Logo
    Search

    America’s First Ladies: Their Changing Role and Influence | Beyond the Scenes

    enSeptember 24, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Building community connections in uncertain timesNeighbor to Neighbor highlights the importance of forming bonds with neighbors and standing together during crises, while the influential roles of first ladies demonstrate their unique ability to shape policies and impact history.

      Community connections are essential in uncertain times. Neighbor to Neighbor, a California volunteer network, emphasizes the importance of building meaningful social bonds with those around us. Whether it's helping a neighbor in need or standing together during natural disasters, Neighbor to Neighbor empowers individuals to grow their community. On a different note, the influential roles of first ladies throughout history, despite not being elected, have significantly impacted the country. From Martha Washington to Hillary Clinton, first ladies have shaped policies and wielded power through their unique position as the president's spouse. In honor of Women's History Month, Beyond the Scenes podcast explores the powerful and often political partnerships between first ladies and their husbands.

    • The evolving role of the First LadyThe First Lady's role is complex and shaped by societal expectations, with some focusing on policy work and others on domestic duties. The role has evolved over time, with societal norms and expectations influencing its interpretation.

      The role of the First Lady is a complex and evolving one, shaped by the individual woman holding the position and influenced by societal expectations and gender norms. While some First Ladies, like Michelle Obama, have taken on significant initiatives and policy work, others, like Melania Trump, have focused more on domestic duties. The expectations placed on the First Lady can be unfair and sexist, and each woman must navigate the role in her own way. The constitution does not dictate the responsibilities of the First Lady, leaving room for interpretation and personal choice. The history of the role shows a shift in expectations and societal norms, with some women being criticized for overstepping boundaries and others for not doing enough. Ultimately, the First Lady's role is what she makes of it, and society must continue to evolve and adapt to allow women to embrace the position in a way that empowers and supports them.

    • The Evolution of the Role of the First Lady in the USFrom social causes to policy influencer, the role of the First Lady in the US has transformed over the years, with each First Lady leaving a unique impact on the country

      The role of the First Lady in the United States has evolved significantly over the years, from a more traditional role of championing social causes and supporting their husbands, to a more influential position as an adviser to the president. The First Lady's impact on policy in the country can be seen throughout history, with examples like Nancy Reagan's "Just Say No" campaign influencing her husband's war on drugs. From Eleanor Roosevelt's advocacy for women's rights and orphan children, to Harriet Lane Johnston taking on the role as a bachelor president's niece, each First Lady has made the role their own and left a lasting impact. Despite the changing times, the position of the First Lady remains an important one, and the expectations and responsibilities continue to evolve.

    • First Ladies' Influence on Policy and Public DiscourseFirst Ladies have shaped policy and public discourse through their unique position as advisors, advocates, and gatekeepers. Their influence extends beyond traditional domestic duties and has led to significant change.

      The role of a First Lady goes beyond the traditional domestic duties and extends to influencing policy and shaping the public discourse. From Michelle Obama's Let's Move campaign to Hillary Clinton's push for Ruth Bader Ginsburg's appointment to the Supreme Court, First Ladies have used their unique position to effect change. They act as advisors, advocates, and gatekeepers, controlling access to the president and shaping the political landscape. The idea that they wield power through "pillow talk" might seem frivolous, but their influence has been significant and often for the better. However, the question remains whether this unofficial power is healthy or detrimental. The recent push for Jill Biden to be paid for her role as First Lady highlights the need for acknowledging the value of this position and allowing women to continue their careers while fulfilling their duties as First Lady.

    • Historical Challenges Faced by First LadiesFirst Ladies have faced high expectations, criticism, and no pay while making significant contributions to their roles and the country.

      Throughout history, First Ladies have faced high expectations, criticism, and unrealistic standards while fulfilling their roles without pay. The discussion touched upon the stories of Dolley Madison, Eleanor Roosevelt, and the challenges they faced. Despite their significant contributions, it was impossible to cover every detail in a 10-minute podcast. Melania Trump's reluctance to take on the role and Ivanka Trump's potential alternative were also mentioned. The First Lady role comes with a prestigious title, but no salary, which raises questions about the fairness of the situation. The expectations and criticisms faced by First Ladies make their roles more complex and demanding than meets the eye.

    • Melania's Unconventional Start as First Lady and the Challenges Faced by First LadiesFirst ladies face intense scrutiny and pressure, which can be mentally challenging. Melania Trump initially refused to move to the White House, while Michelle Obama dealt with criticism over her image and expressions. Many first ladies seek support from close friends and family to navigate these challenges.

      Melania Trump defied expectations by initially refusing to move to the White House after her husband's election, leading to scrutiny from other first ladies and the public. This experience, along with the constant scrutiny and pressure faced by first ladies, can be mentally challenging. Michelle Obama, for instance, dealt with criticism over her image and facial expressions during her tenure. The role of a first lady is not an easy one, and many have turned to their close friends and family for support. The scrutiny faced by first ladies, from the media and the public, can be intense, and some have dealt with it in unhealthy ways. Despite the challenges, Michelle Obama managed to embrace her role and inspire the nation with her speeches and initiatives.

    • Media scrutiny of first ladies' fashionFirst ladies' fashion choices have long been a subject of media fascination and scrutiny. Due to their limited ability to express political views openly, their clothing becomes a means of making statements. From Hillary Clinton's pantsuits to Michelle Obama's sleeveless dresses, fashion choices have shaped societal norms and expectations.

      There exists a significant double standard in how the media covers and scrutinizes the fashion choices of liberal and conservative first ladies. From Michelle Obama's arms to Melania Trump's jacket, the public's fascination with what first ladies wear has been a long-standing tradition. This scrutiny often stems from the inability of first ladies to express their political views openly, leaving their fashion choices as the only means of making a statement. Hillary Clinton's pantsuit during her campaign is a prime example of this. The discussion also highlighted the evolution of first ladies' fashion, from Jackie Kennedy's iconic Chanel suits to Michelle Obama's sleeveless dresses, and how these choices have shaped societal norms and expectations. Ultimately, the media's focus on first ladies' fashion can be seen as a reflection of the political climate and societal values of the time.

    • The Role of the First Lady and Gender ExpectationsThe First Lady's role continues to face intense scrutiny and gender expectations, with Melania Trump's actions and fashion choices being a recent example. This scrutiny raises questions about gender norms and progress towards equality.

      The role of the First Lady continues to be subjected to intense scrutiny and gender expectations, with Melania Trump's actions and fashion choices being a recent example. The discussion highlighted how women in this position are held to a high standard, with even small deviations from societal norms leading to significant criticism and media attention. The scrutiny raises questions about gender expectations and the progress made towards gender equality, particularly in the context of the White House. The balance between informing the audience and adding humor to historical segments is a challenge, and the team at the show navigates this by providing writers with multiple options and allowing them to choose the one with the best potential for humor. The discussion also touched upon the comparison between the White House and the Kardashians as two influential entities in shaping fashion trends.

    • Navigating the Challenges of Being a First LadyA successful first lady is one who can connect with the American people despite media scrutiny and public perception challenges.

      The role of a first lady is often defined by public perception and the ability to connect with people on a human level. As seen in the example of Jill Biden's failed attempt to break a champagne bottle during a plane christening ceremony, the media can often focus on small moments and exaggerate them, making it difficult for first ladies to be seen as authentic human beings. Kate, an expert on first ladies, believes that a successful first lady is one who can navigate these challenges and make a positive impact on the country. Jeff, without a bestselling book to his name, offers his perspective as an observer. He notes that while the role of a president is often judged based on policies and their implementation, the role of a first lady is more about public perception and the ability to connect with the American people. Jill Biden, as the current first lady, is still in the process of defining her role and making her mark. Only time will tell how history will view her tenure.

    • The Role of the First Lady EvolvesMichelle Obama brought relatability, Hillary Clinton blazed trails, Jill Biden works outside White House, Doug Emhoff as First Gentleman raises questions about gender norms

      The role of the First Lady has evolved over time, with each occupant contributing to moving the role forward, albeit incrementally. Michelle Obama's relatability and warmth, Hillary Clinton's trailblazing political career, and Jill Biden's employment outside the White House are just a few examples of how the role has shifted. The upcoming presence of the first gentleman, Doug Emhoff, in the White House, raises interesting questions about gender dynamics and expectations within the household. As more women enter politics, it will be intriguing to observe how the roles and responsibilities of the First Lady and First Gentleman will continue to evolve and potentially challenge traditional gender norms.

    • The role of the second gentleman is shifting gender expectationsDoug Emhoff embraces a nurturing role, allowing Kamala Harris to lead, contrasting past expectations of tough, macho first gentlemen, while first ladies' relationships are less explored and have minimal impact on the public's perception of the administration.

      The role of the second gentleman, such as Doug Emhoff, is shifting the expectations of traditional gender roles in the White House. Unlike the past, where the first gentleman was expected to be a tough, macho figure, Emhoff is embracing a more nurturing and supportive role, allowing Kamala Harris to be the powerful figure in their relationship. The dynamic between first ladies, on the other hand, is less explored. While there have been friendly interactions between former first ladies like Laura Bush and Michelle Obama, they don't have a close relationship or regular communication. The absence of this connection during the transition between Melania Trump and Jill Biden added to the tension and negativity between the Trump and Obama administrations. Overall, the evolving roles of the second gentleman and the complex dynamics between first ladies highlight the importance of emotional intelligence and support in leadership.

    • First Ladies' Unconventional AchievementsMichelle Obama and Hillary Clinton won Grammys for their memoirs and audiobooks, while Nancy Reagan sought advice from an astrologer to influence her husband's schedule.

      First ladies have made significant accomplishments beyond their traditional roles. Michelle Obama holds the record for being the most recent first lady to win a Grammy, for her memoir "Becoming," while Hillary Clinton won in 1997 for her audiobook "It Takes A Village." Nancy Reagan is known for seeking advice from an astrologer during her husband's presidency, using the astrologer's predictions to control the president's schedule and keep him safe following an assassination attempt. These first ladies have made history by expanding their influence and achieving notable accomplishments.

    Recent Episodes from The Daily Show: Ears Edition

    Biden 2024: It Is What It Is? | The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart

    Biden 2024: It Is What It Is? | The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart

    Jon Stewart returns with another episode of The Weekly Show, his podcast featuring in-depth conversations with special guests that explore the biggest threats to our democracy. In this episode, Jon addresses President Biden’s insistence on running for re-election. Guests Jon Favreau and Tommy Vietor, Founders of Crooked Media, hosts of Pod Save America and Authors of Democracy or else: How to Save America in 10 Easy Steps, as well as Bakari Sellers, CNN political commentator and Author of The Moment, join to hash out the best path forward for Democrats to defeat Trump this election and save democracy. Catch new episodes of The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart every Thursday, wherever you get your podcasts.

    Follow The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart on social media for more: 

    > YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@weeklyshowpodcast
    > Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/weeklyshowpodcast
    > TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@weeklyshowpodcast 

    > X: https://x.com/weeklyshowpod

     

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    George Clooney Wants Biden To Step Down | Elizabeth Dias & Lisa Lerer

    George Clooney Wants Biden To Step Down | Elizabeth Dias & Lisa Lerer

    Desi Lydic and Jordan Klepper cover the latest news surrounding the Biden campaign, including a call from George Clooney for Biden to step down. Plus, they tackle Trump's latest rally ramblings. Trump has been a big proponent of the Taiwan-based electronic manufacturer Foxconn's opening of a massive factory in Wisconsin, promising thousands of new jobs. But it seems like the people of Wisconsin have been Fox-conned. Ronny Chieng investigates. Also, New York Times reporters Elizabeth Dias & Lisa Lerer sit down with Desi & Jordan to talk about their new book, “The Fall of Roe: The Rise of a New America.” 

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Desi Lydic & Jordan Klepper Unpack Trump's Confusing Project 2025 Response | Aasif Mandvi

    Desi Lydic & Jordan Klepper Unpack Trump's Confusing Project 2025 Response | Aasif Mandvi

    Desi Lydic & Jordan Klepper cover Trump’s contradictory tweet about Project 2025, President Biden’s Parkinson’s panic, and Gwyneth Paltrow’s shitty house guest. Michael Kosta also helps Desi & Jordan get to the bottom of all of Biden’s medical house calls. Josh Johnson sat down with a panel of Black voters to ask, "Do we f**k with Trump?" Plus, former Daily Show correspondent and star of Paramount Plus’ “Evil” Aasif Mandvi reminisces with Desi and Jordan about some of his most memorable field pieces, from asking former Florida governor Rick Scott for a urine test, to nearly being arrested in a two-headed fish costume.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Jon Stewart Examines Biden’s Future Amidst Calls For Him to Drop Out | A.J. Jacobs

    Jon Stewart Examines Biden’s Future Amidst Calls For Him to Drop Out | A.J. Jacobs

    Jon Stewart digs into the backlash to America’s bed-wetting panic over Biden’s incoherence, some of the president’s recent slip-ups, the future of the Democratic candidate, and Biden’s promise in an ABC interview with George Stephanopoulos to give “fighting fascism” his all. Also, journalist and best-selling author A.J. Jacobs joins Jon to discuss his new book “The Year of Living Constitutionally,” which addresses a timely question: What does the Constitution actually say?

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Meet The Daily Show Dogs | Behind the Show

    Meet The Daily Show Dogs | Behind the Show

    Daily Show dog celebs Walter and Riot steal the spotlight on this week's episode hosted by Michael Kosta, alongside showrunner Jen Flanz and producer Jocelyn Conn. Kosta, Jen, and Jocelyn discuss how TDS became the most dog-friendly show in late night and how their lovable canine colleagues inspired "Indogcision 2024: Rescuing Democracy," an event taking place at the RNC and DNC that will combine dog adoption and voter registration.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    ‘Quon Chops It Up with Nathan Wade | George Conway Discusses Trump’s Legal Woes

    ‘Quon Chops It Up with Nathan Wade | George Conway Discusses Trump’s Legal Woes

    ‘Quon (Marlon Wayans) has a sit-down with former Trump prosecutor, Nathan Wade, to hear more about his affair with Fani Willis and advice for the Black men and haters who can’t get laid. Plus, conservative attorney, George Conway, sits with Ronny Chieng to discuss how Trump turned him off of the Republican party and offers advice to voters in the upcoming election.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Related Episodes

    Like a Circle in a Spiral, Part 2

    Like a Circle in a Spiral, Part 2

    You might consider spinning around in a circle either great fun or a one-way ticket to barf town, but spinning and whirling are also tied to childhood development, artistic expression and the pursuit of meditative states. Join Robert and Joe as they explore the spin on Stuff to Blow Your Mind.

    Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    The Many Roles of Lady Bird Johnson with Julia Sweig

    The Many Roles of Lady Bird Johnson with Julia Sweig
    In today’s episode, Sharon talks with author Julia Sweig about her newest book, Lady Bird Johnson: Hiding in Plain Sight. The research and writing took Julia over six years, as she meticulously poured over the details of not only Lady Bird’s life, but also the 1960s era and the state of the nation at the time. Lady Bird, a whip-smart Southern woman, met Lindon Johnson in Austin, Texas where he proposed to her at the end of their first date (she said no!). Eventually, the pair married and moved to Washington DC. As LBJ’s political career progressed, Lady Bird’s influence spread; she was a woman who showed up. Listen to learn more about Lady Bird: her real first name, the complexities of her marriage to LBJ, her relationship with the Kennedys, her environmentalism, and her propensity to document her life, from the major moments down to the mundane details.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Karen Tumulty: The Sununu Effect in New Hampshire

    Karen Tumulty: The Sununu Effect in New Hampshire
    New Hampshire voters are famously contrarian, and the non-MAGA set is showing up for Haley and Christie ahead of the first-in-the-nation primary. Plus, a Rosalynn Carter appreciation, and the 'Lord of the Flies' vibe in the House. Karen Tumulty joins Charlie Sykes from New Hampshire.

    show notes:

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/11/20/rosalynn-carter-place-in-history/ 

    Jackie O: Public, Private, Secret with J. Randy Taraborrelli

    Jackie O: Public, Private, Secret with J. Randy Taraborrelli

    Today, on Here’s Where It Gets Interesting, Sharon connects with journalist and celebrity biographer, J. Randy Taraborrelli, to chat about his new book “Jackie: Public, Private, Secret.” In his book, he paints a portrait of the lesser known parts of the iconic life of Jackie Kennedy Onassis. We all know public details of her time as First Lady in the White House, and recall the historic imagery of her wearing a pink Chanel suit with the matching pink hat on the day President Kennedy was assassinated. But with only a few years spent in the White House, what fabric makes the full life of this beloved First Lady? This conversation brings to light the story of a woman’s total lived experience in a way that is surprising, complex, and distinctive. 


    Special thanks to our guest, J. Randy Taraborrelli, for joining us today.


    Host/Executive Producer: Sharon McMahon

    Guest: J. Randy Taraborrelli

    Audio Producer: Jenny Snyder



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Mavericks & Legends: Mary Todd Lincoln

    Mavericks & Legends: Mary Todd Lincoln

    This week is sponsored by Madison Reed. Find your perfect shade and start your hair transformation at https://madison-reed.com/womannica.

    Become a Womanniac!: https://glow.fm/womannica

    Every weekday, listeners explore the trials, tragedies, and triumphs of groundbreaking women throughout history who have dramatically shaped the world around us. In each 5 minute episode, we’ll dive into the story behind one woman listeners may or may not know -- but definitely should. These diverse women from across space and time are grouped into easily accessible and engaging monthly themes like Pioneers, Dreamers, Villainesses, STEMinists, Warriors & Social Justice Warriors, and many more. Encyclopedia Womannica is hosted by WMN co-founder and award-winning journalist Jenny Kaplan. The bite-sized episodes pack painstakingly researched content into fun, entertaining, and addictive daily adventures.

    Encyclopedia Womannica was created by Liz Kaplan and Jenny Kaplan, executive produced by Jenny Kaplan, and produced by Liz Smith, Cinthia Pimentel, Grace Lynch, and Maddy Foley. Special thanks to Shira Atkins, Edie Allard, and Luisa Garbowit. Theme music by Andi Kristins. 

    Follow Wonder Media Network:

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.