Logo
    Search

    Conversation with Raj Chetty — Driving Upward Economic Mobility

    enSeptember 21, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • UAW Strike: Strategic Leverage PointsUAW strategically strikes at key leverage points, maintains strike fund, and keeps companies guessing for significant wage increases and better working conditions. Demands include 40% pay increase, 32-hour work week, pension plan expansion, and end to tiered wage system.

      The United Auto Workers Union is strategically striking against Detroit's big three auto companies, GM and Stellantis, asking for significant wage increases and better working conditions. The UAW is being smart about this by only striking at key leverage points in the supply chain, maintaining their strike fund, and keeping the companies guessing. Their demands for a 40% pay increase over the next 4 years, a 32-hour work week, expansion of pension plans, and an end to the tiered wage system are reasonable considering the increase in CEO pay and inflation over the years. The negotiations are ongoing, and it's expected that they will end up somewhere around 27 or 28% wage increase. The UAW's demands are not unreasonable, but they could benefit from more help, such as a minimum wage raise to $25 an hour.

    • Auto Industry's Labor Cost ChallengeTesla's dominance and lower labor costs force traditional automakers to innovate or fall behind. Proposed solutions include a federal union and $25 minimum wage, which studies show can boost the economy and create jobs without destroying them.

      The auto industry is facing a significant challenge due to the dominance of Tesla, which is worth more than most automakers combined and can innovate with lower labor costs. The industry's foreign manufacturers, including Toyota, Honda, and Hyundai, as well as new players like Rivian and Tesla, are pulling away from their competitors due to lower labor costs. To address this issue, a mandated federal union and a $25 an hour minimum wage are proposed. Contrary to concerns, studies show that increasing the minimum wage does not destroy jobs but creates them and boosts the economy. The transfer of wealth from shareholders to labor is necessary to reverse the trend of wage stagnation that began in the 1970s.

    • Inequality in America: Time for a Serious Reversion to the MeanDespite economic growth, bottom 90% Americans have seen little wealth creation and wage growth hasn't kept pace with productivity. A strong labor union led by a figurehead like President Biden could advocate for a $25/hour federal minimum wage, and professionals can use Canva for effective visual communication.

      While there have been significant periods of capital appreciation and productivity growth in America over the last few decades, the benefits have not been evenly distributed. The bottom 90% of Americans have seen very little incremental wealth creation, and the wage growth has not kept pace with productivity. The speaker argues that it's time for a serious reversion to the mean, and companies can afford to pay their workers more. However, the labor movement is fragmented and lacks unity, and there are concerns about corruption within unions. The speaker suggests that a single, strong labor union, led by someone like President Biden, could help address this issue by advocating for a federal minimum wage of $25 an hour. The speaker also emphasizes the importance of visual communication in the workplace and promotes Canva as a tool to help professionals create stunning presentations and documents quickly and easily.

    • Maximizing rewards with travel credit cardsHarvard study reveals income gap in higher education, perpetuating societal privilege. Make smart financial decisions, optimize rewards, and consider societal context.

      NerdWallet can help you make smarter financial decisions, particularly when it comes to travel credit cards. Their experts can help you compare and maximize your rewards, with some cards offering up to 10 times the points per dollar spent. Meanwhile, in the world of higher education, a recent study by Harvard University's Raj Chetty revealed that kids from higher income families are much more likely to attend elite colleges, potentially perpetuating privilege in society. The study also showed that the gap in academic achievement between rich and poor is now greater than the gap between black and white. While the 77x statistic is alarming, Chetty emphasizes that the issue goes beyond higher education and is rooted in a pipeline of disparities that starts at birth. Overall, it's important to make smart financial decisions and consider the broader societal context. Whether it's optimizing credit card rewards or pursuing higher education, every step counts. To learn more and find smarter financial solutions, visit nerdwallet.com.

    • Inequality in Ivy League AdmissionsDespite equal academic achievements, students from top 1% families are more likely to attend Ivy League colleges due to income inequality and limited seats. To promote equal opportunities, expanding access to high-quality education is crucial, including increasing seats at universities and investing in vocational programs.

      Despite similar academic achievements, students from top 1% families are significantly more likely to attend Ivy League colleges than those from middle-class families. This disparity is a result of a complex interplay of factors, including growing income inequality and limited college seats. The American dream of upward mobility is fading, with only half of today's young adults earning more than their parents did at the same age. To address this issue, expanding access to high-quality higher education, whether through existing institutions or creating new ones, is crucial. This could involve increasing the number of seats at universities like Harvard and Yale, or investing in state institutions. Additionally, addressing cultural expectations and reviving vocational education programs could also contribute to a more equitable education system. Ultimately, it's essential to recognize that the current system is not serving all students equally and that meaningful change is necessary to ensure a level playing field for future generations.

    • Expanding vocational programs and addressing cultural and social capital gapsVocational programs and job training can provide individuals with the skills to secure good jobs and be happy, regardless of their background. Addressing cultural norms and social capital gaps is essential to ensure these opportunities are accessible to all.

      There's a need for more vocational programs and job training opportunities beyond the traditional 4-year college pathway. These targeted programs can provide individuals with the necessary skills to secure good jobs and be happy, regardless of their background or socio-economic status. Programs like Year Up, which pairs disadvantaged youth with firms for apprenticeships and training, have shown positive results in increasing earnings by 30-40% in a sustained way. However, it's essential to acknowledge that cultural norms and social capital play a significant role in determining career aspirations. For kids growing up in disadvantaged neighborhoods, the college path may not even be on their radar. Addressing these issues requires a holistic approach, including expanding vocational programs and addressing cultural and social capital gaps. Additionally, the study of friendship and its correlation with economic success and mobility is gaining attention. Research suggests that having strong friendships can positively impact one's opportunities for upward mobility.

    • Interaction between Low and High Income Individuals Influences Economic MobilityStudies show similarities between maps of economic mobility and Facebook friendships. Cross-class interaction exposes individuals to new opportunities, influences aspirations, and promotes empathy. Integrating institutions and reducing friending bias can increase cross-class interaction and upward mobility.

      The areas where low and high income individuals interact and form friendships are strongly linked to economic mobility. According to a study, maps of economic mobility and Facebook friendships look similar. This interaction may influence individuals' aspirations and expose them to new opportunities, leading to upward mobility. Research also shows that growing up in areas with innovation or female inventors in specific fields increases the likelihood of becoming an inventor for girls. However, the benefits are not one-sided, as exposure to diverse backgrounds can also help wealthy children develop empathy and life skills. To increase cross-class interaction, efforts should focus on integrating institutions like schools and churches, as well as reducing friending bias within these environments. This can be achieved through tools like changing school district boundaries, providing housing vouchers, and implementing thoughtful architectural designs. Ultimately, creating more opportunities for cross-class interaction is essential for upward mobility and a more equitable society.

    • Shared experiences build friendships across diverse backgroundsUnderstanding the importance of shared activities and male role models in fostering friendships and promoting upward mobility is essential for addressing social and economic disparities.

      Common recreational activities, such as sports teams and religious groups, play a significant role in helping people from diverse backgrounds form friendships. This is important because these shared experiences create a sense of common ground, making it easier to bridge social divides. However, there is a need for more attention on this aspect of friending bias, as many policies focus solely on reducing segregation. Another key point discussed was the economic mobility disparities between black and white Americans, with gender playing a significant role. Black boys starting out in families with similar income levels to white boys are less likely to rise up the income distribution to the middle class or beyond. The presence of male role models, particularly for young boys, is also critical for their development and upward mobility. In conclusion, understanding the importance of shared experiences and the role of male role models in fostering friendships and promoting upward mobility is crucial for addressing social and economic disparities. By focusing on these aspects, we can create more inclusive environments and help bridge the divide between different communities.

    • Impact of male role models on boys' outcomesBoys from single-parent households face unique challenges due to lack of male role models, contributing to issues like incarceration. Solutions include helping children move to better communities and investing in affordable housing.

      The absence of male role models in a boy's life, particularly in disadvantaged communities, significantly impacts their outcomes. According to the data, boys from single-parent households face dramatically different challenges compared to girls, with a lack of male role models being a major contributing factor to issues like incarceration. This issue is not just about having a male role model in the family, but also about community-level factors. For instance, a child growing up in a community with more two-parent families and fathers present tends to have better outcomes, even if their own parents are single. To address this issue, potential solutions include helping children move to neighborhoods with better opportunities, such as higher quality schools and more accessible higher education, through housing voucher programs or other methods. Additionally, investing in affordable housing on a larger scale could also be part of the solution. Overall, the data highlights the importance of male role models and community support in helping boys overcome adversity and reach their full potential.

    • Promoting Social Mobility: Strategic Investments, Education, and Local SolutionsInvesting in low-income areas, improving access to higher education, and focusing on local solutions are key to addressing social mobility. Geographic mobility is also important, but not all residents of rapidly growing cities are benefiting equally.

      Addressing the issue of social mobility and creating opportunities for individuals, particularly in low-income areas, requires a multi-faceted approach. This includes making strategic investments in those areas, improving access to higher education, and focusing on local solutions rather than looking solely to other countries for role models. Additionally, mobility in general, including geographic mobility, is an important factor to consider, with some regions experiencing higher rates of mobility than others. However, not all residents of rapidly growing cities are benefiting from this growth, and it's crucial to ensure that these opportunities are accessible to all members of the community. Overall, the conversation emphasized the importance of addressing structural factors and local solutions to promote social mobility and create opportunities for individuals to succeed.

    • Economic prosperity doesn't guarantee upward mobility for local kidsFocus on surrounding yourself with opportunity creators, acquiring versatile skills, prioritizing health and happiness for long-term prosperity and happiness.

      While cities like Charlotte may economically prosper, it doesn't necessarily translate to upward mobility for children growing up there. This is due to the importation of talent for high-paying jobs, leaving local kids without access to the same opportunities. Young adults trying to position themselves for prosperity and happiness should focus on surrounding themselves with opportunity-creating individuals, acquiring versatile skills, and prioritizing health and happiness directly. Professor Raj Chetty's research emphasizes the importance of these factors, and his work has significantly influenced discussions on economic opportunity. It's crucial to remember that prosperity and happiness extend beyond income, and focusing on personal passions can lead to long-term success. Additionally, acknowledging and managing personal struggles like anger and depression is essential for maintaining healthy relationships.

    • Focus on the positive aspects of a relationshipFocusing on the good in a relationship can lead to growth, success, and a stronger, healthier partnership.

      Focusing on the positive aspects of a relationship and celebrating what works can lead to an upward spiral of growth and success. It's natural to focus on the negative, but it's important to acknowledge and lean into the 90% of the relationship that is working. By doing so, individuals can create a virtuous cycle and build economic security and professional growth together. It's important to remember that every relationship will have its challenges, but the key is to focus on the good and continue to invest in the partnership. This approach can lead to a stronger, healthier, and more fulfilling relationship. As the speaker mentioned, they have seen this firsthand in their own experiences, raising healthy children and advancing professionally as a result of their partnership. So, instead of focusing on the 10% that isn't right, try to focus on the 90% that is and watch your relationship thrive.

    Recent Episodes from The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway

    Global Elections, Foreign Affairs, and National Security — with Admiral James Stavridis

    Global Elections, Foreign Affairs, and National Security — with Admiral James Stavridis
    Admiral James Stavridis, a retired four-star U.S. naval officer, and currently Partner and Vice Chairman of Global Affairs for The Carlyle Group, joins Scott to discuss foreign affairs and the wars in the Middle East and Ukraine.  Scott opens with his thoughts on Biden remaining in the race.  Algebra of Happiness: be open-minded.  Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice Buy "The Algebra of Wealth," out now. Follow the podcast across socials @profgpod: Instagram Threads X Reddit Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Why China Dominates the EV Market, How We Operate the Prof G Media Business, and How to “Rich”

    Why China Dominates the EV Market, How We Operate the Prof G Media Business, and How to “Rich”
    Scott speaks about the Chinese EV market, specifically how China has an advantage in the EV race due to costs. He then discusses Prof G Media’s business model and why he hasn’t moved the show behind a paywall. He wraps up with advice to someone who has suddenly come into a significant amount of wealth.  Music: https://www.davidcuttermusic.com / @dcuttermusic Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice Buy "The Algebra of Wealth," out now. Follow the podcast across socials @profgpod: Instagram Threads X Reddit Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Prof G Markets: How the Debate Moved the Market & Wall Street’s Take on Trump - with Josh Brown

    Prof G Markets: How the Debate Moved the Market & Wall Street’s Take on Trump - with Josh Brown
    Josh Brown, co-founder and CEO of Ritholtz Wealth Management, fills in for Scott to talk about how the markets reacted to the Presidential debate. Then Josh and Ed discuss how Trump and Biden presidencies could impact investors and Josh breaks down why he isn’t concerned about Trump’s potential tariffs on China.  Follow Prof G Markets: Apple Podcasts Spotify  Order "The Algebra of Wealth," out now Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice Follow the podcast across socials @profgpod: Instagram Threads X Reddit Follow Scott on Instagram Follow Ed on Instagram and X Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    First Time Founders with Ed Elson – This Founder Raised $900M to Power the Grid

    First Time Founders with Ed Elson – This Founder Raised $900M to Power the Grid
    Ed speaks with Mateo Jaramillo, Co-Founder and CEO of Form Energy, an energy storage and manufacturing company. They discuss how his experience at divinity school led him to start the company, what his experience working at Tesla was like, and why innovation in energy storage is so imperative to help save the planet. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    The Defense Industry, Greatness Is in the Agency of Others, and What to Do When Your Partner Makes More Money Than You

    The Defense Industry, Greatness Is in the Agency of Others, and What to Do When Your Partner Makes More Money Than You
    Scott speaks about the defense tech industry, specifically why he believes it is a great business. He then discusses how greatness is in the agency of others, particularly in the context of the workplace. He wraps up with advice to a listener about how to act if your partner makes more money than you.  Music: https://www.davidcuttermusic.com / @dcuttermusic Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice Buy "The Algebra of Wealth," out now. Follow the podcast across socials @profgpod: Instagram Threads X Reddit Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Prof G Markets: Rivian and Volkswagen’s New Partnership + Scott’s Tax Strategy

    Prof G Markets: Rivian and Volkswagen’s New Partnership + Scott’s Tax Strategy
    Scott shares his thoughts on Volkswagen’s investment in Rivian and why he thinks the electrical vehicle industry is entering the “Valley of Death”. Then Scott and Ed discuss JPMorgan’s tax management business and Scott breaks down different tax avoidance strategies he thinks more young people should know about.  Follow our new Prof G Markets feed: Apple Podcasts Spotify  Order "The Algebra of Wealth," out now Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice Follow the podcast across socials @profgpod: Instagram Threads X Reddit Follow Scott on Instagram Follow Ed on Instagram and X Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Buckets of Rich, Attracting Luck, and Maintaining Balance — with Jesse Itzler

    Buckets of Rich, Attracting Luck, and Maintaining Balance — with Jesse Itzler
    Jesse Itzler, a serial entrepreneur, a New York Times bestselling author, part-owner of the Atlanta Hawks, and an ultramarathon runner, joins Scott to discuss his approach to entrepreneurship, including how it aligns with his fitness journey, and the strategies he implements to maintain balance in his life.  Follow Jesse on Instagram, @jesseitzler.  Scott opens with his thoughts on the EU’s antitrust crusade against Big Tech and why he believes breakups oxygenate the economy.  Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice Buy "The Algebra of Wealth," out now. Follow the podcast across socials @profgpod: Instagram Threads X Reddit Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Elon Musk’s Pay Package, Scott’s Early Career Advice, and How Do I Find a Mentor?

    Elon Musk’s Pay Package, Scott’s Early Career Advice, and How Do I Find a Mentor?
    Scott speaks about Tesla, specifically Elon’s compensation package. He then gives advice to a recent college graduate who is moving to a new city for work. He wraps up with his thoughts on finding mentorship. Music: https://www.davidcuttermusic.com / @dcuttermusic Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice Buy "The Algebra of Wealth," out now. Follow the podcast across socials @profgpod: Instagram Threads X Reddit Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Related Episodes

    2016 Ballot Initiatives: 156 Measures In 35 States and D.C. (pt 3 of 3)

    2016 Ballot Initiatives: 156 Measures In 35 States and D.C. (pt 3 of 3)
    Mark Grimaldi, Executive Producer of The Leslie Marshall Show, guest hosts for Leslie during this hour of the show.

    He's joined by Political Strategist Brad Bannon and callers as they discuss some of the 156 ballot initiatives being voted on in 35 states and the District of Columbia on November 8th. This includes initiatives regarding education, minimum wage, and marijuana. They also discuss the ballot process in general.

    In case you missed them, here is a link to the first two parts of this three-part series: http://tinyurl.com/jdydb8q.

    Brad runs Bannon Communications Research, a polling, message development and media firm which helps labor unions, progressive issue groups and Democratic candidates win public affairs and political campaigns.
    He's also a senior adviser to and contributing editor for Tiller4you.com, the social media network for politics.
    He lectures in Political Science at Salem State University in Salem, Massachusetts.

    Brad's Twitter handle is @BradBannon and his website is www.BannonCR.com.

    Mark Grimaldi's Twitter handle is @MarkJGrimaldi.

    "Hot for Teacher"

    "Hot for Teacher"
    Kevin, Sully and Crystal discuss some interesting news topics as well as the recent "teacher strikes" in a few states across the country.

    A contestant from the show "The Bachelor" has a state banning him. The "Grumpy Cat" lady sues for using her kitty in ways she didn't want, and a few more fun topics.

    Then the crew gets into a teacher discussion over the recent strikes down south. They give their opinions and state some other facts surrounding the issue at hand. Unions, kids, among a bunch of other things affected by it.

    Always a fun time, and always real... we say what you're thinking and we'll probably go to hell for it.

    52 Weeks Later...

    52 Weeks Later...

    One year after the coronavirus pandemic turned life as we knew it upside down, veteran journalists David Mendel and Mike Xirinachs share its personal impact. What new routines are here to stay? Which old ones will return? Is the vaccine a miracle, or a celebration of science? What about our kids? There are lots of light-hearted moments, too, as the two discuss toilet paper, hand-shaking, distorted selfies and more.

    Episode 248: The Nobel Prize and the Minimum Wage

    Episode 248: The Nobel Prize and the Minimum Wage

    David Card recently won the Nobel Prize in economics for his contributions to the study of labor markets and natural experiments. Some minimum wage proponents confuse these excellent contributions with a particular application of his contributions to a study he conducted of a hike in New Jersey’s minimum wage. We discuss the flaws in that oft-cited study, and the distinction between his contributions and the study.

     

    Get Your Copy of Cooperation and Coercion Now!

    http://www.cooperationandcoercion.com

    Show Your Support for Words & Numbers at Patreon

    https://www.patreon.com/wordsandnumbers

    Quick Hits
    https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/11/buffalo-election-2021-results-india-walton-defeated.html

    https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/580322-democrats-brace-for-flood-of-retirements-after-virginia-rout

    https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2021/11/07/biden-approval-falls-38-midterms-loom-usa-today-suffolk-poll/6320098001/

    Foolishness of the Week
    https://abcnews4.com/news/nation-world/annual-microsoft-ignite-conference-entices-criticism-over-woke-introductions

    https://freebeacon.com/culture/microsoft-encourages-employees-to-state-race-gender-during-presentations/

    https://www.fox5ny.com/news/one-of-worlds-largest-investment-firms-will-need-permission-to-hire-white-men

    Topic of the Week

    https://davidcard.berkeley.edu/papers/njmin-aer.pdf

    https://www.econlib.org/no-krueger-didnt-prove-that-raising-the-minimum-wage-doesnt-increase-unemployment/

    Join the Conversation

    Words & Numbers Backstage

    https://www.facebook.com/groups/130029457649243/

    More James at Smoke & Stories
    https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLjILow4-ZJpBV-NnmSusZJ_vCuzKUJ4Ig

    Let Us Know What You Think

    mailto:wordsandnumberspodcast@gmail.com

    Antony Davies on Twitter

    https://twitter.com/antonydavies

    James R. Harrigan on Twitter
    https://twitter.com/JamesRHarrigan



    BHS - 7A – CA Proposition 1 | The Science of Reading Movement

    BHS - 7A – CA Proposition 1 | The Science of Reading Movement
    Gov. Newsom is urging California voters to support Proposition 1, why? Families’ lawsuit against Snapchat alleging the platform enables drug dealers allowed to move forward. California’s fast-food minimum wage hike is already getting people fired. An effort to overhaul how children learn to read, known as the science of reading movement, is sweeping the country.