://bit.ly/2B3vprJ

    YouTube: Diego Footer: http://bit.ly/SubtoDiego

    Podcast: DO THE WORK: https://apple.co/2ERsLHZ


    Produced by podcaster, entrepreneur and dad of three daughters - Diego Footer.


    Support content I have created: