Logo

Ep. 2089 - The COLLAPSE Of The Elitists

en

November 20, 2024

TLDR: Columnist David Brooks discusses the destruction of pseudo-meritocracy; transgender controversy arises in House of Representatives; media disconnect from reality.

1Ask AI

In episode 2089 of the podcast, the host dives into several critical topics, discussing the decline of the elitist meritocracy in America, the ongoing transgender debate in politics, and the media's failure to connect with public sentiment. The episode draws on insights from columnist David Brooks, who critiques the current status of meritocracy and highlights the rise of non-traditional political figures in response to a perceived failure in elite governance.

Key Themes and Insights

The Failures of the Meritocracy

  • David Brooks' Perspective: David Brooks argues in his Atlantic article that the modern meritocracy is collapsing. He suggests that a shift in leadership styles, particularly in the mid-20th century, has led to a disconnect between the elites and the average Americans.
  • Technocracy vs. Meritocracy: The host critiques Brooks’ view, asserting that he confuses a legitimate meritocracy with technocracy. According to the host, a true meritocratic system should allow individuals with merit to rise based on their capabilities rather than through manipulated structures set up by an elite few.
  • Historical Context: The shift is traced back to the progressive movement of the early 20th century, where a belief developed that elites could manage society better than evolving systems like free markets and community institutions.

The Rise of Outsider Politicians

  • Reaction to Elitism: The emergence of leaders like Donald Trump and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is interpreted as a backlash to the failures of the entrenched elite. The podcast suggests that a desire for change is pushing the public towards these unconventional figures.
  • Public Sentiment: There's an observable disconnect between the political elite and the general populace, particularly in how issues of meritocracy and governance are understood and navigated by the public.

The Transgender Debate

  • Dueling Perspectives: A heated debate encapsulated by recent resolutions in the House of Representatives surrounding transgender individuals' access to bathrooms highlights the broader cultural and political dilemmas. Many see this as an example of how far the political discourse has diverged from the average citizen's views.
  • Cultural Disconnect: The host emphasizes that such social issues often contribute to a rift between traditional cultural values and modern progressive stances touted by the elite.

Insights on Educational Institutions

  • Collapse of Colleges: The episode critiques the failure of universities to uphold their original purposes—promoting productivity and virtue—arguing that they have shifted to a focus on elitist ideologies rather than serving broader societal needs.
  • Innovation and Productivity: There’s a strong defense of the role of free markets in fostering merit and moderating success, arguing that managed systems, supposedly founded on merit, often perpetuate elitism rather than diminish it.

Practical Applications for Listeners

  • Understanding Political Dynamics: Recognizing the significance of voter sentiment in shaping political outcomes and the importance of connecting to grassroots perspectives.
  • Valuing True Meritocracy: Listeners are encouraged to consider aspects of meritocracy in their own environments and how merit-based systems can be promoted to counter elitist governance.
  • Engagement in Civic Issues: The episode urges listeners to engage meaningfully with the ongoing cultural debates, particularly regarding societal changes and the role of government versus community solutions.

Conclusion

This episode of the podcast challenges listeners to reflect on the changing landscape of American politics under the strain of a supposed meritocratic collapse. It poses critical questions about the role of elite governance and the importance of community and market-based solutions in fostering genuine meritocracy and connectivity in society. Through the exploration of these themes, it advocates for a new political paradigm grounded in traditional values and genuine civic engagement.

Keywords

  • Meritocracy
  • Technocracy
  • Elite Governance
  • Political Outsiders
  • Transgender Debate
  • Cultural Disconnect
  • Educational Institutions
  • Community Solutions
  • Free Markets
  • Civic Engagement

This summary reflects the core discussions and insights provided in the podcast episode, conveying the host's perspective on contemporary issues facing society.

Was this summary helpful?

Recent Episodes

Black Friday: Save 50% on DailyWire+ Memberships

Black Friday: Save 50% on DailyWire+ Memberships

The Ben Shapiro Show

50% off annual memberships for DailyWire+, offering uncensored shows and groundbreaking documentaries.

November 23, 2024

Ep. 2091 - The Democrats’ Future Swirls The Toilet

Ep. 2091 - The Democrats’ Future Swirls The Toilet

The Ben Shapiro Show

Democrats ignoring election elephant; Nancy Mace advocates for biologically female bathrooms in Congress; upcoming advertiser censorship.

November 22, 2024

Ep. 2090 - Trump Is VENGEANCE

Ep. 2090 - Trump Is VENGEANCE

The Ben Shapiro Show

Team Trump addresses broken institutions, Democrats defend transgenderism and critique Israel, while Jaguar unveils an ineffective car ad; Matt Walsh's documentary 'Am I Racist?' is available on DailyWire+

November 21, 2024

Ep. 2088 - Joe and Mika BEND THE KNEE

Ep. 2088 - Joe and Mika BEND THE KNEE

The Ben Shapiro Show

MSNBC's Morning Joe hosts visit Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago; Biden ends his term internationally; Trump prepares military for border crisis.

November 19, 2024

AI

Ask this episodeAI Anything

The Ben Shapiro Show

Hi! You're chatting with The Ben Shapiro Show AI.

I can answer your questions from this episode and play episode clips relevant to your question.

You can ask a direct question or get started with below questions -

Sign In to save message history